|
On June 11 2015 01:40 boxerfred wrote:
Why exactly is marv town, jat?
You will probably not like the reason. Ok, first of all he is putting in quite a bit of effort even though we lynched mafia day1 and it is his second consecutive scumgame. He could do that as scum but it is something.
But more importantly the reason I scumread him early day1 can be explained by what he said about not being joyful as town. Dick move analysis says he would not try to convince me that this is the case with the argument that he wants to retire from playing mafia. I just do not think he would do that. If he did, fine. It will never work again. But I doubt it. And fortunately if we lynch his partner he will probably concede anyways - it will get easier to lynch him the longer he lives. So I do not concern myself too much with doubting him.
|
On June 11 2015 02:11 VayneAuthority wrote:
well i suck at actual scumhunting, back to gut reads.
mig train choo choo
Fuba and boxer will both have to go before I even consider lynching mig.
|
fuba is fine, wouldnt lynch boxer. putting him under too naive and troll to be scum for better or worse
|
If I had to rank them I'd say Fuba or Mig for reasons previously posted over BF, but the questionable voting...if he's a troll yeah he could be hiding scum play under the guise of trolling.
Though even if you had to consider that the switch to marv d2 was pure troll the fact he just asked why marv is town makes me wonder if he was really trolling. At least I am taking that post on the previous page more seriously given marv's response.
|
EBWOP - questionable voting on chez and marv by BF....if he's a troll
|
I know BF had that exchange though with JAT and that seemed entirely unproductive. Might need to double check D1...
|
The no-lynch post was another thing I didn't like. Almost forgot.
|
Alright, read on Artanis is reasonable but the case on Yamato plus (JAT called him for this already) associative reads based off that could be TMI for him. Ugh.
|
|
|
On June 11 2015 01:42 marvellosity wrote:ask yourself, you went through my filter and came to the town conclusion
nah it's not about this. I wanna know why jat thinks it.
|
On June 11 2015 02:14 justanothertownie wrote:You will probably not like the reason. Ok, first of all he is putting in quite a bit of effort even though we lynched mafia day1 and it is his second consecutive scumgame. He could do that as scum but it is something. But more importantly the reason I scumread him early day1 can be explained by what he said about not being joyful as town. Dick move analysis says he would not try to convince me that this is the case with the argument that he wants to retire from playing mafia. I just do not think he would do that. If he did, fine. It will never work again. But I doubt it. And fortunately if we lynch his partner he will probably concede anyways - it will get easier to lynch him the longer he lives. So I do not concern myself too much with doubting him.
hmkay
|
On June 11 2015 02:52 boxerfred wrote:Show nested quote +On June 11 2015 01:42 marvellosity wrote:On June 11 2015 01:40 boxerfred wrote:
Why exactly is marv town, jat? ask yourself, you went through my filter and came to the town conclusion nah it's not about this. I wanna know why jat thinks it.
Why?
|
JAT, I see why you don't like BF, but where do you stand on Mig that you'd put him behind the other two?
|
Eh, BF just answered his own question.
|
On June 11 2015 02:53 boxerfred wrote:Show nested quote +On June 11 2015 02:14 justanothertownie wrote:On June 11 2015 01:40 boxerfred wrote:
Why exactly is marv town, jat? You will probably not like the reason. Ok, first of all he is putting in quite a bit of effort even though we lynched mafia day1 and it is his second consecutive scumgame. He could do that as scum but it is something. But more importantly the reason I scumread him early day1 can be explained by what he said about not being joyful as town. Dick move analysis says he would not try to convince me that this is the case with the argument that he wants to retire from playing mafia. I just do not think he would do that. If he did, fine. It will never work again. But I doubt it. And fortunately if we lynch his partner he will probably concede anyways - it will get easier to lynch him the longer he lives. So I do not concern myself too much with doubting him. hmkay
And where does that put you with respect to JAT and Marv?
|
On June 11 2015 02:54 Half the Sky wrote:
JAT, I see why you don't like BF, but where do you stand on Mig that you'd put him behind the other two?
It's all in my filter. He tried to get a lynch going day1 and made that case on me day2 and I don't think he does this if he is scum and knows I am town and universally townread. I don't have a strong townread on him or anything but it is enough to make him a way worse lynch than fuba or boxer or maybe even FF.
|
On June 11 2015 02:57 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On June 11 2015 02:54 Half the Sky wrote:
JAT, I see why you don't like BF, but where do you stand on Mig that you'd put him behind the other two? It's all in my filter. He tried to get a lynch going day1 and made that case on me day2 and I don't think he does this if he is scum and knows I am town and universally townread. I don't have a strong townread on him or anything but it is enough to make him a way worse lynch than fuba or boxer or maybe even FF.
Got it. I have zero experience with him, so I wasn't sure if you were seeing something in him that I was not.
|
On June 11 2015 02:59 Half the Sky wrote:Show nested quote +On June 11 2015 02:57 justanothertownie wrote:On June 11 2015 02:54 Half the Sky wrote:
JAT, I see why you don't like BF, but where do you stand on Mig that you'd put him behind the other two? It's all in my filter. He tried to get a lynch going day1 and made that case on me day2 and I don't think he does this if he is scum and knows I am town and universally townread. I don't have a strong townread on him or anything but it is enough to make him a way worse lynch than fuba or boxer or maybe even FF. Got it. I have zero experience with him, so I wasn't sure if you were seeing something in him that I was not.
I only played one game with him. I remember him being a little townier there but I did not reread his filter from that game.
|
The D2 case I effectively debunked before he went for Chez, though. Or rather I criticised for him not taking in all the parts of your push on Artanis into account. To me that looked bad alone plus the vote on chez, but I'll re-read D1.
|
On June 11 2015 03:02 Half the Sky wrote:
The D2 case I effectively debunked before he went for Chez, though. Or rather I criticised for him not taking in all the parts of your push on Artanis into account. To me that looked bad alone plus the vote on chez, but I'll re-read D1.
Of course the case wasn't good. But why make a case on the universal townread - what's his plan there?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
