Mafia in the Himalayas - Page 174

On June 23 2015 14:09 LightningStrike wrote:
Nydus in case you haven't caught up she claimed Mason with Fidei before the GB stuff so she's town lol. Also she is hard to lynch as either alignment outside of her claim simply because of her nature I guess lol.

On June 23 2015 14:16 NydusHerMain wrote:


Okay Fidei I had as scummy so that's good if that's a legit claim... I had LS and RS as town and I was willing to believe GB for a day on his claim as well as his check on MiG. HF I had as town, and I think that might be about it off the top of my head. Onegu I have had as scum since day but I think I read something about him pushing on HF so that might change things. This game, I've been trying to trust my own personal meta reads on people, e.g. Ritoky, but it's been proven wrong once and I have a feeling that I'm wrong on another (either onegu or damdred or both or I don't know). My reads are 100% proven to be bad because I had RS as town and Fidei as scum and they're hard aligned, I had HF and GB as town and they're obviously opposite alignments so it's kind of awkward for me. I think I'm going to try to spend my time on deciding whether or not I trust RS as town by not going off a tone read but an actual logic / activity read because I trust her meta reads over mine. At least she has more games than I do with everyone... zzz...

On June 23 2015 14:18 NydusHerMain wrote:
Oh and I definitely think Shockey is scum as I have all game if the people who died in the night were pushing on him. I don't actually remember if they pushed on him but I HIGHLY doubt mafia try to frame someone by killing wrong town. That's so dumb. It's easier to get someone mislynched by keeping the people pushing the mislynch alive rofl than trying to frame by killing anyone who calls that town scum. Shockey is way scummier for those night kills than he claims.

On June 23 2015 14:25 rsoultin wrote:


ah :/ trusting my meta/tonereads can be dangerous

fidei and ls i won't let people lynch

damdy is someone i BELIEVE i've got a good toneread on...i really do. but in all honesty a month or two ago i was still struggling with him so i've been very accurate recently but i don't think it's been tested enough to be completely reliable

i still won't lynch him without a very good reason

oneg i'm not certain on. like literally you should just get your own read on him. all i will say is that i can see him playing this way as town easily and HAVE seen him play this way as town

hf i've waffled on most of the game. i think he's tied in pretty close to mig though given his behavior when gb claimed; if one is scum the likelihood that they both are is kinda high

shockey is likely scum but that's not meta and it's mostly associative so that's for later

ruxxar independently i think is scum. rit may have been right about the association between him and shockey though

lol that's where i'm at ><

va...i think the best way to tell with him is to wait a bit

On June 23 2015 14:27 NydusHerMain wrote:


What was rit's association because shockey and ruxxar? Because I independently read them both scummy.

On June 23 2015 14:29 rsoultin wrote:


it was bugs actually

bugs asked shockey a question when he was out of the thread and shockey immediately answered it. ritoky thought that meant that bugs probably already knew that shockey was there...i.e. scum together

On June 23 2015 14:29 NydusHerMain wrote:
I dunno, even without reading through your filter, just talking to you now I feel like we're coming from the same mindset. After this game is over I'll find out if I just think like mafia or not but until then, I'm probably just leaning town on you forever >.>

On June 23 2015 14:31 NydusHerMain wrote:


Ehhhhh, that sounds like a stretch... I dunno if I'd trust that read but I have a null read on bugs so meh.

On June 23 2015 14:34 rsoultin wrote:


i feel like anything i say to this will reduce my credibility xP

in all honesty i'm really not an easy scum catch. some people just use the "is she still alive" metric, which is probably a fair one

i don't fake-claim, though. so you can at least trust (and others will back it up) that if i'm scum this game i've fake-claimed for the first time in 20 games

On June 18 2015 03:46 Holyflare wrote:


just ignore her back she loves it

i'm sorry if we've caused unnecessary confusion with the votes but they are just sitting afk on rsoultin due to sheer lazyness so treat like 3/4 of them as not real votes

the people that i'd likely lynch today will be:

the person that gets replaced
boxerfred
possibly va but i'll have to have a think about that
notreallysureaboutlshe'sgivingmedemweirdfeels

On June 18 2015 03:50 Holyflare wrote:


either mig or bill murray yeh the reason is that they both had to have /confirmed to play the game and doing that meant they had time to play, hts just asked for only ONE replacement near the start of the game which likely meant someone got their role pm and was like fuck this lets replace

On June 23 2015 14:46 NydusHerMain wrote:
So I'm thinking like HF would have a team of like shockey, mig and another?

On June 23 2015 14:49 rsoultin wrote:


i could see hf with them both yeah

like, read eod 2 after hf has been tunneling gb all game and how he reacts to the claim

and then his posting during night phase

i want to see if we're seeing things the same way