|
On February 01 2015 00:01 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On January 31 2015 23:51 Damdred wrote:
I like hts posts seem ok at this point town pile for now.
Tr just isn't here in a way I feel is towny, posts lack focus and intent and promises contribution later days. Really don't like it and under the radar Fair enough. He's done the under the radar thing as town before. He's trying to change his gameplay, which is the interesting bit to me, but I'm not seeing the more vocal, contributive Truffle that he claims he wants to be. Talk to me about Palmar. You keep saying you're interested in possibly lynching people without saying why. As for HTS...she reads more town to me when she's scum. So I don't think she's my lynch today. Still...underwhelming.
I feel like HTS is town this game although the last I gave her a town read Day 1 she fucked me over as scum and not quite forgiven her for that but you know I never played with scum HTS before that game so what can I say. Can you tell me why you're right and I'm wrong about our reads on HTS?
|
Hts posts are good I think.
Also Palmar is a policy lynch at best it's pretty obvious.
|
On January 31 2015 23:57 marvellosity wrote:
I could kill rsoultin for being boring.
 Cool story, bro.
Now, palmar. 'splain plz. 'less you're cool with him explaining you for you.
|
Damdred what you think of rsoultin and me?
|
On February 01 2015 00:03 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2015 00:01 rsoultin wrote:On January 31 2015 23:51 Damdred wrote:
I like hts posts seem ok at this point town pile for now.
Tr just isn't here in a way I feel is towny, posts lack focus and intent and promises contribution later days. Really don't like it and under the radar Fair enough. He's done the under the radar thing as town before. He's trying to change his gameplay, which is the interesting bit to me, but I'm not seeing the more vocal, contributive Truffle that he claims he wants to be. Talk to me about Palmar. You keep saying you're interested in possibly lynching people without saying why. As for HTS...she reads more town to me when she's scum. So I don't think she's my lynch today. Still...underwhelming. I feel like HTS is town this game although the last I gave her a town read Day 1 she fucked me over as scum and not quite forgiven her for that but you know I never played with scum HTS before that game so what can I say. Can you tell me why you're right and I'm wrong about our reads on HTS?
Are we disagreeing?
Our reasons for saying she's probably town (or at least may not be scum, in my case) are different, but the conclusion is more or less the same.
She's not screaming town to me. The only game I was hard townreading her early on was her scum game. Ergo I'm not interested in lynching her today.
|
Rs is super boring and kinda meh to me. I'm not sure if I would lynch him today but not the town rs I generally see.
LS you could be town but IDK you are playing different but wouldn't lynch you yet
|
Damdred - On Fecalfeast, I'm not sure his first post
On January 31 2015 07:11 Fecalfeast wrote:
So I am thinking scum!damdred wouldn't talk about scum strategy in thread, what's the point as scum to talk about what scum knows and needs to confirm in thread? The over-explaination doesn't feel scummy to me idk
I would think overexplanation of things is generally a scum trait, but it could be faulty reasoning.
Not much to glean from most of his posts at the moment. I get this thought of laziness from the first few hours of the game.
This quote is also a potential issue:
On January 31 2015 13:14 Fecalfeast wrote:
Can I just be your hype man this game HF? I'll stand behind you looking tough and intimidating while sporadically interjecting with generic agreements.
Now as I said, I'm reading HF as town. But the issue with this quote is a few things:
1 not an interest to solve the game himself
2 HF obv not confirmed town - if both are scum, this could be quite dangerous
3 Could be a scum trying to take advantage of a possible incorrect read by HF
On these two quotes, he doesn't look so good, but let's see if he picks things up.
|
That's good thoughts not sure if it makes ff Scum at this point but I like the read progression.
Would you lynch robik hts
|
Okay, HtS, I stand corrected.
I like where your head is on your reads on me and FF. You get a town pass today.
|
Same question to you rsoul
|
On February 01 2015 00:10 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2015 00:03 LightningStrike wrote:On February 01 2015 00:01 rsoultin wrote:On January 31 2015 23:51 Damdred wrote:
I like hts posts seem ok at this point town pile for now.
Tr just isn't here in a way I feel is towny, posts lack focus and intent and promises contribution later days. Really don't like it and under the radar Fair enough. He's done the under the radar thing as town before. He's trying to change his gameplay, which is the interesting bit to me, but I'm not seeing the more vocal, contributive Truffle that he claims he wants to be. Talk to me about Palmar. You keep saying you're interested in possibly lynching people without saying why. As for HTS...she reads more town to me when she's scum. So I don't think she's my lynch today. Still...underwhelming. I feel like HTS is town this game although the last I gave her a town read Day 1 she fucked me over as scum and not quite forgiven her for that but you know I never played with scum HTS before that game so what can I say. Can you tell me why you're right and I'm wrong about our reads on HTS? Are we disagreeing? Our reasons for saying she's probably town (or at least may not be scum, in my case) are different, but the conclusion is more or less the same. She's not screaming town to me. The only game I was hard townreading her early on was her scum game. Ergo I'm not interested in lynching her today.
I thought you weren't townreading her my bad on misreading your posts T_T.
|
Also rs marv said his reason in his filter about Palmar begging out of a lynch? You don't like his reasons or missed it?
|
Robik hard claimed. It's early to hard claim. I've only played one game with Robik so far (can't talk about that game, it's in progress) but he struck me as a low post count person.
If he's town he could be hard claiming and just being lazy. Thing is, he's not doing a whole lot so far. He voted you, and based on what I know, he's not pushing you. So that's a possible red flag. Think he said something along the lines of "it only matters to me or something" and then when HF calls him out, he talks about formatting. So I'm confused there.
Also of all the other things he's said, I looked at these:
On January 31 2015 07:00 IAmRobik wrote:Cause your case revolves around him talking about the setup, and while his posts aren't useful, they're not scummy.
On January 31 2015 07:08 IAmRobik wrote:Show nested quote +On January 31 2015 07:02 Holyflare wrote:On January 31 2015 07:00 Eden1892 wrote:On January 31 2015 06:53 Holyflare wrote:super serious time On January 31 2015 06:05 Damdred wrote:
Voting damdred is good especially when i'm motivated to do things.
I feel good this game and will be happy to play town.
But yea the other blue named role should probably claim with robik if there is one. trying to get blues to claim On January 31 2015 06:07 Damdred wrote:
Well I guess finding out the setup isn't that important. But anyway but then says setup isn't important On January 31 2015 06:14 Damdred wrote:
I am having to go to work for a bit I should be able to make it back for voice in a bit though.
Also people put way to much emphasis on blue play, and if they are claiming named VT or the blue VT it helps narrow down the setup for everyone which scum already knows anyway meh. still talks about setup and repeats the same thing On January 31 2015 06:15 Damdred wrote:
Scum will know the setup PARTIALLY by know there own makeup, and when robik claimed they were able to figure out and if edens claim is true they pretty much know it at this point. explains the same thing AGAIN On January 31 2015 06:18 Damdred wrote:
Oh my god let me explain the setup talk
A) 1 That One Program, 1 Proprietary, Intermittently-Functional Driver, 1 OS X, 1 tar, 1 | grep, 8 Linux Distros
B) 2 That One Programs, 1 Proprietary, Intermittently-Functional Driver, 1 Favored Distro, 1 tar, 8 Linux Distros
C) 2 That One Programs, 1 Proprietary, Intermittently-Functional Driver, 1 Favored Distro, 1 | grep, 8 Linux Distros
D) 1 That One Program, 1 Proprietary, Intermittently-Functional Driver, 1 OS X, 2 Favored Distros, 8 Linux Distros
If scum has a godfather setup (A and D) and has two distros claim the setup is known that it has to be D. If they dont' have a godfather they know its between B and C. And if more than one distro claims it really doesn't matter just the doc or cop know what the setup is just as likely as the scum does at that point.
So yea even when you take in the next part you can rule out setup A for sure. Etc., just logically AND AGAIN!!! :O On January 31 2015 06:21 Damdred wrote:
Of course I always lynch mafia or at least give good thoughts when I can! then he lies right to my face! bro is totally mafia cz role fishing and over explanation after he said it wasn't important at all
##vote damdred Wat. Setup spec isn't role fishing bruh. I didn't think he was actually role fishing he totally fished for roles until i said not to and then went onto setup speculation after saying it was bad and then continued to talk about it after saying it was bad vote him When I first started here, I would say setup speculation was really scummy. But then I realized that most TLers suck at mafia, so I can see why they would default to talking about shit that doesn't matter
First quote seems noncomittal, I feel and second quote he's making a generalisation when you were the one that made the quote. I think he'd have been more town if he specifically commented on YOU making that quote.
|
On February 01 2015 00:21 Damdred wrote:
Same question to you rsoul
No. I see no point in lynching a claimed role Day 1.
For being the amazing town leader to sheep to victory, he's been especially useless, and I'd probably lynch him later if he continues as he is, but not today.
|
Damdred - I want to talk about Trfel, but I need to bolt for the pilates class.
Will touch on that when I return.
|
On February 01 2015 00:11 Damdred wrote:
Rs is super boring and kinda meh to me. I'm not sure if I would lynch him today but not the town rs I generally see.
LS you could be town but IDK you are playing different but wouldn't lynch you yet
My Great Uncle was over at my house so ofc my activity took a hit because I was hanging out with them and I don't got a scum qt so I aint scum this game at all. My reasoning might be a bit weak though yes but I feel like you are much more motivated this game than Student V and so does Marv but HF I like him so far but the last town I gave him a Day 1 townread he was scum (Carol of the Bell) so I need to seem his progress this game to see difference between his play at Carol and here.
|
@Damdred
Okay, yeah, I did miss that. Probably because I still have trouble sheeping what others say others' meta are, so tend to disregard it.
However, Palmar appealing to me when I asked marv to explain his read better is kind of funny, given the arrogance I associate with Palmar.
|
I'm not really commenting on your activity LS, it's not horrible and you don't lie about rl things. So what I have been commenting on when it comes to you is a marked change in your posting at this point, reads are a bit different which isn't bad. It should just give people pause when reading you.
|
Actually yeah, Palmar post made me chuckle which makes me want to not lynch him.
|
On February 01 2015 00:25 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2015 00:11 Damdred wrote:
Rs is super boring and kinda meh to me. I'm not sure if I would lynch him today but not the town rs I generally see.
LS you could be town but IDK you are playing different but wouldn't lynch you yet My Great Uncle was over at my house so ofc my activity took a hit because I was hanging out with them and I don't got a scum qt so I aint scum this game at all. My reasoning might be a bit weak though yes but I feel like you are much more motivated this game than Student V and so does Marv but HF I like him so far but the last town I gave him a Day 1 townread he was scum (Carol of the Bell) so I need to seem his progress this game to see difference between his play at Carol and here.
I'm liking HF cause he's not focusing on one thing to the exclusion of all others. He tunneled hard as scum Day 1 the only other game I've played with him in.
This doesn't look like that game to me.
I don't know that he's incapable of this as scum, and given his scum win record I'd say it's not enough for a hard townread. But I don't want to lynch him today, for sure.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
