New Years Eve Party Mini Mafia - Page 2

On January 08 2015 00:34 27ninjabunnies wrote:
Okay, here's another post from me. I was hoping others would be around so I could get some back and forth going, but eh.

First things first + Show Spoiler +
I really like that there are already basically two wagons going on SL and Lian. Good job possible towns, we might actually get something accomplished today!

Town
HTS- I'm really liking her day 1 reads. She seems thoughtful, and the reads are backed up by evidence in the thread.

Leaning town
Eden- Ive been in a game with him when he was mafia. The final 3lylo he was talking about I'm sure. So he is definitely on my watch list because in that game he came out super townie, and stayed super townie. But for right now, I've liked what he has contributed, and he wont be definitive town yet.

Leaning Scum
Mderg- I'm not really liking mdergs posts this game. One, I'm just not a big fan of oneliners. Two, Im curious as to his pressure on HTS for "obvious shitposts" or something like that, but then he turns to put pressure on lian over her. @Mdeg, what do you think of HTS now that she has given reads?

Breshke- what weirded me out most about breshke was his entrance to the thread. I mean I guess if you are gonna go hard, immediately call two people scum. Interesting entrance, but his tone (very challenging) is similar to the last game we played where he flipped mafia (that shot though). The only thing that would make me place him as town is if SL flipped scum tbh. I don't think they could be scum together.

Lian

SL

Oats?- more so for his questioning on what the point to my post was. Eden got the point. Or atleast answered.

Scum
None definitively at the moment.

I need to read more into Lian and SL, but here are my thoughts so far.
And oats needs to come back

On January 08 2015 06:59 Breshke wrote:


Meh, most of the cases on Lian are that he is acting differently to how he normally does and i have no idea if this is true or what it means because im too lazy to read past games. I don't understand why he is purposly acting like a dick because if he is town i don't think that's the way to go about getting people to listen to you but being a dick doesn't equal mafia. I do think he is town though because even though his case is shit on LS he seems to actually want people to comment on it and that feels town motivated to me. I am intrested to see what happens when he comes back to the thread though.

So i also think bunnies is town because the questions she has been asking while may not be like scum hunting are obviously there to get conversation flowing which is obviously something this game needs so im happy to call her town for now.

I was also liking Eden because he seemed to be on the same thought process as me about sicklucker but has seemingly flipped now for reasons that i feel are really weak.

Also sicklucker could you explain how you went from scum to null on LS (I've included your posts and the only one he made in between in the spoiler tag.

+ Show Spoiler +

On January 08 2015 07:07 sicklucker wrote:
oh and Ls admitted he claimed day 1 in EVERYGAME which ddefends me and makes me obvious town to anyone with a brain

On January 08 2015 08:41 liancourt wrote:


PPL come on this post is weird as fuck.

Thread sentiment was literally dead and was inactive as fuck and that's why I said it was going to be a hard game, bu tthen LS comes up with this bullshit post out of nowhere that has absolutely nothing to do with the current game. If you look at all the posts before this LS has been posting filler shit and nothing else regarding the game. Even going as far as saying how it was "worrying".



When in fact LS hasnt done jack shit up until then. Instead of pretending to "worry" scum hunting would have been better.

I havent been so sure of scum on day 1 in all my games of playing on TL.

Vote LS now or you're scum

On January 07 2015 23:39 Half the Sky wrote:


Right now, from the posts I've seen so far, I'm leaning town on Bunnies for her post evaluating the 2-3 reads she did (she's trying, no?), leaning scum on SL (previously mentioned), leaning scum on LS (his posts are a bit of fluff, plus posts that detract).

Eden, I'm leaning town, not so much because he voted SL, but his detailed post in doing so. It shows what appears to be a town-driven analysis.

Batsnacks, I will need to see more posts from him to evaluate.

Lian seemed emotional in the last game I played with him too, but his posts this time are a bit more content. He does point out flaws in LS's posts and he is reading between the lines, yes they are emotional, but Lian was emotional in Carol. For now, I'm leaning town on Lian, although I am waiting to see if someone can give me another POV on a scum meta.

On January 09 2015 05:17 Breshke wrote:


In my eyes she tried to push the thread early and shit when we were seriously lacking in activity.

I don't get this last post.



She is really defensive about irl shit with almost no one pressuring her that is odd.

I don't know if the bolded sentence refers to this game or the last game in which she vig shot me correctly. If the former she should be voting me. If the latter there was no reason to bring it up and is just filler to try justify her vote.

Still don't think i would vote her today

On January 09 2015 05:43 Breshke wrote:


Okay noted.

Do you still think HTS is scum? I don't, can you explain.

On January 09 2015 04:33 Half the Sky wrote:
OWS and DrP, this is my first time playing with him and Bats defence of him was meta. I cannot speak for the veteran votes on him, though. With three people defending him for reasons they are, I'm willing to give VA benefit of the doubt.

My thoughts:

I do not understand Bunnies' vote on Oats, but I want her to explain first.
I do not feel Oats is the D1 lynch.

Sicklucker generally needs more than one day to evaluate, Breshke I know has been scum before and a couple are scumreading him based on tone. I also feel I need another day to eval those two, Bats, OWS.

Lian...different approach...but I'm not feeling a lynch on him either.

mderg, I don't want to omgus him, but if I were to switch my name with someone else's and if I saw him say the same thing, my problem with his argument is that even for D1, the reads still show I am trying to work with what limited information I have. Saying my reads were inaccurate (i.e. Bats) is fine, though.

Eden's posts I am getting a town sense of thinking, I don't want to lynch him.

Lala has yet to post since he (she?) confirmed though. Now this is a potential modkill and if we absolutely positively have no other alternatives...

On my phone, but I'll keep my eyes open here if I can.

On January 09 2015 05:58 Half the Sky wrote:
Mderg, others have said similar things to what you have bolded. Why pick me out of the rest?

On January 09 2015 06:00 Half the Sky wrote:
EBWOP: You criticised my reads, so I am saying why your argument is a poor one.

On January 09 2015 06:00 DrParnassus wrote:


does hts showing up for pre-lynch mean anything?

On January 09 2015 06:06 Half the Sky wrote:
Mderg, I am not referring to my opening. I already responded to that saying it was a poor argument.

I am referring especially to this:



Others are saying they also want to hold off on others lynches as well. That is what I mean. Why pick me?

On January 09 2015 06:08 Half the Sky wrote:


So this is a tone argument I understand? One of my reads were based on a previous quote.

This is the first time I've played a game with you.
How reliable do you think your (tone?) read on me is?

On January 09 2015 06:20 Half the Sky wrote:
Mderg. Okay, now you are clearer, THAT I can explain.

SL, Bats, OWS, Breshke. I have played 1-2 games with each of them before.

Bats is a hard read. I have misread him in both games I've played with him.
Sicklucker posts very erratic, he has done this in both games.
Breskhe, one game played as town with him, and obs a game he was scum. Could not read him when he was scum.
OWS, played one game and badly misread him. Wasn't sure how to interpret his indifference.

Based on their posts in this game, and based on how I felt their posts were in prior games difficult to read. Not feeling different now except for SL tunnelling me and I don't understand his motives.

On January 09 2015 06:33 batsnacks wrote:


Please give reads on people other than VA in the time we have left. I don't care if you vote him but just hopping on the biggest wagon right now with no other reads is suboptimal for town.

---

On January 09 2015 06:43 lalalipop wrote:


it isn't really a big deal to miss out much of d1: most d1 lynches in all sites will come down to wagon hopping. Information in d1 is used as a comparison to d2, with the changes in n1 through PR uses and lynches.

On January 09 2015 06:49 Breshke wrote:
I also don't like mderg much. Calling out HTS on tone and filler when arguably NB has the same problem but he doesn't seem to have a problem with her.