Newbie Student Mafia X - Page 6

On May 28 2015 15:38 Sulfurus wrote:
I probably should have taken the time to explain my votes earlier.

Remember on D1 the vote was 6 for Scott and 3 for Dis with most people giving no indication of changing so there is nothing I can do to change who dies. But what I can do is give my reads more weight to them by voting my top scum (who unfortunately for me turned out to be cop).

On D2 it is true that I was AFK for the whole Bunnies vs. Murray ordeal however both were on my lynch list so technically I would have been fine with either getting lynch. However I have a feeling that if I was present I would have changed my opinion.

Speaking of changing opinions I realize that the list I linked looks pretty bad in light of recent events (I am pretty certain that BS is legit for reasons others have stated) so it looks like I will have to take some time off to do some rereading and hopefully come up with a list of scum that doesn't make people want to instalynch me.

On May 28 2015 19:55 disformation wrote:
Also town rb and gf stuff:
Since batsnacks is 100% the cop and we 100% have masons, that makes it extremely unlikely we also have a town rb (that can block mafia kp!). Thus I agree that we have 2 mafia rb. Which makes it a bit more unlikely we have mafia rb/rb/gf.

By taking out the people with claims,checks, etc. the people left are:
ticktoc
boxerfred
Sulfurus
sicklucker
disformation

That is like a 2/5 to lynch mafia. If one of those is the town mason and claims, we are down to basically a 50% chance of hitting mafia.
In my case, if I take myself out (since I know I'm town) and you are the mason. I have only 3 targets left. Look at my huge wall a few pages ago.
Even if there is a GF, one of those 3 is 100% mafia.

On May 28 2015 20:42 disformation wrote:
Yo. plotspot.


I am getting a bit annoyed right now. This game is basically solvable using some logic, but we are having a bunch of (presumably) town trying to make it as hard as possible to the very last minute.
I kinda want to go in a corner and cry for a bit.

On May 28 2015 20:58 plotspot wrote:
Bats like how does SL confirm to you he is not town RB? He should just confirm, it's no risk I promise.

On May 28 2015 20:59 sicklucker wrote:


im not splots it was jokes

On May 29 2015 02:09 disformation wrote:


At the time of posting that I was very sure that lynching according to my huge wall would bring town a victory. And I don't like the tone. =p

On May 29 2015 02:06 disformation wrote:


In your case you can totally take yourself out and leave me in the pool.
Was trying to imply that with "I take myself out (since I know I'm town)". Should have been more clear.
"Even if there" at the time I was highly doubting the existence of a GF.

Currently very unsure. Likely to drop the role speculation stuff altogether and return to look at who looks really scummy and so on, since I feel all the role speculation stuff will lead into a trap.

On May 28 2015 21:51 disformation wrote:
Shit. I'll have to think about this a lot when I get home later.
##unvote for now...

On May 28 2015 23:09 Tictock wrote:
I think I got a good enough answer out of Plots to poke holes in his claim to be Town RB.

I'm a little biased here though, so I encourage Town to see if they think plots claim holds.

I believe he is Mafia RB trying to fakeclaim Town RB.

RB,RB, Goon vs Cop & Masons sounds fairly balanced, no?

On May 28 2015 23:12 Tictock wrote:
If that is true it would mean BF is likely the last scum, since plots is so sure he will CC me.

On May 28 2015 23:19 plotspot wrote:

I'm sorry I confused you disformation. Yes I town read him there, but I observed something about him that raised my suspicion, but since I am Town RB I may not always post what I find suspicious next just to RB it. It may give away my that I'm the RB. You see I was terrified that Mafia would discover me on the account of this post about Rels here right after she died:



If for some reason Mafia thought:"who the fuck would RB this guy? Like who, wait a minute: Maybe he blocked himself to establish a story? That would look so bad. Why would he waste a block on himself? Hey maybe he blocked Rels. Yeah that's it he scumread her after she died remember? He even said he would have shot her if he was Vig. So if this guy is RB he would definitely have blocked her. Now that she is dead, no one can tell if he lied or not, but he establishes himself as town. Hehe; this guy is so dead"

Ok I'm sorry for all the mucus earlier. I apologize for my bad behavior. I shouldn't have done this. It was just I work for it all night and posted what I thought was the solution for us at 4:00 am (4hours after D3). You guys don't believe I am the RB and blocked Barakos? I can even semi-prove it, but I'd rather not as it gives away some info for possible future mafia. Please allow me some secrecy in that regard.

On May 28 2015 23:38 plotspot wrote:
Okay let's assume this:
Tictock Mason
plotspot RB
disformation VT
27ninjabunnies VT
sicklucker VT
batsnacks Cop
Barakos VT

---
wouldn't that leave: Sulfurus and boxerfred left as Mafia?

On May 28 2015 23:47 27ninjabunnies wrote:
So wwe have

Cop
Town RB
MAson
Mason

IT could be possible to have these many roles in a setup.

But plots claim throws me off.
We asked MULTIPLE time for a RB claim, and it took him that long of talking when he could have outed earlier?
Also, claiming he himself was roleblocked just seems like mafia play rather than a town play there.

Could we very well have 2 mafia roleblockers?

I don't know why yall are on me. Im town.

The reason why I voted on dis was the lack of actual townieness to me day 1 and the connection with BF (who is still alive btw)

You may not like my reasoning, but that's it.

On May 29 2015 00:50 disformation wrote:
plotspot: could you explain why boxerfred was the second mason in your opinion? imo you never bothered to explain that.

On May 29 2015 02:14 boxerfred wrote:

Well I just did that . I think dropping the role speculation is a good thing - we have solid claims in cop and RB and mason, so all that is left is speculating about which role for which player would make sense.

On May 29 2015 07:11 Tictock wrote:
I'm a little on the fence about BF's rapid fire posting on page 83. There is a lot of stuff being said but I'm not sure how many real points of deeper thought I can see, it's more like hes just reacting. That's NAI, I'm just having a hard time reading through it kus it's a bit all over the place.

@ BF
You mention you brought up questions you wanted answered. I feel like i lost them in your like 20 post spam. Can you restate please?

I also want to remind you that while i for a moment considered you and plots as potential scum team, I dismissed it the next post. It was only based on what plots has said, and if he is scum it could have been a move to push you into the limelight after he gets lynched.

I'd also like you to critically look at the 3 claims made today, you've been wanting to do roles stuff for the past few phases, now is your chance. Look through each claim and tell me what makes you think the claim could be legit and what could not be legit. If you need to get more info to reach a conclusion, now is the time to ask.

On May 29 2015 07:39 Tictock wrote:
@ BF
Thanks for your thoughts and reposting your questions.

I'm around for a bit longer, but then i need to get some RL stuff done.

Anything for me before I go?
^This is to everyone

On May 29 2015 07:39 disformation wrote:


First question was alreay answered by me here:




Thanks.

On May 29 2015 21:52 Tictock wrote:
Last thought before I go away.

Nobody claimed RB until N2.

This was well after I started an unhealthy discussion regarding setup speculation.