Witchcraft Mini Mafia III - Page 4

On June 11 2015 16:29 yamato77 wrote:
As for what Bill would have done, that argument is complete WIFOM and presupposes that you have some sort of knowledge of how Bill plays scum, which I almost certainly have more of than you.

I do think Bill would play like he did D1 as mafia. He was overall directionless and was playing solely to fuck up the game. He even once claimed he was requesting a replacement in the thread which is basically as low as you get in terms of faking being butthurt.

As far as him having a plan, I immediately direct you to Assassination mafia where mafia BM fires a nuke only hours into D1 without consulting his team whatsoever, and then fires a second nuke at his own teammate once the first one is shot down. No, I don't think Bill has plans as scum, he just plays disruptively and tries to play off WIFOM. Seems pretty effective given you read him town for it, haha.

I also do think that mafia may have at some point wanted to save LS for his KP but may have not succeeded. Like I said earlier, I don't necessarily believe you are mafia but if you were your only play is to vote against WBG so you voting with your scum team isn't all that implausible. Bill can vote wherever he pleases because no one honestly expects him as town to be all that rational and he also probably can't vote with WBG given his play throughout the day.

On June 11 2015 16:37 yamato77 wrote:

Ad hominem and logical fallacies are not scum tells, especially for bugs, lol.

Bill focusing on such an irrelevant point is something against him in my book.