So wait GB, I haven't read your filter to doublecheck but you're saying you were already setting up a fake claim on MiG as town since day 2? I like your claim (kind of?) but it's interesting that you would put a fake green on someone you thought was scum because if they actually are mafia, they're pretty much off the table that day solely because of you. On top of that, I want to give you two scenarios under the assumption you're real.

1) MiG is godfather and thinks you're the real cop with a green check on him. He sees that you're getting a lot of scum pushed on you despite you being a cop claim. Then, he doesn't kill you in the night because you're getting a lot of scum pushed on you and MiG knows that if he's to ever get lynched, you have to get lynched first so it kinda puts him on your side in association so he doesn't ever have to kill you and can just let town mislynch you.

2) MiG is town and the mafia sees you getting a lot of scum pushed on you and decides to keep him alive because he's inactive and useless anyways (from their eyes) and all they need to do is push you and get you mislynched.

I appreciate your efforts if you're real on doing a "fancy" play but I don't think that your play solves anything with respect to MiG's alignment. Also, if you wanted to do a fancy play like you did, I suggest in the future to claim like a green check on me. It's much more likely for me to be town than for MiG (although I might be biased in saying this) and it would've made sense since you said that you thought I was town but that I was dropping down from the circle. Meh, I dunno. I'll probably have to filter dive hard to see what's up.

RS, I forget. How hard did HF push on you? I recall him being with bugs on the push on you but he backed off pretty easily?

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

June 23 2015 04:54 GMT

#3449

I think this was Tina's theme for first part of her Mafia career:

NydusHerMain

Canada492 Posts

June 23 2015 04:58 GMT

#3450

I am going to say that I am leaning more towards GB being real, moreso than prior to his check switch solely because I think LS is town. It's interesting because I was reading HF as town too. I didn't really believe him when he said he had a red on RS though. I thought that there was no reason for him to check RS but at the same time, I didn't believe RS instantly saying she was framed either because I feel like if mafia believed that GB was cop, since RS wasn't on GB's radar, framer wouldn't use his power on RS and would use it on some town in GB's scum circle unless they're all scum. <- not that the last part matters since he's not claiming RS red

NydusHerMain

Canada492 Posts

June 23 2015 05:00 GMT

#3451

I just want a fucking mafia to flip. That would make the game way more interesting. Every game I've played, even the one where I was mafia, it's always just been town lynches until mafia just wins via massive stomp.

NydusHerMain

Canada492 Posts

June 23 2015 05:03 GMT

#3452

Would it be more interesting to give my reads prior to the checks or just start from scratch and look for a GB team vs a HF team?

NydusHerMain

Canada492 Posts

June 23 2015 05:04 GMT

#3453

By interesting, I mean more useful

NydusHerMain

Canada492 Posts

June 23 2015 05:04 GMT

#3454

Don't tell me everyone went to sleep just as I come back into the game LOL

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

June 23 2015 05:05 GMT

#3455

Pretty much how I feel like this Day Phase now that we are serious:

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

June 23 2015 05:06 GMT

#3456

On June 23 2015 13:54 NydusHerMain wrote:
So wait GB, I haven't read your filter to doublecheck but you're saying you were already setting up a fake claim on MiG as town since day 2? I like your claim (kind of?) but it's interesting that you would put a fake green on someone you thought was scum because if they actually are mafia, they're pretty much off the table that day solely because of you. On top of that, I want to give you two scenarios under the assumption you're real.

1) MiG is godfather and thinks you're the real cop with a green check on him. He sees that you're getting a lot of scum pushed on you despite you being a cop claim. Then, he doesn't kill you in the night because you're getting a lot of scum pushed on you and MiG knows that if he's to ever get lynched, you have to get lynched first so it kinda puts him on your side in association so he doesn't ever have to kill you and can just let town mislynch you.

2) MiG is town and the mafia sees you getting a lot of scum pushed on you and decides to keep him alive because he's inactive and useless anyways (from their eyes) and all they need to do is push you and get you mislynched.

I appreciate your efforts if you're real on doing a "fancy" play but I don't think that your play solves anything with respect to MiG's alignment. Also, if you wanted to do a fancy play like you did, I suggest in the future to claim like a green check on me. It's much more likely for me to be town than for MiG (although I might be biased in saying this) and it would've made sense since you said that you thought I was town but that I was dropping down from the circle. Meh, I dunno. I'll probably have to filter dive hard to see what's up.

RS, I forget. How hard did HF push on you? I recall him being with bugs on the push on you but he backed off pretty easily?

i'm ridiculously hard to lynch, nydus, as either alignment. i've been mislynched once in lylo and i would have been lynched (probably) if i hadn't conceded in my first scum game

but otherwise -shrugs-

he came after me for pushing him, basically saying that i should know his meta and since i was pushing him anyway for those reasons it made me scum

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

June 23 2015 05:07 GMT

#3457

he did not support bugs' reasons

but bugs' reasons would never make me scum, and honestly...i don't know if he could get away with supporting those with the players in the thread with me

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

June 23 2015 05:08 GMT

#3458

On June 23 2015 13:58 NydusHerMain wrote:
I am going to say that I am leaning more towards GB being real, moreso than prior to his check switch solely because I think LS is town. It's interesting because I was reading HF as town too. I didn't really believe him when he said he had a red on RS though. I thought that there was no reason for him to check RS but at the same time, I didn't believe RS instantly saying she was framed either because I feel like if mafia believed that GB was cop, since RS wasn't on GB's radar, framer wouldn't use his power on RS and would use it on some town in GB's scum circle unless they're all scum. <- not that the last part matters since he's not claiming RS red

xP i said he was either scum or i was framed

i'm mason

there's simply no possibility of me coming back red unless there's a framer or...well i guess technically gb is faking the red check lol >< but i didn't think he'd fake a red check on me as town that's just mean -_-

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

June 23 2015 05:09 GMT

#3459

Nydus in case you haven't caught up she claimed Mason with Fidei before the GB stuff so she's town lol. Also she is hard to lynch as either alignment outside of her claim simply because of her nature I guess lol.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

June 23 2015 05:10 GMT

#3460

On June 23 2015 14:03 NydusHerMain wrote:
Would it be more interesting to give my reads prior to the checks or just start from scratch and look for a GB team vs a HF team?

ummmmm

maybe from the perspective of the "checks" since you'll be looking at the information with new eyes and may see things we missed without that information? i mean you won't be able to forget it now, anyway