Generic Boring Mini Mafia - Page 3

On May 20 2015 03:51 Palmar wrote:
Can we have less talk about things that don't matter and more talk about how much we're going to lynch Vivax?

On May 20 2015 03:57 sciberbia wrote:

1) You didn't answer the question: what was your opinion of Damdred's alignment when you made that post?
2) Also, what are you referring to "fixing" if not your vote on Damdred?

3) Lastly, why did you want to know Stutters' opinion of Damdred? You never show any interest on Stutters anywhere else in your filter? You never push or defend Damdred. Why, of everything that you could possibly comment on when you returned to the thread, did you want to know Stutters' read on Damdred?

On May 20 2015 04:19 Qwerty! wrote:
It seems that I'm only reading at the rate that you guys are posting... this isn't working.

are we actually killing vivax? would much rather kill obi

##vote ObiWanShinobi

On May 20 2015 04:22 sciberbia wrote:

No the problem is not that you left your vote on Damdred. Here is the problem.

You supposedly have a leaning town read on Damdred. However, Damdred is under a great deal of attack from several people in the thread. There are 4 votes on him and it looks like he might even be lynched.

Do you defend your townread? No
Do you question people as to why they are calling Damdred scum? No

You question someone as to why they said they WON'T lynch your town read. That is very odd and not a natural townie instict. The townie instinct if you see one of your leaning town reads being bandwaggoned is to defend him, or at the very least question people who are attacking him. But question people who are defending him? That's just not a natural response.

Then your wording as to how Damdred plausibly could be town, under normal usage of this phrase, really implies that you do not think Damdred is town. Finally, it is really awkward that you say this in the context of justifying leaving your vote on Damdred longer.

Obi: troll vote on damdred
Obi: even though damdred might be town, I'm going to leave my troll vote on him a little longer

It really really bothers me.

To everyone else, I agree Obi seems carefree/laid back. It is one of the reservations I have about him being mafia. But notice when that now, after I got 3 votes on him, is when he becomes much more active/responsive. It's suspicious.

On May 20 2015 04:33 GlowingBear wrote:
Damdy your read on Vivax can change when he has done nothing new yet.

Lol.

Anyway, you have my sword, Palmar. I still think Shockey is more likely to be Mafia but there is not enough time to get him + my persuasion skills sucks

On May 20 2015 05:09 Qwerty! wrote:
you know better than that for two reasons

1. i switched to vivax as the 9th vote or 10th vote, smth like that... if i wanted to look good i just never would have switched to vivax in the first place
2. maybe if people actually bothered trying to post there could have been a vote switch... enough ppl were online

On May 20 2015 05:12 sciberbia wrote:


This is very wrong. Anybody who is not a complete moron would know that nobody is going to say "Great job Qwerty! You knew he was town. If only we had listened to you!"

On the contrary, anyone who has played any amount of mafia here should know that people are going to be raising eyebrows at his vote switch. Precisely because it is such an eye-catching and arguably bad play, I honestly think he is town.

I'm not saying we should have switched votes or that his vote switch was a good play. But I think he is town.

Actually reading his posts on this page I feel pretty strongly that he is town.

On May 20 2015 05:14 sciberbia wrote:


Show me a few examples of mafia spazzing out in reaction to a last second reads post and asking for a vote switch.

If you can, then I will consider changing my read on Qwerty.

On May 20 2015 23:55 ShoCkeyy wrote:



Both Palmar and Obi are mafia.

After you question obi:


Why doesn't he want to be lynched? So the mafia can continue to win of course. I don't care if I get lynched cause at least everything I've said will help town in the future, the point is to win. While obi just seems like he wants to survive to the last day

Vivax's first vote was for Obi:




Are you? really?

Why would Palmar decide to just provide a case against Vivax? Because he was going after his partner. Just like what happened to me on day one. I went after Palmar and Palmar and Obi followed - as they still do so now. It was easy to remove on town person they knew was town, he wasn't as active as others and his style was not what people were used to, which made it easier to pin him as mafia. Of course everyone bought into that random mumbo jumbo and lynched our VT.

Either way, I'm still sticking to my votes and still will be going after Palmar and Obi.

On May 21 2015 03:31 Damdred wrote:
Not even a comment on my post obi sadness

On May 20 2015 15:02 Qwerty! wrote:
cant say i was expecting scrib to defend me like that, but ive been successfully pocketed

ObiWanShinobi is scum mostly because of scriberbias case. i noticed two additional reasons.

1. inconsistent tone

obi normally plays as he pleases, and is willing to be aggressive, disagree with people, and doesnt really care what others think of him. this game has many examples of this. however, there is one post that is a major departure from this:i dont really see this post coming from a town obi at all (given the tone of the rest of his posts this game). Town can be headstrong and stubborn, town can be apologetic and meek, but its really hard to see both in such a short time period.

And it's not like obi put out enough content to fully correct his being useless, but his tone completely reverted to his original complete confidence.

2. i feel a tone change once the lynch started shifting to vivax. this isnt necessarily an issue, but obi's tone (to me) seems to be smug, which isnt really fitting for a townie who was just up for lynch.

---

as for onegu... i checked my meta more carefully, and i was mistaken about the frequency that he complains about being town. this is pretty embarrassing...

still, its a point against him, and im suspicious of him.

another reason he is scummy is how aggressively he commented on plynches and inactives (his second read of the game is on me), when i know that he hates inactives, shown by this post from Student Mafia VIII.
And from this game:I bolded the inconsistency. I find it really strange that onegu is inconsistent about how his stance on less active players,
And a final example. From someone who hates plynching inactives?

By the time of the lynch, Onegu expressed suspicions on the following:
Qwerty!
GlowingBear
Sealoz
Shockey
Vivax
Oatsmaster
Palmar (more on this later)
scriberbia

I don't really see a sense of direction here at all. he's fanning out and giving him as many lynch choices as possible.

He's also really heavily following the thread sentiment on all of his votes (Sealoz and then Vivax). Policy voting me isnt enough to change this.

Finally, his discussion with palmar makes no sense. First he seems disappointed that Palmar disappeared, and he says that he disagreed with Palmar's first read. Palmar never explains his Damdred scumread. Still, Onegu alternates between begging Palmar to come back and solve the game and being potentially willing to lynch him.

---

my head is hurting (i got a cold ), this is about it from me for tonight, i think. will answer any questions though.

not really sure about the third mafia yet, though some of stutters' early posts were really suspicious (specifically the way he referenced how assassination mafia changed his mindset).