EPTNewbie Mini Mafia LX
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Gumdrop
United States35 Posts
| ||
|
Gumdrop
United States35 Posts
I apologize. I was just informed that I only join if I type /in. | ||
|
Gumdrop
United States35 Posts
So... Hi. I am looking through the first posts, but is it realistic to use them to figure out who is scumy and who is not? This feels like Sudoku without any starting numbers. | ||
|
Gumdrop
United States35 Posts
On January 06 2015 12:28 LightningStrike wrote: Correct. I'm sorry I'm bad this game on my scum hunting hunting on Day 1 but half of the players are inactive it kind of hard to find scum unless they are active :| As a player who has been inactive up to this point, I think the inactivity is mostly due to the fact that its hard to make reads right now. There is no solid information on anything presently. That makes life difficult. | ||
|
Gumdrop
United States35 Posts
On January 06 2015 14:17 Tubesock wrote: Gumdrop, unless you step up I'm not removing my vote. ##Vote: Gumdrop I understand entirely. In your spot, it seems like the only rational option. TheShining. I concur with her belief that there's something off with Exo. Refer to post 246 for his reasoning. While I do agree with him, I can't simply give him a town pass because he built a case that is moderately secure. My verdict on TheShining is that he is probably town, but I don't want to lock him into town right now. JarJarBlinks. He is the person that I would be the second most likely to bet on right now as far as scum goes. He has posted a moderate amount, but the sum total of his posts doesn't contribute very much. Check out his posts: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/474146-newbie-mini-mafia-lx?user=jarjarbinks All of his posts but 2 are fluff posts. The first non-fluff post spent most of the time supporting a read on TheShining as being scum, probably. The rest of the time was devoted to... adding length? Of course at the top of the same post, he claimed that his reads were bad. The other post that wasn't fluff was merely crowdsourcing to get a general consensus on Celestial. TheWarWaffle. Your first reads impressed me, if for no other reason then you were able to drive to the heart of a matter based on only some slips. Thats solid. I look forward to new posts from you. Tube. You asked me which player I would lynch. I would lynch Exo_. I don't even care about the vig call, I care more about the fact that TheShining and Exo were on at very similar times when she made her daming post and he didn't respond to her. The post is now buried on the 12th page. I am signing off for the night. | ||
|
Gumdrop
United States35 Posts
| ||
|
Gumdrop
United States35 Posts
Irrelevant of that Exo_ has still yet to impress me. Vote: Exo_ | ||
|
Gumdrop
United States35 Posts
| ||
|
Gumdrop
United States35 Posts
So Gumdrop and Celestial already voted outside the wagons, Celestial has already explained away (which I need to have a further look at), but it's Gumdrop's turn, I think Tube called him earlier saying in no world would ExO be done for. It doesn't appear Gumdrop was in thread, but if you were, whom would you have voted for and what are your thoughts now? By pissing away my vote, I effectively voted for the lead. The lead for the entire time was WarWaffle. When he declared his role... it made things troublesome. Was he mafia that was trying to save his own hide? Was he actually a powerful role? Everything reeked of desperation and it wouldn't matter if he was scum or town, he would have done the exact same things to try to save himself from being lynched. I didn't agree with some of his thoughts on his only large scale analysis of peoples alignments, but thats neither here nor there now. I was paralyzed with inaction, because I didn't know what to do and none of the options seemed like good ones. Taking a look at the votes, and based off the information on how tie votes are decided that Trfel gave us, it would have taken at least two people to make a not WarWaffle lynch happen. Looking at the vote tallies from yesterday though, the last second vote changes interest me more than anything else. JarJar and Trfel, neither one of you really explained why you swapped over to join the Shinings lynch mob. You both just gave vague explanations. Can you explain further please? | ||
| ||
