|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
On September 17 2015 18:58 justanothertownie wrote:
Like, am I missing something or why do you tie him to geript? Unlike rayn I am not convinced geript is mafia. But I also didn't catch up yet.
like i'm considering various alignment scenarios.
so the thing being discussed is damdred being potentially mafia, so i'm thinking if damdred is mafia making that post, then geript is mafia or town
if geript is town, then i think it's exceptionally odd to kinda build suspicion on him to make that post that ends up with him "definitely" not wanting to lynch geript, it's very decisive and closing doors
so if geript is mafia, it makes a little more sense in that you're manufacturing an about turn on your scumbuddy? but i don't get why he'd say all the things he said about geript already if that were the case
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
On September 17 2015 18:57 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On September 17 2015 18:55 marvellosity wrote:
do you agree/disagree with what i said about that post though?
or is there something i'm not considering I am not really seeing what you see in that post. You can call it "natural" or you can call it a wishy washy, inconclusive pile of words.
it's the way you watch him about-turning in his own post
and his conclusion was not wishy washy either
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
also while it just crossed my mind - my weekend plans that got cancelled got reinstated in a different form, so again i'll be very largely afk friday evening - sunday
|
On September 17 2015 19:04 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On September 17 2015 18:57 justanothertownie wrote:On September 17 2015 18:55 marvellosity wrote:
do you agree/disagree with what i said about that post though?
or is there something i'm not considering I am not really seeing what you see in that post. You can call it "natural" or you can call it a wishy washy, inconclusive pile of words. it's the way you watch him about-turning in his own post and his conclusion was not wishy washy either
I don't think I agree that this is very natural. If I would notice that I change my mind in a post this short I would just say my final conclusion and the reason for it. It is absolutely possible that damdred did this exactly because he expected people to townread him for it.
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
do you understand what i'm saying in the post above that though?
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
maybe i'm reading too much into one post.
|
On September 17 2015 19:08 marvellosity wrote:
do you understand what i'm saying in the post above that though?
I understand but I don't agree. I will take back the wishy washy stuff regarding his conclusion. You are right on that one. But I see no reason why damdred would not "close the doors" like this if geript is town. Not to mention that he can easily change this read again later on.
|
|
|
On September 17 2015 19:04 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On September 17 2015 18:58 justanothertownie wrote:
Like, am I missing something or why do you tie him to geript? Unlike rayn I am not convinced geript is mafia. But I also didn't catch up yet. like i'm considering various alignment scenarios. so the thing being discussed is damdred being potentially mafia, so i'm thinking if damdred is mafia making that post, then geript is mafia or town if geript is town, then i think it's exceptionally odd to kinda build suspicion on him to make that post that ends up with him "definitely" not wanting to lynch geript, it's very decisive and closing doors so if geript is mafia, it makes a little more sense in that you're manufacturing an about turn on your scumbuddy? but i don't get why he'd say all the things he said about geript already if that were the case
And when Damdred is town and I'm town and Rayn is mafia?
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
possibly. the post is definitely better for coming to a firm conclusion rather than just a waffle though, it's the decisiveness at the end of the about-turn that i thought made it quite townie.
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
On September 17 2015 19:12 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On September 17 2015 19:04 marvellosity wrote:On September 17 2015 18:58 justanothertownie wrote:
Like, am I missing something or why do you tie him to geript? Unlike rayn I am not convinced geript is mafia. But I also didn't catch up yet. like i'm considering various alignment scenarios. so the thing being discussed is damdred being potentially mafia, so i'm thinking if damdred is mafia making that post, then geript is mafia or town if geript is town, then i think it's exceptionally odd to kinda build suspicion on him to make that post that ends up with him "definitely" not wanting to lynch geript, it's very decisive and closing doors so if geript is mafia, it makes a little more sense in that you're manufacturing an about turn on your scumbuddy? but i don't get why he'd say all the things he said about geript already if that were the case And when Damdred is town and I'm town and Rayn is mafia?
then i need a bump of k
|
On September 17 2015 19:13 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On September 17 2015 19:12 geript wrote:On September 17 2015 19:04 marvellosity wrote:On September 17 2015 18:58 justanothertownie wrote:
Like, am I missing something or why do you tie him to geript? Unlike rayn I am not convinced geript is mafia. But I also didn't catch up yet. like i'm considering various alignment scenarios. so the thing being discussed is damdred being potentially mafia, so i'm thinking if damdred is mafia making that post, then geript is mafia or town if geript is town, then i think it's exceptionally odd to kinda build suspicion on him to make that post that ends up with him "definitely" not wanting to lynch geript, it's very decisive and closing doors so if geript is mafia, it makes a little more sense in that you're manufacturing an about turn on your scumbuddy? but i don't get why he'd say all the things he said about geript already if that were the case And when Damdred is town and I'm town and Rayn is mafia? then i need a bump of k
You could just look at your read like asked.
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
the thing is, geript, when rayn is mafia he doesn't push his mislynches based on mysterious stuff floating in the air that no-one/few people are quite grasping
he's clear and picks on things that you can evaluate yourself, he'll push on inconsistencies that don't make that player mafia. it would be a quite remarkable push as mafia, one that i'd love to replicate myself as scum sometime, but i'm not sure it's even possible to do
|
On September 17 2015 19:17 marvellosity wrote:
the thing is, geript, when rayn is mafia he doesn't push his mislynches based on mysterious stuff floating in the air that no-one/few people are quite grasping
he's clear and picks on things that you can evaluate yourself, he'll push on inconsistencies that don't make that player mafia. it would be a quite remarkable push as mafia, one that i'd love to replicate myself as scum sometime, but i'm not sure it's even possible to do
I'm pretty sure I explained how he pushed on things that didn't make Moosy anything. Like go back through. Where is there a single damn thing that moosy did that Rayn pushes him for that makes him mafia?
You're telling me, no he's town and here's what he does as scum. Yet I pretty specifically outlined what he did and it aligns with your scumread of him??????? Wtf
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
On September 17 2015 19:26 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On September 17 2015 19:17 marvellosity wrote:
the thing is, geript, when rayn is mafia he doesn't push his mislynches based on mysterious stuff floating in the air that no-one/few people are quite grasping
he's clear and picks on things that you can evaluate yourself, he'll push on inconsistencies that don't make that player mafia. it would be a quite remarkable push as mafia, one that i'd love to replicate myself as scum sometime, but i'm not sure it's even possible to do I'm pretty sure I explained how he pushed on things that didn't make Moosy anything. Like go back through. Where is there a single damn thing that moosy did that Rayn pushes him for that makes him mafia? You're telling me, no he's town and here's what he does as scum. Yet I pretty specifically outlined what he did and it aligns with your scumread of him??????? Wtf
nope.
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
like i'm not even sure what you're babbling about.
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
oh i see. no, the point is that mafiarayn's pushes are on the surface pretty reasonable. i don't think this push was ever that reasonable, it just seemed he believed very strongly in it.
|
Bhow about you answer my case geript?
Also fyi to evetyone, if i post after 22cet dont listen to me.
I am probably gonna be very drunk.
|
United Kingdom36160 Posts
as an aside, i find it quite funny that you always ask me to "trust" your reads.
but here you're trying to convince me that one of the best historic reads that TL Mafia has ever seen is bound to be wrong.
this relationship is very one-sided.
|
Also if i was scum i would have totally mislynched jat instead of moosy. So geript basically has to think jat is mafia aswell.
That makes it two terrible reads.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
