|
On September 19 2015 11:56 geript wrote:
In looking back at it, I don't think Marv is mafia either. I don't think he talks about his Rayn read how he does if he's mafia. I think he entertains it at least a little. In the least, he can do so to like try and super hang me with it or at least spread a question in regards to Rayn's alignment if sentiment moves that way. So I don't think Marv's mafia either.
I kinda just htink Onegu might have been janitor.
TBH I'mnot quite sure if I'm sour about still not getting Vigi. Obviously, I probably would've shot wrong, but it means I still didn't get to shoot anyone.
Can you show what exactly you are talking about with the rayn read? In my opinion it being too confident too early is not a point in marvs favor. He made mistakes like that before when he was mafia.
|
On September 19 2015 11:53 geript wrote:
Shooting Rayn is kinda an interesting choice. They're choosing not to medic dodge as I think he's a bit more likely (considering most people's reads) than Marv or Palmar.
The funny thing is that it feels like more of a Palmar kill than a Marv kill, but IDK if either of them would actually make that kill. So I can still live in a world where both Palmar and Marv are town.
Why wouldn't they make that kill? I don't follow your logic at all.
If marv is mafia he absolutely needs to get rid of rayn because he can never change his mind about him and has to support him. Imagine he shot someone that isn't palmar or rayn - then there would still be 2 good players (ok, let's say 1,5 considering one of them is palmar) alive now who he could never attack and who would never be lynched before him. That rayn was universally townread and strongly townreading me is a bonus too.
|
Medic dodging is also not as good in a 13 player mini with 1 KP. If a shot gets blocked town does not gain a mislynch and mafia did not know there was a vigi in this game.
And now that I think about it - even if they suspected it the shot is good since if rayn gets saved the vigi is not confirmed regardless of who he shoots due to the janitor.
|
I think trying to lynch marv day3 is the best play we can make. If he is town it will most likely become obvious and then the game is literally solved (3 suspects with damdred, cephiro and geript, 3 lynches) assuming scott is real which I see no reason to doubt. If he is mafia that's nice too.
I will try to put into words why I think he could be mafia in a minute.
|
United Kingdom10443 Posts
Day2 Votecount
Wile E. Coyote (9): geript, scott31337, Koshi, ritoky. Damdred, justanothertownie, Palmar, marvellosity, Cephiro
Not Voting (1): Wile E. Coyote
Voting ends in at 21:30 GMT (+00:00).
|
Marv confirmed mafia due to all these pending cases.
|
I got the sickest marv is mafia case incoming give me a couple seconds guys
|
This is hilarious and possibly intentional.
Step 1: Jat and geript read OP
On September 18 2015 07:24 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2015 07:23 geript wrote:
Am I the only person that caught that Rayn wasn't confirmed to his partner and vice versa? No, reading the OP isn't that hard.
Step 2: Jat and geript don't read the OP
On September 19 2015 11:53 geript wrote:
Shooting Rayn is kinda an interesting choice. They're choosing not to medic dodge as I think he's a bit more likely (considering most people's reads) than Marv or Palmar.
The funny thing is that it feels like more of a Palmar kill than a Marv kill, but IDK if either of them would actually make that kill. So I can still live in a world where both Palmar and Marv are town.
On September 19 2015 21:06 justanothertownie wrote:
Medic dodging is also not as good in a 13 player mini with 1 KP. If a shot gets blocked town does not gain a mislynch and mafia did not know there was a vigi in this game.
And now that I think about it - even if they suspected it the shot is good since if rayn gets saved the vigi is not confirmed regardless of who he shoots due to the janitor.
There is literally no medic/jailkeeper in the game.
Don't know what to do with this.
The reason is, two people made the same mistake. I (mis?)remembered it being JAT who had pointed the thing about the masons, then I saw him talk about medic dodging, so I charged right to my computer in order to post why JAT is 100% mafia for this.
The problem is, when I started looking into JAT's filter to see where he had said it I found it it was geript who had said the thing about the masons and JAT simply agreed with him. This means that unless those two are exactly the remaining mafia team (this is actually very possible, it just means Onegu is town), then at least one townie made the mistake.
It's a great wifom bomb to throw if you're scum. "Look, I wasn't aware of mechanics that affect night kills so I can't be mafia!!!", although it also requires one, or both of them to have forgotten about having already bragged about reading the OP. Or alternatively (and much more unlikely) knowing about it and simply gambling no one would notice.
So idk...
|
I'm obviously town, but I don't think that makes a difference.
I guess there being no medic is kinda weird though.
|
On a scale of 1 to LS after believing a joke, how much town am I for actually recalling that detail?
|
Anyway, it's weekend, I'm not going to be much around.
Damdred has been dropping off it feels like but still.
Ceph said something about wanting to be suspicious which doesn't sound suspicious at all. I also think JAT called him out on it which is mehh~~~~
|
that "but still" means that I don't know if it means anything.
There's too many people who need to do more, the game feels sort of undecided now.
We kinda have to lynch correctly tomorrow.
|
Last sentence is the only important sentence.
And the people you talk about who need to do more are the spammiest motherfuckers ever.
JAT, marv, Palmar
So........
Vets suck
|
|
|
I am still working on this marv case guys.
Give me a couple secs.
|
Ok. I actually read Palmar his post and it is hilarious.
haha.
Good thing I did that.
wow.
There is no medic? I also didn't know that.
|
wow the wifom games are real.
|
Anyway Palmar and JAT still mafia and Palmar made this post to point out JAT isn't mafia.
Still working on the marv case. Proofs marv is mafia. 2 secs please.
|
JAT is probably doing his scum meta pretending to be the same as others.
Thing with medic that Palmar pointed out. aka JAT pretending to be the same as geript.
The new "lets make a marv case meme" aka JAT pretending to be the same as cephiro.
Probably more in this game but I haven't read all the posts.
|
On September 20 2015 00:46 Palmar wrote:This is hilarious and possibly intentional. Step 1: Jat and geript read OP Show nested quote +On September 18 2015 07:24 justanothertownie wrote:On September 18 2015 07:23 geript wrote:
Am I the only person that caught that Rayn wasn't confirmed to his partner and vice versa? No, reading the OP isn't that hard. Step 2: Jat and geript don't read the OP Show nested quote +On September 19 2015 11:53 geript wrote:
Shooting Rayn is kinda an interesting choice. They're choosing not to medic dodge as I think he's a bit more likely (considering most people's reads) than Marv or Palmar.
The funny thing is that it feels like more of a Palmar kill than a Marv kill, but IDK if either of them would actually make that kill. So I can still live in a world where both Palmar and Marv are town. Show nested quote +On September 19 2015 21:06 justanothertownie wrote:
Medic dodging is also not as good in a 13 player mini with 1 KP. If a shot gets blocked town does not gain a mislynch and mafia did not know there was a vigi in this game.
And now that I think about it - even if they suspected it the shot is good since if rayn gets saved the vigi is not confirmed regardless of who he shoots due to the janitor. There is literally no medic/jailkeeper in the game. Don't know what to do with this. The reason is, two people made the same mistake. I (mis?)remembered it being JAT who had pointed the thing about the masons, then I saw him talk about medic dodging, so I charged right to my computer in order to post why JAT is 100% mafia for this. The problem is, when I started looking into JAT's filter to see where he had said it I found it it was geript who had said the thing about the masons and JAT simply agreed with him. This means that unless those two are exactly the remaining mafia team (this is actually very possible, it just means Onegu is town), then at least one townie made the mistake. It's a great wifom bomb to throw if you're scum. "Look, I wasn't aware of mechanics that affect night kills so I can't be mafia!!!", although it also requires one, or both of them to have forgotten about having already bragged about reading the OP. Or alternatively (and much more unlikely) knowing about it and simply gambling no one would notice. So idk...
Talk about levels of mafia play. lol
On September 20 2015 01:13 Palmar wrote:
Anyway, it's weekend, I'm not going to be much around.
Damdred has been dropping off it feels like but still.
Ceph said something about wanting to be suspicious which doesn't sound suspicious at all. I also think JAT called him out on it which is mehh~~~~
I called it dumb. Do you disagree it is dumb? I hope you don't.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
