Mini Mafia Down Under 3 - Page 21

On July 26 2015 12:45 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
Hope, I don't understand the point of your scott case?
Elaborate for me?

On July 26 2015 03:37 GlowingBear wrote:


Palmar, address to this.
This + him constantly being annoyed that people are wasting his posts + wanting to lynch me because he doesn't like me, then saying it's because I'm stupid, then admitting that being stupid doesn't make me Mafia but still willing to lynch me is very scummy to me.

On July 26 2015 12:54 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I would advocate taking a serious look at Onegu if he continues down this path of "I claimed so I'm confirmed town."

On July 26 2015 12:59 rsoultin wrote:


he's done it too much as town for that to mean anything? like, i have a way to read him but it requires a little more time than this lol >< and it's still in it's early stages but it bore fruit last game

On July 26 2015 12:55 Hopeless1der wrote:

Can I just say "waffle" and leave it at that?

@GB re kelsier

I see a number of somewhat explained town reads in his filter but little to no scum reads and vague "I'd lynch this guy...maybe" vibes. Not feeling great about kelsier but I would really want to lynch him today.

On July 26 2015 13:05 Onegu wrote:



Onegu confirmed town.

On July 26 2015 13:07 ObiWanShinobi wrote:


Iuno.
Like.
I know what you're saying and I also want to lynch scott.

I was kind of aware of the idea behind what you were saying but I felt like there was something I was missing from your post.
Like in hindsight it was kind of obvious but still.

On July 26 2015 12:58 rsoultin wrote:


meh, maybe, but you think it's more likely for annoyed scum to say he wants to lynch you even though stupid doesn't make you scum? or annoyed town?

cause yeah, i perfectly understand his sentiment. i feel the same way about snickers. i won't lynch him, but i'd be happy to have him out of the game xP

On July 26 2015 12:55 Hopeless1der wrote:

Can I just say "waffle" and leave it at that?

@GB re kelsier

I see a number of somewhat explained town reads in his filter but little to no scum reads and vague "I'd lynch this guy...maybe" vibes. Not feeling great about kelsier but I would really want to lynch him today.

On July 26 2015 13:40 GlowingBear wrote:


That puts snickers, or even Scott, on the chopping block. I've done nothing to annoy him other than calling him Mafia for fair reasons. Plus he says he doesn't like me. Then he says it's because I'm stupid. Then admits being stupid isn't a scum tell but he would be okay to lynch me anyway.

It's not that he could not do that as annoyed town, is that there is no reason to be annoyed with me in this game + it sounds more like he was okay with a lynch on me without having any reasons for lynching me. Then, when having the matter pushed, he couldn't find a fair reason to "not like" me. Why doesn't he like me? What I've being doing that is stupid? He fails to show that.

The only townie thing I saw in his filter was what Palmar said about dismissing the possibility of shitting the thread, but he could also be trying to avoid getting more suspicions at him by dismissing a push, even if a bad push.

I see nothing townie in him that takes him out of the lynch list like you did. I have yet to see what exactly makes him townie to your eyes that he is never getting lynched day1. Please tell me

On July 26 2015 13:40 GlowingBear wrote:Then admits being stupid isn't a scum tell but he would be okay to lynch me anyway.

On July 26 2015 14:15 rsoultin wrote:


yeah, well, i'm okay with lynching people i have no reasons to lynch, too xP it's called a null read

and yes, ksc is perfectly capable of being annoyed with stupidity in general. neither of us has much patience for it, and you aren't exactly known for being logical

look at his filter and his read progression

has he expressed irritation at stupid pushes on him? yes. is that the majority of his filter? no

he's clearly making reads and contributing and i really liked his push on tofu because i felt the same way reading tofu's response to palmar. plus i dunnae i think the aggression and bite in general is more likely to come from a town ksc than a scum one. scum worries about making friends. town just wants to solve the game xP

it's tonal but i'm fairly confident on it or i wouldn't have him in my strong townreads in the first place

On July 26 2015 12:51 Onegu wrote:
Like what is my motivation as scum to make this claim this early?

Your odds are way off there are normally 2-3 blues in a 13 player setup. There are 7 possible blue roles. So the odds are 2/7 or 3/7 you get CC if you make this claim as scum. There are 3 scum out of 13. So yes the slight majority of the time you dont get CC and you are ok. But the other 40ish percent of the time you are CC and at best you trade 1 for 1 against a blue that has no powers. But knowing me I am lynched first and then you lost one scum and confirmed a town. Not worth the risk.

Also you think I am bussing Rsoul when if we were scum together... Wait nevermind I would totally bus the shit out of her if we ever rolled scum together. But we didnt.