On December 10 2014 08:44 KelsierSC wrote: Right so i asked hf to explain how you made a contradiction, he explained it well. I got a town read off him.
I'm curious that you call my play "one liners " considering all my reads have been well explained. Is there a read i didn't explain enough for you.
you said something like "he needs to learn how to read me" that is really scummy, how have you projected town, what have you done that allows him to read you perfectly. . It strikes me as fake indignation that anyone can find you scum
I don't really understand how I was contradicting myself, I think I made myself perfectly clear, and HF was just trying to rip anything apart he could find.
All I can do now from here on out is try to convince you all that I town.
But it looks like I might have to claim just to stay alive. Meh.
have you finished reading? tell me who is scum and why; i don't think your kelsier read is bad, i actually don't mind it. it just isn't compelling imo. there is more than 1 scum in the game though, so who else?
On December 10 2014 08:33 batsnacks wrote: @ritoky I'm pretty sure someone asked FF for reads on those specific people.
oh i guess kita did, missed that; doesn't change that i think the reads are crap lol.
Maybe you could add to your case that FF responding to kitaman in the way he did is not consistent with his "idgaf" attitude toward others. If FF doesn't have strong reads, wouldn't it be more consistent of him to just say "fuck off" rather than spending so much time writing weak reads?
i think it's more townie of him to respond directly to kita. why he takes kita seriously and not me is a good question. the quality of his reads is bad and i don't like them in the slightest so that is scummy. and the fact that he devoted so much time to null reads on people when he can't muster his strong reads anywhere else leans scummy to me as well. so overall it nets out as scum leaning to me which just reinforced my feelings.
why he is on your no-lynch section is beyond me, i would like justification
That first sentence contradicts the rest of the sentences I think. Why is it more townie of him to respond directly to kita and not to you again?
I put FF on my no lynch list because I remember pretty much all his posts and I think the less memorable people are better to focus on right now.
On December 10 2014 08:52 KelsierSC wrote: So rather than convince us your town, as you said is what you have to-do, you aren't going to bother and just "claim" right now, good job
No I'm gonna try and convince yall I'm town, but it seems as if no one is listening to me anyway, so I might just have to claim.
What did you think about my read on Vivax? More specifically, what is your read?
Also, you mentioned earlier in the game about a read on Slam. You found it stupid there were people calling him town. What is your read on him as of this page?
Remember how HF said we shouldn't start claiming because it narrows down potential targets for the role-specific gun scum has? I'd like to reiterate that point.
On December 10 2014 08:52 KelsierSC wrote: So rather than convince us your town, as you said is what you have to-do, you aren't going to bother and just "claim" right now, good job
No I'm gonna try and convince yall I'm town, but it seems as if no one is listening to me anyway, so I might just have to claim.
What did you think about my read on Vivax? More specifically, what is your read?
Also, you mentioned earlier in the game about a read on Slam. You found it stupid there were people calling him town. What is your read on him as of this page?
This "claim" stuff is garbage. You've already pretty much claimed a role just by saying it twice now and you haven't even tried to convince people.
On December 10 2014 08:33 batsnacks wrote: @ritoky I'm pretty sure someone asked FF for reads on those specific people.
oh i guess kita did, missed that; doesn't change that i think the reads are crap lol.
Maybe you could add to your case that FF responding to kitaman in the way he did is not consistent with his "idgaf" attitude toward others. If FF doesn't have strong reads, wouldn't it be more consistent of him to just say "fuck off" rather than spending so much time writing weak reads?
i think it's more townie of him to respond directly to kita. why he takes kita seriously and not me is a good question. the quality of his reads is bad and i don't like them in the slightest so that is scummy. and the fact that he devoted so much time to null reads on people when he can't muster his strong reads anywhere else leans scummy to me as well. so overall it nets out as scum leaning to me which just reinforced my feelings.
why he is on your no-lynch section is beyond me, i would like justification
That first sentence contradicts the rest of the sentences I think. Why is it more townie of him to respond directly to kita and not to you again?
I put FF on my no lynch list because I remember pretty much all his posts and I think the less memorable people are better to focus on right now.
i don't think it contradicts at all, i find responding directly to questions and not giving more than is asked townie. he did respond and gave what was asked from kita.
as for why he chooses to respond to 1 guy and not the other, hell if i know. i am not that guy, can't tell you his thoughts.
i also remember most of his posts....in a bad way. which i think is a better reason to lynch people.
Also, to waste another post because I think in such fragments, I think this makes 27NB town because the other carol singers (WHO SHOULD NOT CLAIM UNLESS THEY KNOW 27NB IS LYING) can out her at any point since they know who the other masons carol singers are.
On December 10 2014 08:52 KelsierSC wrote: So rather than convince us your town, as you said is what you have to-do, you aren't going to bother and just "claim" right now, good job
No I'm gonna try and convince yall I'm town, but it seems as if no one is listening to me anyway, so I might just have to claim.
What did you think about my read on Vivax? More specifically, what is your read?
Also, you mentioned earlier in the game about a read on Slam. You found it stupid there were people calling him town. What is your read on him as of this page?
i think your viv read is bad, i dont understand what you are saying, he is town because of -link to post, why is that post towny, viv isn't in my town circle
On December 10 2014 08:44 KelsierSC wrote: Right so i asked hf to explain how you made a contradiction, he explained it well. I got a town read off him.
I'm curious that you call my play "one liners " considering all my reads have been well explained. Is there a read i didn't explain enough for you.
you said something like "he needs to learn how to read me" that is really scummy, how have you projected town, what have you done that allows him to read you perfectly. . It strikes me as fake indignation that anyone can find you scum
I don't really understand how I was contradicting myself, I think I made myself perfectly clear, and HF was just trying to rip anything apart he could find.
All I can do now from here on out is try to convince you all that I town.
But it looks like I might have to claim just to stay alive. Meh.
have you finished reading? tell me who is scum and why; i don't think your kelsier read is bad, i actually don't mind it. it just isn't compelling imo. there is more than 1 scum in the game though, so who else?
I haven't finished reading. I'm coming back to this page to try and stay on top of current discussion as well as look into past discussion.
I'm actually very interested in the HTS discussion and contradictions in that. I was looking through and it looks like at first there was some attack on her for saying she was town, too, in response to me. I figured it was because she read my post where I claimed town and would lead us to victory. I think if anything, she would be the next target for a mislynch, if she is town. There's already so much pressure on her, but Idk, I like her as town rn from the page I am one.
Also, who is rsolutin? *sp* I don't like his entrance. Nor any of his posts after. Has anyone played with him?
On December 09 2014 10:07 GlowingBear wrote: Ok uhm we can lynch Templar because he is scum We can lynch bats because he is scum We can lynch kita because where the fuck is he We can lynch sicklucker because he is reading but not interacting kthxbai
I'd lynch templar because his posts, while long, are full of more fluff than slam's. idk who kita is but it's still early so give him a break I'd lynch sicklucker because I wanted to plynch him last game and he was scum.
I don't like either of their posts. At all. Rn, they are on my look at more list.
On December 09 2014 10:05 Holyflare wrote: Vivax had the same train of thought. Like even more elaborated. He wasn't mentioned at all. I'm pretty sure I elaborated I didnt care about him over nb either but im not mentioned. Although that might have been later (he has made no return which is annoying), i think damd said something too maybe.
The point is he doesnt acknowledge anything like this at all and just tries to pass off something that isnt scummy as scummy and then you town read him for it which doesn't make sense at all. You are throwing out a lot of easy reads based on little information and it doesn't look good for you my friend.
i gave you and bats as town right
my ff read isn't an easy read at all.
so I'm not throwing out easy reads at all. Anyway I explained bats did the analysis on hts and it felt towny to me. Plus his manner feels like the other town games bats has played
You gave me a town read based on meta that is incomplete and didn't really factor in any game info other than "pressuring" which when you couple with my actual meta would mean nothing at all. Yet, when I say otherwise you somehow know it's still "town" Holyflare pressure rather than mafia.
Your bats read as I explained to anyone looking critically does not make any sense at all but he's still a d1 town list. I can see you making an analysis point on him but what about the stuff I just explained? Why was he still a town read after I pointed out he was picking and choosing who scum were based on absolutely nothing (he even just admitted it)!
And omg, we may make a town out of HF yet! I really like this view holyflare has. I mentioned before how Kelsier went from being on my side, to being on HF side. I think here, HF semi points out just how Kelsier pretty much buddied up to him.
As of this post, HF is townie to me. (Even though I don't want to call him town for pushing on me ;( )
Will give you some updated reads soon. It's taking longer to read than I thought.
On December 10 2014 08:52 KelsierSC wrote: So rather than convince us your town, as you said is what you have to-do, you aren't going to bother and just "claim" right now, good job
No I'm gonna try and convince yall I'm town, but it seems as if no one is listening to me anyway, so I might just have to claim.
What did you think about my read on Vivax? More specifically, what is your read?
Also, you mentioned earlier in the game about a read on Slam. You found it stupid there were people calling him town. What is your read on him as of this page?
This "claim" stuff is garbage. You've already pretty much claimed a role just by saying it twice now and you haven't even tried to convince people.
I never said I'm claiming a role.
I could claim some random bs and still be town.
And Im trying to convince people. Wtf do you think I'm doing?
On December 10 2014 09:05 liancourt wrote: where did ninja claim mason
On December 10 2014 08:44 27ninjabunnies wrote: And seeing as I'm being completely ignored at the moment (Seriously what's the point of me defending myself if no one is even going to interact with me?)
I'll leave you with a video of my college choir singing Christmas Music. This is us singing Carol of the Bells
EPT
