Here's the current nicknames list if you're interested: https://github.com/Xatalos/mafia-votecount/blob/master/resources/public/js/nicknames.js

I've played my couple of last games on Vendetta Strada. Last time I played here... Was this one I think: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/484076-assassination-mafia

Yeah I agree that Slam is feeling very carefree/relaxed. Which usually leans towards town...

How did you come to that townread list btw?

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

October 13 2015 10:49 GMT

#142

Xatalos replies:

Koshi, there is a chance if we lynch mafia today, 3p will kill the other mafia and mafia will kill the 3p and we win the game N1

Koshi replies to the Xatalos reply:
+ Show Spoiler +

hahahahaha, sure buddy

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

October 13 2015 10:51 GMT

#143

Well I agree it's pretty random and there's not much snowballing in the setup. In a sense, the anti-towns should focus on killing each other unless town is playing perfectly.

Hm. I guess I can understand your point of view. It's a little bit too elaborate to be a fake frustration?

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

October 13 2015 10:53 GMT

#144

IMPORTANT CLARIFICATION for people who can't read between lines.

It would be pretty cool to lynch anti-town. But playing on D1 random and not rewarding. There is a chance this game will become interesting D2. D1 it is pure shit. D2 has a 50% chance to still be shit.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

October 13 2015 10:54 GMT

#145

Still, basically there's never a reason not to play as town. Only scum(/anti-town) benefits from a silent thread. And it even makes the game MORE random since there's less to work with.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

October 13 2015 10:55 GMT

#146

Could you explain your vote btw? lol

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

October 13 2015 10:58 GMT

#147

I clicked myself and deleted myself.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

October 13 2015 11:00 GMT

#148

Seriously Xatalos. The explanation is standing in the damn vote. Moosy did completely nothing. He could be town doing completely nothing. Or he could be mafia doing completely nothing.

Town sometimes adds some silly plan in their first post, or try to do something. Mafia doesn't have do to shit so sometimes they forget they actually need to pretend to be town in the start.

Moosy didn't do shit. Hence. He could be mafia. Still didn't do shit when I poked him to do shit. Passive as fuck. Defensive. ezgame.

I am reading this forum on TL Dota so I have no filters. But I am probably 100% right.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

October 13 2015 11:00 GMT

#149

Oh yeah:

Claims post N1 need to be evaluated on their own.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

October 13 2015 11:05 GMT

#150

On October 13 2015 19:54 Xatalos wrote:
Still, basically there's never a reason not to play as town. Only scum(/anti-town) benefits from a silent thread. And it even makes the game MORE random since there's less to work with.

There will always be hardtryers. 15 page thread is as valuable in this game as a 150 page thread.
15 pages are probably better.
Please stop spamming.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

October 13 2015 11:05 GMT

#151

On October 13 2015 20:00 Superbia wrote:
Oh yeah:

Claims post N1 need to be evaluated on their own.

Yea, I have no idea what your doing this game...

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

October 13 2015 11:06 GMT

#152

On October 13 2015 20:00 Koshi wrote:
Seriously Xatalos. The explanation is standing in the damn vote. Moosy did completely nothing. He could be town doing completely nothing. Or he could be mafia doing completely nothing.

Town sometimes adds some silly plan in their first post, or try to do something. Mafia doesn't have do to shit so sometimes they forget they actually need to pretend to be town in the start.

Moosy didn't do shit. Hence. He could be mafia. Still didn't do shit when I poked him to do shit. Passive as fuck. Defensive. ezgame.

I am reading this forum on TL Dota so I have no filters. But I am probably 100% right.

I got the opposite picture? He didn't really do anything, but he seemed pretty relaxed despite your attack (not defensive / worried). And I think Mafia very rarely just "forget they need to pretend to look town". Rather, it's much more likely that Mafia do something at least resembling an okayish starter while townies often just explode.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

October 13 2015 11:08 GMT

#153

Well, it's still mainly a gut feeling from the way he responded "humorously". I've done that before as town many times when I'm accused early on.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

October 13 2015 11:09 GMT

#154

##Vote: Sylencia

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

October 13 2015 11:10 GMT

#155

On October 13 2015 20:05 Tictock wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yea, I have no idea what your doing this game...

Making a post. But please, elaborate on this.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

October 13 2015 11:10 GMT

#156

On October 13 2015 19:58 Superbia wrote:
I clicked myself and deleted myself.

Haha, looks like you added yourself back in

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

October 13 2015 11:11 GMT

#157

So Koshi, what I dont understand is you start off saying you want to plynch all liars, then jump on moosey for being, what "too casual" in the first 20 posts of the game?

Just seems like a silly vote to defend while also saying it's useless to try.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

October 13 2015 11:12 GMT

#158

On October 13 2015 20:09 Xatalos wrote:
##Vote: Sylencia

Oh yeah... This was mostly because I disliked his style of just cautiously/briefly popping into the thread to make some semi-useless comment, then disappear. That and the fact that others who had posted so far had at least something town-leaning going for them.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

October 13 2015 11:12 GMT

#159

On October 13 2015 20:10 Superbia wrote:

Show nested quote +

Making a post. But please, elaborate on this.

Do I need to? Seems better to wait for this post.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

October 13 2015 11:15 GMT

#160

Actually not going to post my post. Had a nice little theory written up about how I think both mafia and third party will play this game. Going to post it later (mayb n1) after people have "played". ;p