EPTUr implying ninja is town in ur posts and yet u say ninja is the scummiest person in the thread. What are u trying to say why are u fence hogging?
TL Mafia LXIX: Carol Of The Bells - Page 66
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
liancourt
1563 Posts
Ur implying ninja is town in ur posts and yet u say ninja is the scummiest person in the thread. What are u trying to say why are u fence hogging? | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On December 11 2014 04:37 Holyflare wrote: you shouldn't think like this at all because that's exactly what a mafia would want to do so you're telling us that we shouldn't lynch her or put pressure on her on the off chance that she COULD be town??? you're essentially giving someone that has a super high chance of being mafia a free pass because of a possibility she could be town, which doesn't make sense at all, especially when you posted this: you have no reason to town read her... claiming a role is something scum loves to do to survive as that's their main goal, she's been bandwagoned the entire day by multiple people all day and arguably has the MOST information on her flip but you're telling us not to lynch her because she doesn't give us any info on a flip and she has claimed a role??? oh please as if that wasn't an attempt at some super obvious breadcrumb at being a carol singer "oh yeh guys just randomly while im under pressure im gonna drop this video of me carol singing in college" Alright I get that idea she wants to survive as mafia I'm not sure if she HAD to claim there as mafia maybe she could have done more to project town , in fairness every town game so far I have basically read the cop as mafia so I am just a bit paranoid. I was working through it in my head and I just thought we got a lot of information if we leave her in the game to claim her "role". I still think FF is a good lynch though. what do you think hf? kos? | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On December 11 2014 04:39 liancourt wrote: Kel u arent reacting to minor pressure very well resorting to making insults. Has it unruffled ur feathers that i m beginning to start playing the game for real and i caught u? Ur implying ninja is town in ur posts and yet u say ninja is the scummiest person in the thread. What are u trying to say why are u fence hogging? + Show Spoiler + you aren't reading the thread properly. I never implied ninja is town I brought up the fact she claimed a role. | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On December 11 2014 04:32 KelsierSC wrote: ahh post count....I think FF is also really scummy and I want more people to comment on my read of him. I tend to agree that FF is likely mafia. He moves off bunnies because of claim onto ritoky. bunnies admits she wasn't claiming, yet FF doesn't seem to find her interesting anymore. He admits his current vote on ritoky was just an attempt to get a reaction from him, but that leaves him with no actual mafia suspects. He makes that response post about templar, but I'm left wondering if he wants us to lynch templar for it or if he's just whining about how templar posts. | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
 | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On December 11 2014 04:37 Holyflare wrote: you have no reason to town read her... claiming a role is something scum loves to do to survive as that's their main goal, she's been bandwagoned the entire day by multiple people all day and arguably has the MOST information on her flip but you're telling us not to lynch her because she doesn't give us any info on a flip and she has claimed a role??? Are we at the point where we are ready to issue her an ultimatum to claim or do we give it 1-2 more hours. I certainly don't want her showing up 5 minutes before the lynch and claiming that she is Arnold or something. I'm not saying that we listen to her claim and it suddenly makes her town, but if she is going to go around saying that she might "claim to save herself" then I don't see the point of keeping quiet with so many votes on her with a few hours left. I'd rather digest what she has to say now. | ||
|
froggynoddy
United Kingdom452 Posts
Early day 1 - (when he is meant to be busy): lots of fluffy no content reads; Mid Day 1 - Comes back with something again that looks constructive but is not (see FF's deconstruction that I would tend to agree with) Late day 1 - no real pressure on him (apart from me kinda and FF kinda) - says a few things of no value - goes away (whilst this is when he was meant to be more active). Now he could be acting disaffected (similarly to myself to be fair) - but I feel like he has managed to put more time in than me yet come up with very little. The only reason I thought Rit looked bad (as per my previous post) was the timing on his LS and FF votes. It felt like he was trying to get a wagon away from NB who seems a pretty strong NB read. So if NB flips scum then I would deffo consider another look at Rit. Other than that I cannot really see anything scummy on him so not worth a day 1 vote (particularly this late into the day). I will vote Templar (as my vote doesn't seem likely to swing things towards or away from NB) as I feel he is my marginally scummier read than NB but will keep an eye on the thread until the deadline. ##Vote: The_Templar | ||
|
Tubesock
United States2726 Posts
Kelsier, I'm sorry, you're too heavily scum for me so I won't respond to you after this post. Your scum read on me is based on bad play not me being scum. Which I should be lynched/PK'd for eventually but not today. I think someone asked me about my HTS read. I think my read on her was null but after a few posts from her I'm town on her. I wanted to know why HTS was a better lynch than bunny, so I asked some randoms who were posting with coherent and thoughtful content. I also want to know why Viv thinks Xatas is a better lynch than bunny as I was towning Viv. Still am but not solidly. | ||
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
If 27nb is the scummiest why am i being voted? Is it because you know 27 is scum and just incase your scumbuddy gets killed you can be all 'see here i thought 27 was scummy' I'm sure i make contradicting reads because it's too boring to pour over the entire thread looking for nitpicky shit as town. I take everything at face value whenever i am here and reading. I'm not sure what people mean as an inconsistency between my tubesack read and my LS read but I've played with LS before and haven't with tubesack. I'm either gonna sheep back onto 27 or omgus vote you(kelly) not sure which. | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
| ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
On December 11 2014 04:47 froggynoddy wrote: If NB is town then I sure wish she would defend herself a little more than she has... I think Templar is my scummiest read. Early day 1 - (when he is meant to be busy): lots of fluffy no content reads; Mid Day 1 - Comes back with something again that looks constructive but is not (see FF's deconstruction that I would tend to agree with) Late day 1 - no real pressure on him (apart from me kinda and FF kinda) - says a few things of no value - goes away (whilst this is when he was meant to be more active). Now he could be acting disaffected (similarly to myself to be fair) - but I feel like he has managed to put more time in than me yet come up with very little. The only reason I thought Rit looked bad (as per my previous post) was the timing on his LS and FF votes. It felt like he was trying to get a wagon away from NB who seems a pretty strong NB read. So if NB flips scum then I would deffo consider another look at Rit. Other than that I cannot really see anything scummy on him so not worth a day 1 vote (particularly this late into the day). I will vote Templar (as my vote doesn't seem likely to swing things towards or away from NB) as I feel he is my marginally scummier read than NB but will keep an eye on the thread until the deadline. ##Vote: The_Templar Someone read my post on Templar's post? Holy shit it's a Christmas miracle my work was actually looked at! | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On December 11 2014 04:53 Fecalfeast wrote: I'm either gonna sheep back onto 27 or omgus vote you(kelly) not sure which. So you don't want to lynch templar? | ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
I'd lynch templar, sure | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On December 11 2014 04:47 kitaman27 wrote: Are we at the point where we are ready to issue her an ultimatum to claim or do we give it 1-2 more hours. I certainly don't want her showing up 5 minutes before the lynch and claiming that she is Arnold or something. I'm not saying that we listen to her claim and it suddenly makes her town, but if she is going to go around saying that she might "claim to save herself" then I don't see the point of keeping quiet with so many votes on her with a few hours left. I'd rather digest what she has to say now. that point is now, isn't the deadline soon? | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
| ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On December 11 2014 05:13 Koshi wrote: There are major signs that this is a town lynch. But what can we do? well that's the worst thing i've heard in a long while wtf???? lynch mafia?? | ||
|
LightningStrike
United States14277 Posts
On December 11 2014 05:13 Koshi wrote: There are major signs that this is a town lynch. But what can we do? It like me saying let's no lynch...... By the way guys the reason I not posted much this morning is because I got 4 pages in my filter and don't wait waste more posts after this one ofc. But I find it odd that Oatsmaster not really hunting for scum this game if he is town because the town Oatsmaster I know would be scum hunting already. I need to filter dive him after EoD if 27ninja gets lynched and if 27ninja is town then I will filter dive Oatsmaster really hard and if 27ninja is scum I might look at him still but not on the highest priority. | ||
|
Vivax
22106 Posts
Overall I'm willing to see where Xata and the other guys I've been calling out will be headed in the next days. Plus this game is just tiring on D1. There's no way anyone who isn't spending all his time on this game can have a good overview of everything going on, I just want this mountain of information to shrink atm, people shitposting didn't help the game. And I don't think that this looks necessarily like a town lynch cause mafia players can simply be passive about it...Or tried to get another lynch but went down in the noise and have been forgotten about. | ||
|
Xatalos
Finland9675 Posts
On December 11 2014 04:00 Koshi wrote: Xatalos. Read my posts. I gave you 3 names I wanted to lynch. If you can proof to me that OWS has a meta in which he is never less useful as town D1 I will revisit him for today. But you cant'. So stop being dumb. Thx. I'm not really familiar with his meta. I've just looked at his play in this game. If you know him better, you think his D1 play is like this in general? What separates his town and scum play in your opinion? Kush is detrimental and not the worst lynch. I'll have to look at ritoky again. What made you think nb might be town in your more recent post? | ||
| ||
