EPTOn January 19 2015 15:33 DarthPunk wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 19 2015 06:39 DarthPunk wrote:
@ geript.
I don't like this post
Because it isn;t what I thought when I saw JJB's list when I read it I was like this dude is just paraphrasing geript.
and his follow up is wishy-washy
I like thses posts though
Seems like good reads for the mos tpart and displays a kind of fearless tone I would expect from town.
These posts:
]
Show he is willing to re-evaluate based on new or different information
I actually wouldn't want to lynch him today.
@ geript.
I don't like this post
On January 17 2015 21:16 LoneMeow wrote:
So your major reads are a summary of what people have done so far? No one is scum or town? Then why call them reads?
On January 17 2015 19:04 jarjarbinks wrote:
Those were the major reads I got from what I have read up to when I started posting. I'm tired so I will not elaborate on the other people who have posted besides basic thoughts.
Gereipt: Your analysis seems fair. I feel like you would do this no matter what game you play. I haven't played this game to know if you left something out (if your mafia). So I can't give you a solid town or mafia read for now.
Lonemeow: Only defended Trfel and questioned Rsoultin's questioning. Probably due to lack of playing with Rsoultin. This is a possible lurker in my eyes. I guess we shall find out tomorrow.
CoolITLname- definite lurker! Or you know, could be sleeping or something...lol WE SHALL SEE
Waffle- Tried to ask LS a question to establish credibility. Let's see what he does.
DP- I liked gereipts analysis on DP. Very jumpy on Rsoultin for questioning Trfel as well as "missed" Trfel "making waves". Possible she could have just jumped on Rsoultin for the same reasons Rsoultin jumped on Trfel thought.
Those were the major reads I got from what I have read up to when I started posting. I'm tired so I will not elaborate on the other people who have posted besides basic thoughts.
Gereipt: Your analysis seems fair. I feel like you would do this no matter what game you play. I haven't played this game to know if you left something out (if your mafia). So I can't give you a solid town or mafia read for now.
Lonemeow: Only defended Trfel and questioned Rsoultin's questioning. Probably due to lack of playing with Rsoultin. This is a possible lurker in my eyes. I guess we shall find out tomorrow.
CoolITLname- definite lurker! Or you know, could be sleeping or something...lol WE SHALL SEE
Waffle- Tried to ask LS a question to establish credibility. Let's see what he does.
DP- I liked gereipts analysis on DP. Very jumpy on Rsoultin for questioning Trfel as well as "missed" Trfel "making waves". Possible she could have just jumped on Rsoultin for the same reasons Rsoultin jumped on Trfel thought.
So your major reads are a summary of what people have done so far? No one is scum or town? Then why call them reads?
Because it isn;t what I thought when I saw JJB's list when I read it I was like this dude is just paraphrasing geript.
and his follow up is wishy-washy
On January 17 2015 22:18 LoneMeow wrote:
It's on the scummier side of things, as scum he'd want to look like he's giving reads even when he really isn't. However, knowing his play in the previous game it's not as conclusive as it could be.
On January 17 2015 22:01 GlowingBear wrote:
And what do you make of it?
On January 17 2015 21:16 LoneMeow wrote:
So your major reads are a summary of what people have done so far? No one is scum or town? Then why call them reads?
On January 17 2015 19:04 jarjarbinks wrote:
Those were the major reads I got from what I have read up to when I started posting. I'm tired so I will not elaborate on the other people who have posted besides basic thoughts.
Gereipt: Your analysis seems fair. I feel like you would do this no matter what game you play. I haven't played this game to know if you left something out (if your mafia). So I can't give you a solid town or mafia read for now.
Lonemeow: Only defended Trfel and questioned Rsoultin's questioning. Probably due to lack of playing with Rsoultin. This is a possible lurker in my eyes. I guess we shall find out tomorrow.
CoolITLname- definite lurker! Or you know, could be sleeping or something...lol WE SHALL SEE
Waffle- Tried to ask LS a question to establish credibility. Let's see what he does.
DP- I liked gereipts analysis on DP. Very jumpy on Rsoultin for questioning Trfel as well as "missed" Trfel "making waves". Possible she could have just jumped on Rsoultin for the same reasons Rsoultin jumped on Trfel thought.
Those were the major reads I got from what I have read up to when I started posting. I'm tired so I will not elaborate on the other people who have posted besides basic thoughts.
Gereipt: Your analysis seems fair. I feel like you would do this no matter what game you play. I haven't played this game to know if you left something out (if your mafia). So I can't give you a solid town or mafia read for now.
Lonemeow: Only defended Trfel and questioned Rsoultin's questioning. Probably due to lack of playing with Rsoultin. This is a possible lurker in my eyes. I guess we shall find out tomorrow.
CoolITLname- definite lurker! Or you know, could be sleeping or something...lol WE SHALL SEE
Waffle- Tried to ask LS a question to establish credibility. Let's see what he does.
DP- I liked gereipts analysis on DP. Very jumpy on Rsoultin for questioning Trfel as well as "missed" Trfel "making waves". Possible she could have just jumped on Rsoultin for the same reasons Rsoultin jumped on Trfel thought.
So your major reads are a summary of what people have done so far? No one is scum or town? Then why call them reads?
And what do you make of it?
It's on the scummier side of things, as scum he'd want to look like he's giving reads even when he really isn't. However, knowing his play in the previous game it's not as conclusive as it could be.
I like thses posts though
On January 19 2015 00:44 LoneMeow wrote:
This progression on LightningStrike is is just pure bullshit. "Weak meta case" when he's in your strong town category, really? And if you actually had read his previous town games you would have instantly seen that he's playing exactly like he has done as town so far.
I'm fairly sure you didn't actually bother to get any kind of meta on him, just used that as excuse for a town read. Scum like to do that.
##Vote: Breshke
GlowingBear, I am sorry for doubting you
On January 18 2015 12:36 Breshke wrote:
TOWN
Trfel : Trying to change his play seems towny to me. I think as scum he would be more wary of doing this because as we have seen people would notice the change and ping him out for it.
LS : His meta case on me is bad in my opinion but it is the conclusion i thought he would come and to me shows he is trying to work out alignments and stuff not just trying to look town.
Damdred : I liked his case on Cool and the fact that he made people discuss it. Even though we know it was wrong I found myself agreeing with it and Cool would have been my top scum if he was still alive.
TOWN
Trfel : Trying to change his play seems towny to me. I think as scum he would be more wary of doing this because as we have seen people would notice the change and ping him out for it.
LS : His meta case on me is bad in my opinion but it is the conclusion i thought he would come and to me shows he is trying to work out alignments and stuff not just trying to look town.
Damdred : I liked his case on Cool and the fact that he made people discuss it. Even though we know it was wrong I found myself agreeing with it and Cool would have been my top scum if he was still alive.
On January 18 2015 15:07 Breshke wrote:
I read him town for some weak meta case on my being more lurky as mafia. I expected someone to try and come at me because of it and thought it was towny. That's actually a fairly shit tier read though because it isn't actually alignment indicative. Would need to look more into it but i wouldn't call him town anymore.
On January 18 2015 14:50 DarthPunk wrote:
K I just read all of Lightnings filter twice and he is not really scum hunting at all. Most of his contributions are talking about how many games people have played in/ played with him in and he talks A LOT about meta.
Can those people town reading Lightning please give me some in depth reasoning for those town reads. Cause I can't see it.
K I just read all of Lightnings filter twice and he is not really scum hunting at all. Most of his contributions are talking about how many games people have played in/ played with him in and he talks A LOT about meta.
Can those people town reading Lightning please give me some in depth reasoning for those town reads. Cause I can't see it.
I read him town for some weak meta case on my being more lurky as mafia. I expected someone to try and come at me because of it and thought it was towny. That's actually a fairly shit tier read though because it isn't actually alignment indicative. Would need to look more into it but i wouldn't call him town anymore.
This progression on LightningStrike is is just pure bullshit. "Weak meta case" when he's in your strong town category, really? And if you actually had read his previous town games you would have instantly seen that he's playing exactly like he has done as town so far.
I'm fairly sure you didn't actually bother to get any kind of meta on him, just used that as excuse for a town read. Scum like to do that.
##Vote: Breshke
GlowingBear, I am sorry for doubting you
On January 19 2015 03:06 LoneMeow wrote:
Other thoughts, well.
LightningStrike looks town by meta.
DarthPunk looks town for the way his LightningStrike read evolved when presented with evidence from other games.
Trfel I'm really torn on, the case by rsoultin has merit but Trfel puts quite a lot of effort into some of his posts which is a town trait.
rsoultin is perhaps town for his defence of LightningStrike, since if I trust my read on LightningStrike he'd just be narrowing his potential mislynch pool if he did that as scum. But that's associative between unflipped players so meh.
On January 19 2015 00:51 Damdred wrote:
.,.so you have no thoughts on anything else just spamming about older stuff?
.,.so you have no thoughts on anything else just spamming about older stuff?
Other thoughts, well.
LightningStrike looks town by meta.
DarthPunk looks town for the way his LightningStrike read evolved when presented with evidence from other games.
Trfel I'm really torn on, the case by rsoultin has merit but Trfel puts quite a lot of effort into some of his posts which is a town trait.
rsoultin is perhaps town for his defence of LightningStrike, since if I trust my read on LightningStrike he'd just be narrowing his potential mislynch pool if he did that as scum. But that's associative between unflipped players so meh.
Seems like good reads for the mos tpart and displays a kind of fearless tone I would expect from town.
These posts:
]
On January 19 2015 03:16 LoneMeow wrote:
Ah, I must've misunderstood Breshke's post. English isn't my native language. Let me rethink.
On January 19 2015 03:12 rsoultin wrote:
Okay, LM, please clarify your vote on Breshke. The way I read it, you were saying Breshke had a weak meta case on LS, when the opposite was true. (Sorry LS, <3 you, but ^^
On January 19 2015 03:06 LoneMeow wrote:
Other thoughts, well.
LightningStrike looks town by meta.
DarthPunk looks town for the way his LightningStrike read evolved when presented with evidence from other games.
Trfel I'm really torn on, the case by rsoultin has merit but Trfel puts quite a lot of effort into some of his posts which is a town trait.
rsoultin is perhaps town for his defence of LightningStrike, since if I trust my read on LightningStrike he'd just be narrowing his potential mislynch pool if he did that as scum. But that's associative between unflipped players so meh.
On January 19 2015 00:51 Damdred wrote:
.,.so you have no thoughts on anything else just spamming about older stuff?
.,.so you have no thoughts on anything else just spamming about older stuff?
Other thoughts, well.
LightningStrike looks town by meta.
DarthPunk looks town for the way his LightningStrike read evolved when presented with evidence from other games.
Trfel I'm really torn on, the case by rsoultin has merit but Trfel puts quite a lot of effort into some of his posts which is a town trait.
rsoultin is perhaps town for his defence of LightningStrike, since if I trust my read on LightningStrike he'd just be narrowing his potential mislynch pool if he did that as scum. But that's associative between unflipped players so meh.
Okay, LM, please clarify your vote on Breshke. The way I read it, you were saying Breshke had a weak meta case on LS, when the opposite was true. (Sorry LS, <3 you, but ^^
Ah, I must've misunderstood Breshke's post. English isn't my native language. Let me rethink.
On January 19 2015 03:18 LoneMeow wrote:
Right, it's far less strongly implicating him as scum now that I understood correctly, although I still don't like the way he went from "LightningStrike town" to "wouldn't call him town anymore" without any real explanation on what caused the shift.
For now,
##Unvote
On January 19 2015 03:16 LoneMeow wrote:
Ah, I must've misunderstood Breshke's post. English isn't my native language. Let me rethink.
On January 19 2015 03:12 rsoultin wrote:
Okay, LM, please clarify your vote on Breshke. The way I read it, you were saying Breshke had a weak meta case on LS, when the opposite was true. (Sorry LS, <3 you, but ^^
On January 19 2015 03:06 LoneMeow wrote:
Other thoughts, well.
LightningStrike looks town by meta.
DarthPunk looks town for the way his LightningStrike read evolved when presented with evidence from other games.
Trfel I'm really torn on, the case by rsoultin has merit but Trfel puts quite a lot of effort into some of his posts which is a town trait.
rsoultin is perhaps town for his defence of LightningStrike, since if I trust my read on LightningStrike he'd just be narrowing his potential mislynch pool if he did that as scum. But that's associative between unflipped players so meh.
On January 19 2015 00:51 Damdred wrote:
.,.so you have no thoughts on anything else just spamming about older stuff?
.,.so you have no thoughts on anything else just spamming about older stuff?
Other thoughts, well.
LightningStrike looks town by meta.
DarthPunk looks town for the way his LightningStrike read evolved when presented with evidence from other games.
Trfel I'm really torn on, the case by rsoultin has merit but Trfel puts quite a lot of effort into some of his posts which is a town trait.
rsoultin is perhaps town for his defence of LightningStrike, since if I trust my read on LightningStrike he'd just be narrowing his potential mislynch pool if he did that as scum. But that's associative between unflipped players so meh.
Okay, LM, please clarify your vote on Breshke. The way I read it, you were saying Breshke had a weak meta case on LS, when the opposite was true. (Sorry LS, <3 you, but ^^
Ah, I must've misunderstood Breshke's post. English isn't my native language. Let me rethink.
Right, it's far less strongly implicating him as scum now that I understood correctly, although I still don't like the way he went from "LightningStrike town" to "wouldn't call him town anymore" without any real explanation on what caused the shift.
For now,
##Unvote
Show he is willing to re-evaluate based on new or different information
I actually wouldn't want to lynch him today.
This is straight up bad, DP. You're trying to tell me you think that it's town for LM to completely misread Breshke, vote him on the misread, then correct himself when someone points it out? How is that a good read? He was voting Breshke for a meta case Breshke never made.
What's so amazing about his first set of reads? LS and you town for obvious reasons everyone is already saying you're town for?
If you think this makes LM town I have to wonder what you're smoking.
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/23HWoe7.jpg)
