Haunted Mansion Mini Mafia - Page 2

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 09:23 GMT

#473

EBWOP:

On November 26 2015 18:14 Tictock wrote:

Nowhere in his filter do I see a real read from Sn0, just a few suggestions that he's willing to lynch people, but only to "develop reads"

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 09:51 GMT

#475

I'm not really seeing why people are voting for OO either.

I take it most of it was his reaction to SL's "role hunting"?

Seems pretty NAI to me, obvious thing for either alignment to question and... I'm told he's the One...

I feel like he's taking his own approach to the game, and thinking things through himself.

On November 25 2015 09:08 ObviousOne wrote:
the outing scenario, taken alone:

i take fefe's self-outing to mean that he's town and he wants to win the game, and that he believes his normal town behaviour when not associated with his name will lead to being lynched, therefore he can be himself from the beginning. would be hella easy if he rolled mafia to just go along with staying closeted about his identity and doing literally anything else.

that said, i don't think it's really worth using the situation to judge whether or not he's town in a vacuum so just see where he goes from here

And his reads aren't just rehashing what's been said.

On November 26 2015 05:23 ObviousOne wrote:
TicTock - last sentence as of this post is "imma play this slow" no imminent urge to find mafia
Onegu - disavows responsibility to be proactive
boxerfred - looks like participation for participation's sake so far
sicklucker - entirety of filter is regarding FF smurfing

preliminary scum pool by poe via feels and what i can remember of those not listed here, WIP

Not really enough for me to townread him, but I'm not really seeing and mafia motivation behind his posts.

Maybe there's something I'm missing, but I wont be lynching him.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 10:06 GMT

#476

Going to go distract myself with other stuff for a bit, but what do people think of GB?

I'm not sure his pushing to keep the game moving is town motivated, I get more of a trying to stir up trouble vibe from what he's doing.

In particular, this post felt like he was trying a bit too hard to make such a small point seem scummy.

On November 25 2015 12:55 GlowingBear wrote:

Show nested quote +

Nah, FF. He clearly agrees with SL. It's not a "I understand you, but..."

Let me expand my suspicions on this post.

If I see somethig that is NAI, whenever someone says it is suspicious, I will tell them that it's NAI. Whenever I see something that I find suspicious and someone say its suspicious, I will simply agree with it.

I don't understand how can someone agree on a suspicion but reach the conclusion that that is NAI. His thought process is disconnected with his conclusion. In other words, it just sounds that he tried to fake putting thoughts on it when he was really just... Posting.

Also, if this is slightly suspicious, why classifying it as NAI now instead of pushing it further, especially on the early phase of the game when usually we have NOTHING to pursue?

Do you understsnd what I'm trying to say?

For some reason I also thought it was weird for him to get all serious so early and ask people to focus on his reads post. Just felt a little unnecessary? idk I'm probably just picking at nits on this point.

GB where are your reads at now? I feel like you are overly focused on a few people.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 10:29 GMT

#479

D1 policy lynch on Onegu?

bleh

next plz

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 10:47 GMT

#482

On November 26 2015 19:32 marvellosity wrote:
Tictock - I think GB is fine, you're kinda picking at him for being GB

OMGUS might also be a factor as well, it's true.

I tend to play by my gut often D1 and GB does not agree with it right now.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 11:06 GMT

#490

@ #483

Yea, I might be taking back my "wont lynch" on OO

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 11:08 GMT

#492

Ohh Dreamhack!

I'm about to start cooking some Baklava, also with my eyes open

nxt

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 11:10 GMT

#494

Why Onegu? that's what I want to know...

Or do you just plan to make the game more active by lynching the least actives in order?

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 11:14 GMT

#498

Also FF, I'm onto you

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 11:19 GMT

#502

On November 26 2015 20:13 ObviousOne wrote:

Show nested quote +

he wanted to be asked questions, that's the last we heard of him. are you seeing anything alignment indicative in his filter? i'm going to answer for you: no. that always bothers me. i'm always willing to lynch inactives on d1 especially if the impetus of an impending lynch gets them to a readable state.

You are 100% correct.

However I'm not a big fan of coin flipping D1, I'd rather lynch into people who have done some scummy things.

Anyways get yourself some sleep, but I hope you look into some of the other people on that list of yours and see if there aren't better reasons to lynch someone than not being able to read them.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 11:30 GMT

#504

Only because of personality/meta reason I suppose?

I expect this play from Onegu but Vivax's feels off. I've also seen Vivax be really uncomfortable as scum whereas Onegu tends to love it.

Well there's another reason but I'd rather not suggest stuff for scum to play off of

Also Vivax looks like he's hopping on a wagon while going "oh look mindmeld with GB, wow!"

Onegu throwing out random vote on Koshi without any real push isn't any better I suppose, but it doesn't suggest any scum motivation to me

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 12:22 GMT

#506

Where are you at with this game Marv?

You've only got ~9 hrs left on that fence.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 12:28 GMT

#508

Onegu, which is the better flavor?

Pistachio

or

Strawberry

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 12:34 GMT

#513

You answered

On November 26 2015 21:31 Onegu wrote:

Show nested quote +

Strawberry

I refuse to eat anything green, and they fucking die Pistachio's green and that is just against my code.

Which is the incorrect answer, however you have solid reasons. Partial credit, you pass.

However,

I refuse to eat anything green

Sounds very unhealthy

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 12:36 GMT

#514

On November 26 2015 21:32 Onegu wrote:
But the correct answer is vanilla

Actually it was Spumoni

Still, thanks for playing!

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 12:54 GMT

#518

On November 26 2015 21:45 sicklucker wrote:

Show nested quote +

On November 26 2015 16:49 Tictock wrote:
I have returned.

Sorry boys had some last min stuff come up getting prepared for family to come over tomorrow.

Anyways, I'm back and around till closer to EoD when people start showing up.

I'm not fully caught up but I read a little at work earlier and saw GB and Vivax pushing me for this post.

On November 25 2015 09:04 Tictock wrote:

On November 25 2015 08:48 sicklucker wrote:

On November 25 2015 08:46 Chromatically wrote:

On November 25 2015 08:43 sicklucker wrote:

On November 25 2015 08:09 Chromatically wrote:
I'm more interested in if he thinks FF is mafia for that?

ya probably. Hes afraid he will be outed and coming clean will gain him town cred. Theres no way ff smurfed to reveal himself the 80% of the time he rolled town. It makes no sense...

Espiecally since I have never seen him get mafia in like 15 games with him...

lynch ff for sanity

Hmm, I had the opposite reaction. Why would he be afraid of being outed as a smurf?

Ok so ff has a very high perecentage of rolling town. Town is like 80% of the players. Why would he make a smurf when hes only getting mafia like 23% of the time or whatever. Especially when he historically never gets mafia anyway..

lol..

Hmm?

You might have a point here, especially revealing so early before he could even see the affects of smurfing.

FF tends to play fairly lazily the first few days and picks it up later. Maybe he rolled mafia and was worried people would push him early on?

Course all of this is assuming it's actually FF and not someone trying to mind game us early... that's pretty tinfoily though and would be a pretty silly play.

Gunna put this down as slightly suspect but possibly NAI for now.

I didn't state my conclusion as well as I should have I guess. What I was saying is that FF dropping his smurf is weird (SL had a point on that) but that trying to get a read out of that steaming pile of WIFOM is impossible.

Anyways I got some time so I'm just gunna reread this game since it's only 24 pgs. I only recall having vague townfeels on Koshi and SL when I left off.

you acualy didnt say that tho. all you said was "if hes not really ff then its not valid" you 100% said my shit was valid nice backtrack to popular thread sentiment... hum

It's not a backtrack, what?

In the first post I wrote

Gunna put this down as slightly suspect but possibly NAI for now.

which was a very poor way of stating my conclusion

FF dropping his smurf is weird but that trying to get a read out of that steaming pile of WIFOM is impossible.

Anyways I'm fairly convinced he's town now.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 13:00 GMT

#521

On November 26 2015 21:55 marvellosity wrote:
fairly convinced why?

Whats your read on FF?

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

November 26 2015 13:17 GMT

#528

Sigh, fine.

FF's pushing things from multiple perspectives and asking people to further their reads.

On November 25 2015 12:27 ANickelDrink wrote:
like if it's not alignment indicative then he can't really push the discussion anywhere since there's nowhere for it to go.

If he had just said "I see what you mean but..." instead of "You have a point" it would be saying the same thing, no?

besides he actually said

Show nested quote +

On November 26 2015 07:59 ANickelDrink wrote:

Show nested quote +

On November 26 2015 04:04 boxerfred wrote:

On November 25 2015 11:53 Fecalfeast wrote:

On November 25 2015 11:43 GlowingBear wrote:

On November 25 2015 11:39 ANickelDrink wrote:

On November 25 2015 11:35 Koshi wrote:
I wonder where Diablo II sits on my best games I played list. Under Warcraft III, C& C: Red alert, WoW, Dota. Somewhere there?

I played Diablo II so many hours. I'm relentlessly biased toward that game. Including LoD I'd put it in my top 3 easily up there with brood war and Heroes of newerth.

+ Show Spoiler +

HoN with a playerbase = best MOBA

LOL No.

Btw FF can you post with your original account just to make sure you are FF?

oh no oops wrong accouuuunntttt

was just building up my great theory how you're fakeclaiming being FF. neat, right?

anyone still being off-topic (like talking about D3 and shit) is scummy in my eyes.

koshi feels exactly like I got to know him in the banlist - spammy and yolo'y (does that even exist) so town

On November 25 2015 12:37 Chromatically wrote:

On November 25 2015 11:30 GlowingBear wrote:
Cool, some weak early reads:

Koshi looks townie for his tone. Especially when he makes the post of the town pyramid and the following one.

Chrom looks townie for thinking critically about the game.

SL looks scummy for this hard push on FF on a matter that isn't really alignment indicative.

Tictock looks scummy for commenting that SL may have a point but concluding that FF's thing isn't alignment indicative. If SL does have a point then it is alignment indicative. If it isn't alignment indicative, SL doesn't have a point. Therefore you just look you're posting to look contributive while actually being fluffy and pushing the matter nowhere

sicklucker I'm not sure about. I agree he could be mafia for his push over something which I agree wasn't alignment indicative, but I liked that he didn't back down about it when he came under pressure.

Ticktock I agree with your point, plus he just kind of came in and posted those non-opinions on FF and then peaced out.

Koshi I don't have a read on.

Let me expand on what I mean about OO:

On November 25 2015 07:58 ObviousOne wrote:

On November 25 2015 07:57 sicklucker wrote:
And yes i am role hunting

explain

On November 25 2015 08:07 ObviousOne wrote:
how can you be rolehunting when the op says everyone is vanilla?

On November 25 2015 08:10 ObviousOne wrote:
tbh it looks to me like you either a) lied about rolehunting when you meant smurfhunting and then stuck to your lie for whatever reason or b) didn't read the setup or c) you're mafia and just hinted at the hidden mechanic

sicklucker posts his stuff about FF's claim being weird and also makes a comment about rolehunting. OO jumps on the "rolehunting" part of it, which is the part that looks weird and is easy to jump on as mafia (I was interested in his read on FF from it). The third post is the one I particularly didn't like. The whole post says nothing at all (no conclusion or any point for the post), it seems like it's just a poor attempt to explain why he jumped on the rolehunting comment when it clearly didn't mean much.

this post feels totally forced and Im not sure if i like it.

blabla ask me questions im in thread although tired af

Couple questions, who is still being fluffy, or was when you made this post? I'd like to see who you're scumming based on the bolded.

Can you elaborate on what chrome's post is lacking or containing to make it seem forced to you?

On November 26 2015 09:01 ANickelDrink wrote:

Show nested quote +

Any updates on this? Seems like a pretty weird time for a 'preliminary poe scum pool' and you leave out at least two people with one page filters when everyone on your 4 person list's reason is 'not participating to my/their own standards'

Pushes his own reads over thread sentiment

On November 26 2015 09:02 ANickelDrink wrote:
I think I prefer an OO lynch over tictock if I had to pick right now

The entire interaction he had with Koshi on pg 20 I referenced earlier felt really towny. Whole page reads to me like 2 townies hashing out their reads.

In general whole tone is lighthearted and thoughtful. He's not pushing any strong agenda and is willing to rethink reads and talk things out.

If we must keep talking about the smurf I liked his response/reasoning

On November 26 2015 10:33 ANickelDrink wrote:
I wanted to be able to play an active game as either alignment without being scumread for it. I've been getting more into my conversational stride and I know people would scumread me for being active.

Once I started writing my entry post I realized that I was going to have to be conscious of how I post since I personally think I have a... unique posting style on top of the fact that I pretty much only post while baked or while at work.

I decided that it wasn't worth the effort.

So there's a ton of towny things going on in his filter that easily outweigh something that seems strange but I have no way of getting a read off of.