Desert Center Mini Mafia - Page 12

On August 08 2015 01:34 rsoultin wrote:


why should i be concerned about the vote, ruxx? it's nai

is there some reason you take issue with me saying i think yama's scum but don't care about the vote?

On August 08 2015 01:41 rsoultin wrote:
yeah i'm not going to argue with you over this ruxx lol ><

we both think he's scum for almost identical reasons and this argument is pointless

if you want me to change my vote, convince me (or enough other people) that edgar could be town. i'm assuming that's the real purpose behind your aggression xP

On August 07 2015 07:46 EdgarAllanPoE wrote:
I do not care why you are voting me. We are going to lynch igrok today. Every post he makes contains things that look like he is a person that is trying his hardest to formulate coherent reads to fit in but instead they look really flawed and based on silly things where he pushes false dichotomies such as someone being silly-town or mafia but we should lynch them anyway.

None of these things are a towny thought process. Coupled with his coaching and cheerleading earlier and his inablity to answer basic questions then he is an excellent lynch.

On August 07 2015 07:51 EdgarAllanPoE wrote:
Alternatively, I can respond to your case to mindlessly appease you but my responses would not be nice. If you think any of those things make anyone mafia ever then you need to rethink how to look for mafia.

My vote on igrok was because:

A) I was not sure if I'd be around or want to play at all with no filters since I work the entirety of the cycle and catching up does not particularly work for me.

B) my read on ruxxar was based on other people's opinions and my read on igrok was based on mine + ruxxar's opinions and so I picked the person that made the read on the other.

I can still think both are scummy and pick one though, how would that make me mafia either way?

On August 08 2015 02:06 Rels wrote:
Wtf. Edgar is scummy as fuck. I'm OK with yamato but I'm not OK with you calling Edgar town.

Your strongest point, his explanation of igrok vite with his own word, is shut. He just parroted what raoul said, he even took her words (coaching, cheerleading)

And that is exactly what a mafia would do. Would he stay silent ? No be would come, justify his vote with what he can then leave without talking to anyone

On August 08 2015 02:08 yamato77 wrote:
I blame Tina for not getting caught up last night.

On August 08 2015 02:16 Damdred wrote:
Yeah a bit which isn't indicative because I just lynched mafia with no push back in my last 2 games.

However I do have misgivings here on Edgar for some reason, like his posts still aren't horrible scum feeling to me which is meh.

On August 08 2015 02:21 rsoultin wrote:
silencio, padawan

i know your angle and your desire; you don't need to keep screaming it lol ><

nh

reads yama andale

On August 08 2015 02:17 yamato77 wrote:
I will post as much as I can before deadline.

On August 07 2015 15:38 ruXxar wrote:
Here Yamato, to help you along:

1) What are your town and scum reads?

2) Why did you call Igroks post shit?

3) what is your opinion of igrok

4) why are you voting for rsoultin

On August 08 2015 02:27 Rels wrote:
Yamato coming back the second switch to him starts happening is super scummy. It could be a coincidence, or it could be a mafia content with Edgar's lynch.

On August 08 2015 02:42 yamato77 wrote:
I'll start with the stuff I had last night before things happened that I now regret.



This sort of post is what I would expect from town Tina, fortunately. Nothing else I've read really stands out at me too much (I'm only on p12) but her "damdy!whisperer" thing made me laugh. Scum tina just makes me mad to read.



I would expect iGrok, coming from a less-spammy time, to post things like this. Obviously it's not impossible that he's scum and trying to look like he's put thought into the game but I like this post from him, and even the post I poked fun at. It will be interesting to see how he follows up with his reads, however.



This analysis of iGrok is poor. So early in the day, Tina claims that iGrok is somehow scummy for coming out of the gates with an enthusiastic plan for how to structure his play. Why? If he does nothing and just hides behind his anti-lurker campaign, sure, he becomes worse off, but she seems to preempt that with this. For the record, me disagreeing with early game reads by Tina does not really have any impact on my opinion of her alignment.



I believe this was in reference to ruxxar. I had something to say about this post by rayn but I forgot.

Instead I'll use it as a segue to my opinion on ruxxar, which is that I'm not wholly impressed by him.

He continually questions my approach to iGrok's play throughout the game despite it being abundantly clear and accepted by everyone that I was poking fun at him. I don't understand why this has any bearing on my alignment, really, given that I hadn't given any real opinion on iGrok's play until just now. Also, I question his assessment that iGrok's play is somehow scummy, because I obviously disagree with this at this juncture. granted, I will need to read the rest of his filter to make a more accurate judgement, but at this time I would be more in favor of lynching ruxx than iGrok.



Lastly, I noticed this post from Cake about her two townreads. I don't mind the townreads so much as I don't really like her "not-townreads" in this post, in that she barely spends any time trying to explain her reasoning unlike her long-winded take on rayn.

Moving forward, I'm going to take a look at iGrok, Ruxxar, and Cake. Any other recommendations for filters important at this time would be nice.

On August 08 2015 02:37 Rels wrote:

I'll teach you the french touch too. Sexy as fuck accent

On August 08 2015 02:56 yamato77 wrote:

My joke with tina was before the game started.

I haven't even read edgar. I suppose that's a suggestion of someone to read? Thank you for being clear.

On August 08 2015 02:57 yamato77 wrote:

If I don't think he's mafia, then...?

It's like you think I have to find the other guy scummy.

What if I want to lynch you?

On August 08 2015 03:00 yamato77 wrote:
So I've skimmed iGrok's filter, and I find it quite easy to explain.

1) He has a plan of how to play mountainous. I would expect him to. As mafia I doubt he comes up with this plan and follows through.

2) He finds tina quite scummy because of his metric of "active-lurking", and then gets into a tunnel when she calls him mafia. I don't agree with his read of her but it's fairly easy to see how he gets there.

3) He attacks ruxxar for horrible posts. Thus far I'm in agreement about this as well. Will read ruxxar's fitler next and show the horrible posts about which I speak.