| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
On November 19 2015 08:33 Fecalfeast wrote: Ritoky is correct. Even if the claim feels like buttcheeks it's still uncc'd The only other thing I can think of is wait one cycle and if she is still alive lynch her. I don't understand how or why she isn't moving forward in her world view. Anyways looking at other people in the meantime since we don't win until all three are dead. ##unvote fuck this is irritating. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
On November 19 2015 08:39 Fecalfeast wrote: 1. Unless someone claims a vig shot on Geript, he was the only one adamant about trfel being scum and was getting upset that nobody listened to him. 2. His day 1 suspicions from his filter: VE, Moose, Scott, Me. I know 3/4 of those are town 100% while moose is showing some towny play since yesterday. 3. Totally willing to vote an uncc'd blue because she's martyring. you realise that #1 and most of #2 also apply to Breshke right? A thought to consider if Trfel is town. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
"alright, Fecalfeast isn't vig, he could be scum because of X," or "if fecalfast is town and if some person Y is vig" then I'm down to this method, etc. even in your world you aren't moving town forward also post 1129, Trfel is using the word malicious as in mafia agenda. Not that you were insulting, but your play is mafia play. now I have time to sit down, I will look into eversince, and do the best I can here. at least before 2am. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
On November 19 2015 09:48 disformation wrote: Currently my official read on her is: wtf bananaboat. Which is like 3rd party, but slightly tastier and floating on water. Or rather uncced vet with plays that make no sense for either town nor scum. But I might look at it again, if I am able to figure out what the correct bait for a wtf bananaboat is. as glowingbear told me in my newbie 13 game, scum play to survive. even if we go through a cycle, say we fuck up again and mislynch, night phase passes and she's not taken out, if she gets one mislynch out of that, she's gotten her team closer to victory. 2 mislynches left in that scenario. alright now eversince. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
from newbie 13, I was caught out as mafia on voting analysis. I am decently sure the way moosy's been playing he is probably town now. If that's the case, when both wagons are town, there's a decent shot to look at people who didn't give a shit about the lynch or who got lynched or for players that can hide it well, who had a "fake" reaction to try and get one player lynched over another or a bad reason given read progression. now farah's been cited for this, but who else would this apply? there were some isolated voters obviously and those people will always come into question but two of these are known town now. and eversince, who knows. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
On November 19 2015 10:21 disformation wrote: leaving Breshke: he did vote MD around 5h15 b4 deadline and went to bed. If I look at my huge ass post again (http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/497023-newbie-student-mafia-xvii-fullmetal-edition?page=48#948), that starts considering votes from 7h before deadline to deadline, I think this can still be considered early. Next post from Breshke is well into N1. I also don't think that all the mafia are on the scott train. Breshke is Australian so timing might be NAI as he might not have had a choice. I'd focus more on the reasoning and not so much the timing. deadline for me is 8pm. aus has 3 timezones, anywhere from 8-10 hours ahead of me. that would put his deadline at anywhere from 4-6am. I don't know about you but if I was a student (which he said pre-game) and had day classes I highly doubt he could stay up until "close enough" to end of cycle. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
| ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
On November 19 2015 10:37 Trfel wrote: How did you arrive at FarahBlackwing being town? I think I know why he said that but I'll let him explain. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
| ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
post 253 - I didn't take this seriously. thought she was just trying to bullshit and say stuff as an opening salve. Now as Shining and VE and such are going on page 14, she isn't posting. Could be health, could be lying low. 284 - saw nothing wrong with this post, could be interpreted as poking a hole into the arguement. 293 - responded regarding health, in of itself NAI 308 - On November 16 2015 06:21 Eversince wrote: I mentioned in my earlier post, Viscera is null. He sheeped a random vote I made an hour into this game. If he does squat else followin', I'll take issue. Right now I've already mentioned that, while currently not useful, his post don't seem to push him either way. I haven't,and won't until I get a much better base on people, use meta. I do assume that a WHOLE BUNCH of people do. I've read a number of games on this site. I don't understand everything, but under the assumption that I found him in a few old games on the Team Liquid database, he is one who uses meta. On those standards, he's not done anything to make him tilt scales. Time will tell... strange read on VE not taking a side on his tone, could be trying to avoid confrontation? not sure, but he was town and it's not like she pushed him either. quips about meta are not alignment indicative, typical newbie saying fuck the majority. 312 - nothing really relevant to this game if I read it right, same concern I had as breshke earlier, not really commenting on anything relevant to the game as it goes on. 322 and 328 - I could see this as either alignment | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
I'd give an overall scumlean, but very well could be wrong here. back to work. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
Compared to Trfel, he seems less towny although I couldn't initially grasp from ritoky as for why he'd lynch Trfel over Breshke aside from him wanting to lynch Farah whose claim was scummy when it was made. I could understand Fecalfeast's vote on him for that reason although I mentioned that Breshke, the same thing mostly applies except the claim analysis. geript tried to get Breshke lynched d1 and now that we know geript is town and considering his type of read and my initial reservation on Breshke (talking around geript/VE), and geripts history of 30 games, I'm going to assume the meta read is more or less accurate or at the very least we know it was an honest thought from him. not to mention scum really fall off late game, and Breshke's last post irrespective of timezone was.... ....16 hours ago.... I'm looking at Breshke's posts from 1009 and onwards. He's saying disformation and farah are both scum. But they are both scumreading each other. Learnt the hard way from newbie 14 that there was some double bussing going on. there's no explaiantion from Breshke as to why he thinks they are on after each other and disformation has since been a bit more towny. If Farah's claim was true, and without a counterclaim, we have to proceed as if it is true, it was a poor decision, but at least Damdred has a strategy/conditions for when/if/how the vig should claim. I understand it. and this go? Breshke's pushes are a LOT weaker than round 1. he's not as invested in either of them. I think what trfel said is valid, let the moderators deal with Eversince and lynch Breshke unless there is a mechanical reason we have to deal with her now. (do we know if mods modkill or replace or does that even matter? no idea how that shit works.) | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
On October 21 2015 18:06 Tictock wrote: Activity: You must make at least Five posts in this thread per day/night cycle and vote every day while you are alive. Roughly speaking, this equates to a bare minimum of one post per 10 hours. If you fail to do so, you will be modkilled or replaced. Replacements This game uses replacements. Players who are inactive may be replaced by other players. well this isn't terribly clear. 10 players left, 7 of which are town 7:3 - what we have now 6:3 - mislynch 5:3 - possible modkill (???) 4:3 - nightkill Well fuck this. I'd like to lynch Breshke but we might actually have to go for the policy lynch if I'm counting this right. There is one replacement though, but I can't predict what the mods are going to do based on the rules so if someone more experienced can suggest the way to go here or what they normally do that might help tremendously. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
as for geript, to be honest....he was town but he could be wrong on people. the reason I suggested his read on Breshke was good is because Breshke's behaviour currently supports what he stated day 1 and it matched my initial concern on Breshke (avoiding the important issues). | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
| ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
On November 19 2015 22:44 Damdred wrote: Basically thinking would scum trfel get butt hurt the game really didn't listen to him about Scott and partially throw a small tantrum to get people on Scott? Tgere is unflippwd association as breshke being scum heavily implies trfel is as well. Also its worth thinking about where is the waffle in truffles play? Hard to say he's been really sure about everything all game. I'm hoping he's the big trying to make a play Trfel could be mafia based on the so-called WIFOM/NK analysis that rsoultin discussed in newbie 14. But how is there an associative read between Breshke and Trfel? or do you simply mean the fact Trfel's lynching Scott saved Breshke? your first sentence implies that Trfel was being too emotional to be scum, but if there is another post after the lynch that indicates Trfel by association, where is it? nothing has jumped out at me other than the push on Scott, but geript implied (by meta, which again I disregarded because well....it was meta) that Trfel should have known better - he used his town meta to indicate this as Scott's scum meta to get him lynched. Are you experienced enough to make this call? the post in question was post 918 and 925 On November 18 2015 14:39 geript wrote: All association? No. I quite frankly referred to this post + Show Spoiler + On November 17 2015 14:42 scott31337 wrote: I apologize for my last post - I got enough energy to notepad. I'm town. Weak. This is the Breshke I know I thought from his first post - He's thinking about the game and townie thoughts. arr.. And my virtual townleans have not said anything (Geript, etc.) So I think I'm fooled at least by one. I'm going to sleep - at Page 30 of Ritoky's wall of text. I've had a lot to drink and calling it a night. I'll continue from there. Trfel's been trying but like I said - could be his scummy cases he's done it before Fuck Moosy and his lazy ass town game We will not have it. Geript fell the fuck off once he got townleaned NM has been playing his towngame I'll be up in about 12 hours and bitch that I'm not online and posting. Well suck it I was busy helping out my cousin that I just found out had MS. What the fuck is to respond to here that wasn't already in my summary. I noted that the above quoted scott post was decent which negates the critical thinking thing. Scott's activity being awful is by no means alignment indicative. Trfel's jumping on him for 1 post that's lacked critical thinking. On that run Trfel should absolutely be lynched because Trfel hasn't had 1 good post that requires actual thought. Trfel is literally just picking at minor things that don't matter and aren't alignment indicative. Scott not taking a stance on Trfel is literally irrelevant. Trfel's "case" on scott isn't a case. It's not even a set of good points against scott. Trfel should 100% be shot tonight period. On November 18 2015 14:46 geript wrote: My points on Breshke covered this entirely. Breshke should not be read on his reads. It's about how he interacts with and acts in response to what's happening in the thread. Him blandly asking questions that go no where and lead to no conclusions is part of his scum meta. So what Trfel has pointed towards is specifically his scum meta and Trfel is trying to paint him town for it. Critical questions to me (1) did Trfel misrepresent Scott's meta? he has 18 games played in the database. how many of these does he have with Scott? might be time to do some digging and see whether this was below expectations. I have never played with Trfel, and only 2 games with Scott but I can try and take an educated guess if I can count. (2) did Trfel misrepresent Breshke's meta? honestly I read Breshke's filter and came to the opposite conclusion but like I said I don't know these people. I really need some veteran input on this. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
"nothing has jumped out at me other than the push on Scott, but geript implied (by meta, which again I disregarded because well....it was meta) that Trfel should have known better - he used his town meta to indicate this as Scott's scum meta to get him lynched." should be instead: "nothing has jumped out at me other than the push on Scott, but geript implied (by meta, which again I disregarded because well....it was meta) that Trfel should have known better - he used traits for scott that were not alignment indicative to indicate this as Scott's scum meta to get him lynched." | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
Placing it here for now. Database digging and then I have to go in for a research seminar at 3pm. | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
Trfel - 18 games, 3 as scum, 1 as third party Scott - 14 games, 3 as scum next step - go to the games where they both overlapped and scott was town Scott was town in 11 of the 14 games he played on TL. Trfel was present in the following games. (1) Newbie 11 - Trfel was mafia that game (2) Gaiden - Trfel was town (3) Battle of the Drams - Trfel was town Also Scott was in Completely normal generic mafia which Trfel observed. so he has three games' worth of meta knowledge and possibly more on scott where scott was town. is this information enough to say that he should have known better? I have to stop here but the question might lie in reads he made outside this game. particularly in Gaiden and Battle of the Drams where Trfel was town. but three games? gut reaction says yes he should have known better. can anyone discuss? | ||
|
NocturneMage
United Kingdom1965 Posts
| ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 Counter-Strike Super Smash Bros Other Games Organizations Other Games StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 StarCraft: Brood War |
|
GSL
WardiTV Team League
The PondCast
WardiTV Team League
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
CranKy Ducklings
RSL Revival
WardiTV Team League
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
