Student Mafia IV (New/Newish Players Welcome) - Page 87

On December 03 2014 12:42 Oatsmaster wrote:
nononono we kill scum first.

Come on, you gotta think that Hopeless is like wayyyyy more scum than Bats.

On November 28 2014 12:56 LightningStrike wrote:
Okay since now that my cousin and his wife and son have left I can finally give you guys my current reads for the time being.
Breshke: Town since he displaying the same kind of approach for today as he did in my last game when he was town.

Batsnacks: Null leaning town since he is acting close to the same way he did last game with me when he was a doctor but he been dodging questions from Oatsmaster and Half the Sky.

Damndred: Null leaning town since he was one of the major pushers for the lynching of DSIM without much of a good reason and been defending Batsnacks actions but at the same time he been giving losts of questions although DSIM didn't respond well to the questions.

Half the Sky: Town since he been giving good reasonings for his reads throughout the game although I don't like his case for Batsnacks being scum based on my own experience playing with Batsnacks in my last game.

sicklucker: Town because his posting style had pretty much stayed the same from the last game I played with him although he did looked very scummy in that game but he was just a Vanilla town and since our power roles had been lynched/killed I having a safe bet that sicklucker is town.

meatpudding: Null leaning town he had some decent questions after being gone for a while and now he claiming to have no power at his house it could be a scum move because one of the scums in my last game tried to pull that move but failed so perhaps meatpudding could scum.

alakaslam: null leaning scum since he not posted much of his reads but he also admitted to notread much of the thread during the time of us lynching DSIM but I need to see more posts of his though since he said he had to go earlier in the thread to confirm my suspicions.

Oatsmasters: Town since he been asking lots of questions to everyone and been trying to lead the discussion when he can which isn't a trait a scum member would do.

kushm4sta: Null leaning scum since he not been contributing a lot like his last scum game which was my last although he did give a couple questions to people he also didn't post much so I need to wait for him to post more so I can get a better read on him

rsoultin: Null leaning town since he trying to ask some questions and responding to questions he been asked by others although he did convence me to lynch DSIM that is haunting me because of my last game experience :|

On December 03 2014 12:08 sicklucker wrote:
Could oats and bats be scum together? I think theirs a chance and it could be the uneasy feeling were getting breske. I have no idea why Ive been the one pushing bats over his since d1. His defense was terrible. Unlikely Tho

at eod2 did ls move the votes off of ryoulin?

On December 03 2014 16:46 Oatsmaster wrote:
That's a horrible reason to scumread anyone.

You know how it looks? It looks like you are afraid to commit to a read so you are leaving me open to mislynch me at a later date. You don't even have any evidence at all that I'm scum.

What's so hard about calling me town?

On December 03 2014 16:49 Oatsmaster wrote:
Actually any decent scum player will tell his newbie scummate to find a very townie player and sheep him. It makes no sense to sheep your teammate because it's not like you need to buddy him or make him feel like you are listening to him. But it's good to buddy and sheep a strong townie to make him think you are with him and town.


So basically your evidence shows that ls is sheeping bats, therefore bats is town.

On December 03 2014 18:22 rsoultin wrote:


It's actually something SL said that makes me itchy. Oats vs. bats. Why? What about the LS vs. meat voting made it oats vs. bats? I remember you being one of the last people to vote for meat, perhaps the last, bringing the vote to 7. Did that not raise a red flag for you then? You've been more or less non-committal about bats, though he's been throwing you under the bus any chance he can. That argument the first day set the stage for an oats vs. bats game. You're coming back hard at me for commenting that you're not a firm town read for me, but have you bothered to defend yourself from him? I don't recall that you have. You're worth taking a second look at.



As for this...very townie? I could see, if you think that your newbie scummate is gonna give himself away, telling him to sheep a town people already don't trust. That's why I'm asking people what they think. I'm deliberately trying to think of reasons that bats might be town cause...as already said...super biased. Finding a very townie player isn't a bad strategy either to ride the coattails of for as long as possible. But what about bats makes him a strong townie player? He was in the race for scum day 1. Still being mentioned day 2 but we went for policy lynches instead.

I've been questioning him ever since EoD 2, and now you're telling me LS sheeping him proves he's town because he's a very townie player. That's...weird. What about bats' play this game is so very 'townie' oats? Maybe my newb eyes are just blind.

On December 03 2014 20:19 sicklucker wrote:
Meat who are the last two mafia