|
On September 30 2015 01:40 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On September 29 2015 18:57 Palmar wrote:
I actually think this was a pretty good game. I was really afraid I'd get lynched in that last phase but I wasn't mad at all. Town played well, just got a bit unlucky with how unproductive day 2/3 are. Autolynches often actually don't really help town. Cpehiro was a bad lynch because marv his case on cephiro + swing of people on Cephiro was not really that likely a buss.That and Cephiro played well. One of the few I read he posts from. Day 1 was pretty ok from town and mafia. Both played well. Moos was a well deserved lynch for both teams. geript lynch was avoidable in my eyes. But I didn't read those days. Cephiro lynch was pretty bad, like I said. But then again Palmar aka you played really well so w.e. Should have been a lynch between Damdred and Palmar more imo.
Cephiro himself made a mistake though, not getting in front of his lynch early enough. He needed to exploit the fact I was away on sunday to make his case for being town, instead he sat and waited and let me take the initiative.
|
On September 29 2015 12:39 scott31337 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 29 2015 06:42 Koshi wrote:On September 29 2015 06:39 deconduo wrote:
Thanks for playing everyone, and thanks to Kelsier for helping host. I'd appreciate any feedback on the setup, hosting etc.
I think this might have been a slightly town-sided setup, though the fact that the masons are not confirmed does offset that a bit. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAYeah it was townfavored to the max. To balance it town needed at least a 2 shot vigi, scum RB should have been removed, town should have gotten a real cop and after D1 you should have killed the 3 people with the highest amount of votes on them. Please speak to Artanis, Blazinghand and HalfTheSky in the future when you host again. Tracker played well is better than cop. I am unsure how else I could have done better.
You played your role perfect. Really, perfect.
But a tracker is not better than a cop most of the times. I don't know if you could track the janitor. But you only had 1 person you could track, knowing they had a gf for kp delivery. A cop most of the times can check 2 mafia members. Making it more likely a mafia member under pressure will turn up red.
If marv/palmar was rb you would have been a useless role. While if you were a cop, only if Wile was gf you would have been useless.
Basically in this format you had 1 target (the RB), unless gf got lynched/shot. While a cop has more options. A cop green check is also somewhat more trustable for the same reason.
There was also an unaware miller who basically made the chance to hit correctly or disastrously for the tracker 50/50, or not hitting anything
tldr: The post I made there was just to whine about a previous game I played which had a very similar set up like this one, or at least was also a normal mini.
But it had a 2 shot vig, an aware miller, a cop while the scumteam had a framer and 2 goons. Also the host lynched on D1 3 people with the highest amount of votes.
I am afraid to look it up, but I think it also had 14 people so that town could misfire 2 times, and still not lose on 3 ml. Or shoot 2 tiems correctly and ml 5 times and not lose.
It was the most retarded piece of shit balanced game ever. I complained about it and people told me I was wrong per usual and the game was fine.
Obviously it was a piece of shit balanced shitgame and I was correct.
tldr tldr: Koshi is always right when it comes to balance. A couple hosts on this site are braindamaged.
|
On September 30 2015 01:42 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On September 30 2015 01:40 Koshi wrote:On September 29 2015 18:57 Palmar wrote:
I actually think this was a pretty good game. I was really afraid I'd get lynched in that last phase but I wasn't mad at all. Town played well, just got a bit unlucky with how unproductive day 2/3 are. Autolynches often actually don't really help town. Cpehiro was a bad lynch because marv his case on cephiro + swing of people on Cephiro was not really that likely a buss.That and Cephiro played well. One of the few I read he posts from. Day 1 was pretty ok from town and mafia. Both played well. Moos was a well deserved lynch for both teams. geript lynch was avoidable in my eyes. But I didn't read those days. Cephiro lynch was pretty bad, like I said. But then again Palmar aka you played really well so w.e. Should have been a lynch between Damdred and Palmar more imo. Cephiro himself made a mistake though, not getting in front of his lynch early enough. He needed to exploit the fact I was away on sunday to make his case for being town, instead he sat and waited and let me take the initiative.
oh yeah I remember that. That was somewhat bad. I somewhere read that "I am being mafia on purpose, I don't mind". Because people will always remember you had a couple suspicious moments in the game.
|
On September 30 2015 01:42 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On September 30 2015 01:40 Koshi wrote:On September 29 2015 18:57 Palmar wrote:
I actually think this was a pretty good game. I was really afraid I'd get lynched in that last phase but I wasn't mad at all. Town played well, just got a bit unlucky with how unproductive day 2/3 are. Autolynches often actually don't really help town. Cpehiro was a bad lynch because marv his case on cephiro + swing of people on Cephiro was not really that likely a buss.That and Cephiro played well. One of the few I read he posts from. Day 1 was pretty ok from town and mafia. Both played well. Moos was a well deserved lynch for both teams. geript lynch was avoidable in my eyes. But I didn't read those days. Cephiro lynch was pretty bad, like I said. But then again Palmar aka you played really well so w.e. Should have been a lynch between Damdred and Palmar more imo. Cephiro himself made a mistake though, not getting in front of his lynch early enough. He needed to exploit the fact I was away on sunday to make his case for being town, instead he sat and waited and let me take the initiative.
That doesn't make lynching him a better play. People should not only have seen what Koshi said but also and especially how cephiro played the eod when geript got lynched because that was insanely towny. And he continued to play like that in LYLO.
I could have understood a damdred mislynch to an extent but not a cephiro mislynch.
|
lol Cephiro was right the entire game and people thought he was mafia EVEN after 2 mafia had flipped.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
