|
On October 31 2014 14:48 Misder wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2014 14:41 Holyflare wrote:
talking about the cat (aka policy) is a great way for mafia to blend in and is essentially complete wifom (useless because it could be scenario A, B or C) so really you're speculating about nothing and avoiding talking about scummy posts and what you think of other people because you are concentrating on something that doesn't help find mafia
which is what mafia love to do How is saying who to vote to analyze on the cat or asking the mods about the mechanics wifom? Why do you think I'm trying to blend in if only me and jaybrundage are talking about it? What exactly am I speculating on? All that I'm trying to say is that we should use the cat this cycle, and I believed ObiWanShinobi was a good target (past tense because cause he's here and he's ok). I don't have any true scum tells - only thing that stands out to me is that I agree with GB about jkirby's entrance being scummy. Why else do you think I would like to use the cat lol.
oh my gosh this post says nothing.
Why was OWS a good target Misder?
Who is scum now?
|
On October 31 2014 14:50 jaybrundage wrote:
Yo Obi Holyflare. I asked cause I don't know. For instance the term "Third Party" could in TL Mafia always imply that they win to the exclusion of town and mafia. I didnt know.
But being stuck up just makes you guys seem well... Stuck up. Just cause I'm ignorant of something doesn't mean you have to give me shit. Hell I wasn't even asking you guys at first.Originally I was asking the Hosts.
Also saying it was "all I have been talking about when I had been talking to GB just before that just seems to lack thread awareness.
2nd time you noob claimed btw.
Just so you know.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On October 31 2014 14:48 Misder wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2014 14:41 Holyflare wrote:
talking about the cat (aka policy) is a great way for mafia to blend in and is essentially complete wifom (useless because it could be scenario A, B or C) so really you're speculating about nothing and avoiding talking about scummy posts and what you think of other people because you are concentrating on something that doesn't help find mafia
which is what mafia love to do How is saying who to vote to analyze on the cat or asking the mods about the mechanics wifom? Why do you think I'm trying to blend in if only me and jaybrundage are talking about it? What exactly am I speculating on? All that I'm trying to say is that we should use the cat this cycle, and I believed ObiWanShinobi was a good target (past tense because cause he's here and he's ok). I don't have any true scum tells - only thing that stands out to me is that I agree with GB about jkirby's entrance being scummy. Why else do you think I would like to use the cat lol.
if you are mafia you live in a world with perfect information so if you are new to playing it or whatever you're super timid to criticise people's posts because of the lash back or just general fear so it's easy to blend in with policy of who to use the cat on when it should be obvious to anyone that the person you want to analyse is the person you think is the most scummy or a person that has posted almost 0 things
mods won't talk about any mechanics in the thread either, blending is because the talk about the cat is essentially a waste of time (as i talked about before it has no answer, we just use it on scummy ppl and hope for the best) and makes it look like you're participating in the game when really you are avoiding the nitty gritty who is mafia parts
although i do appreciate you elaborated on your obi point now, keep doing things like that
|
On October 31 2014 14:48 Misder wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2014 14:41 Holyflare wrote:
talking about the cat (aka policy) is a great way for mafia to blend in and is essentially complete wifom (useless because it could be scenario A, B or C) so really you're speculating about nothing and avoiding talking about scummy posts and what you think of other people because you are concentrating on something that doesn't help find mafia
which is what mafia love to do How is saying who to vote to analyze on the cat or asking the mods about the mechanics wifom? Why do you think I'm trying to blend in if only me and jaybrundage are talking about it? What exactly am I speculating on? All that I'm trying to say is that we should use the cat this cycle, and I believed ObiWanShinobi was a good target (past tense because cause he's here and he's ok). I don't have any true scum tells - only thing that stands out to me is that I agree with GB about jkirby's entrance being scummy. Why else do you think I would like to use the cat lol.
if you agree with gb why dont u analyze kirby?
|
On October 31 2014 14:50 jaybrundage wrote:
Yo Obi Holyflare. I asked cause I don't know. For instance the term "Third Party" could in TL Mafia always imply that they win to the exclusion of town and mafia. I didnt know.
But being stuck up just makes you guys seem well... Stuck up. Just cause I'm ignorant of something doesn't mean you have to give me shit. Hell I wasn't even asking you guys at first.Originally I was asking the Hosts.
Also saying it was "all I have been talking about when I had been talking to GB just before that just seems to lack thread awareness.
Sorry, not trying to offend. Just trying to keep us on track, is all.
|
On October 31 2014 14:45 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2014 14:31 jaybrundage wrote:On October 31 2014 14:19 Oatsmaster wrote:On October 31 2014 13:59 jaybrundage wrote:
Wait guys I just had an idea what if Mr.Bigglesworth is actually part of Kulthazard as a third party. Who's job is to eliminate the horde cause in that case we should never give votes to the cat. As it can't help us find scum. As horde is not indicative of Mafia Alignment. I dont see why doing a side objective could be bad in any way. Not sure what you mean by side objective. It could hurt us however as third party could glean information to win the game and it would make town lose. Hm thinking about it if horde could be both mafia and town then the third party would be indifferent to helping either of us. hm If third party wins does it mean that town and mafia lose? or does third party win condition, have an objective they have to fufill so they can win with either Mafia or town? Sorry if I didnt make my question clear. I dont know too much about third party in mafia set ups. 3p either wins alone or with town or with scum. So yeahhhhhhhhh basically nothing. I think its way more likely that this helps us rather than hurting us, more info good for town cause of the info imbalance between town and mafia. IGNORE 3P. Interesting that you brought up 3p though, why do you think this game has a 3p?
Thank you Oats. See this is the answer I was looking for HF and Obi plz take note.
Oh and because the Cat specifically mentioned finding and killing the horde (im paraphasing) And the horde isn't alignment indicative of mafia or town.
|
On October 31 2014 14:54 jaybrundage wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2014 14:45 Oatsmaster wrote:On October 31 2014 14:31 jaybrundage wrote:On October 31 2014 14:19 Oatsmaster wrote:On October 31 2014 13:59 jaybrundage wrote:
Wait guys I just had an idea what if Mr.Bigglesworth is actually part of Kulthazard as a third party. Who's job is to eliminate the horde cause in that case we should never give votes to the cat. As it can't help us find scum. As horde is not indicative of Mafia Alignment. I dont see why doing a side objective could be bad in any way. Not sure what you mean by side objective. It could hurt us however as third party could glean information to win the game and it would make town lose. Hm thinking about it if horde could be both mafia and town then the third party would be indifferent to helping either of us. hm If third party wins does it mean that town and mafia lose? or does third party win condition, have an objective they have to fufill so they can win with either Mafia or town? Sorry if I didnt make my question clear. I dont know too much about third party in mafia set ups. 3p either wins alone or with town or with scum. So yeahhhhhhhhh basically nothing. I think its way more likely that this helps us rather than hurting us, more info good for town cause of the info imbalance between town and mafia. IGNORE 3P. Interesting that you brought up 3p though, why do you think this game has a 3p? Thank you Oats. See this is the answer I was looking for HF and Obi plz take note. Oh and because the Cat specifically mentioned finding and killing the horde (im paraphasing) And the horde isn't alignment indicative of mafia or town.
Yeah, if 3p doesn't actually have a wincon like ESPN from Fantasy Football.
This is what I was afraid of happening. We don't know anything about 3p, so speculating on it is a waste of time since we can't know and we can't hope to know without having full knowledge of all available role PMs in front of us.
|
On October 31 2014 14:48 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2014 14:41 liancourt wrote:On October 31 2014 14:37 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
Good to know that HF and Oats are town this game. how'd you come to this conclusion? Holyflare: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=17#334His follow up posts on Misder were pretty good too. The way he's phrasing things and the way he's analyzing stuff looks pretty town imo. I just found myself agreeing with what the two of them were saying about Misder and I liked the points they were bringing up. Oats also had a really good post based on keeping discussion off of the stupid cat thing and onto important things.
stupid cat thingy....yes, but we should choose someone to analyze to find out what it actually does. I agree discussing abou tthe cat was pretty meh when we should discuss something more player related.
|
United States10536 Posts
Oh hey.
##Analyze: GlowingBear
|
On October 31 2014 14:52 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2014 14:50 jaybrundage wrote:
Yo Obi Holyflare. I asked cause I don't know. For instance the term "Third Party" could in TL Mafia always imply that they win to the exclusion of town and mafia. I didnt know.
But being stuck up just makes you guys seem well... Stuck up. Just cause I'm ignorant of something doesn't mean you have to give me shit. Hell I wasn't even asking you guys at first.Originally I was asking the Hosts.
Also saying it was "all I have been talking about when I had been talking to GB just before that just seems to lack thread awareness. 2nd time you noob claimed btw. Just so you know.
in the most amiable way idgaf
|
On October 31 2014 14:58 Seuss wrote:
Oh hey.
##Analyze: GlowingBear
lolwut?
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On October 31 2014 14:54 jaybrundage wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2014 14:45 Oatsmaster wrote:On October 31 2014 14:31 jaybrundage wrote:On October 31 2014 14:19 Oatsmaster wrote:On October 31 2014 13:59 jaybrundage wrote:
Wait guys I just had an idea what if Mr.Bigglesworth is actually part of Kulthazard as a third party. Who's job is to eliminate the horde cause in that case we should never give votes to the cat. As it can't help us find scum. As horde is not indicative of Mafia Alignment. I dont see why doing a side objective could be bad in any way. Not sure what you mean by side objective. It could hurt us however as third party could glean information to win the game and it would make town lose. Hm thinking about it if horde could be both mafia and town then the third party would be indifferent to helping either of us. hm If third party wins does it mean that town and mafia lose? or does third party win condition, have an objective they have to fufill so they can win with either Mafia or town? Sorry if I didnt make my question clear. I dont know too much about third party in mafia set ups. 3p either wins alone or with town or with scum. So yeahhhhhhhhh basically nothing. I think its way more likely that this helps us rather than hurting us, more info good for town cause of the info imbalance between town and mafia. IGNORE 3P. Interesting that you brought up 3p though, why do you think this game has a 3p? Thank you Oats. See this is the answer I was looking for HF and Obi plz take note. Oh and because the Cat specifically mentioned finding and killing the horde (im paraphasing) And the horde isn't alignment indicative of mafia or town.
3p could be win with any alignment, win with 1 of the alignments, win alone, there could be multiple 3p conditions?! who knows in this game????
I already posted this and you criticise me too???
|
On October 31 2014 14:58 Seuss wrote:
Oh hey.
##Analyze: GlowingBear
Holy Shit Monty is in this. Whats up Monty?
Dude BTW i still miss your amazing calls from TL Inhouse 5's
Do you still play any league?
|
On October 31 2014 14:58 Seuss wrote:
Oh hey.
##Analyze: GlowingBear town
|
On October 31 2014 15:00 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2014 14:54 jaybrundage wrote:On October 31 2014 14:45 Oatsmaster wrote:On October 31 2014 14:31 jaybrundage wrote:On October 31 2014 14:19 Oatsmaster wrote:On October 31 2014 13:59 jaybrundage wrote:
Wait guys I just had an idea what if Mr.Bigglesworth is actually part of Kulthazard as a third party. Who's job is to eliminate the horde cause in that case we should never give votes to the cat. As it can't help us find scum. As horde is not indicative of Mafia Alignment. I dont see why doing a side objective could be bad in any way. Not sure what you mean by side objective. It could hurt us however as third party could glean information to win the game and it would make town lose. Hm thinking about it if horde could be both mafia and town then the third party would be indifferent to helping either of us. hm If third party wins does it mean that town and mafia lose? or does third party win condition, have an objective they have to fufill so they can win with either Mafia or town? Sorry if I didnt make my question clear. I dont know too much about third party in mafia set ups. 3p either wins alone or with town or with scum. So yeahhhhhhhhh basically nothing. I think its way more likely that this helps us rather than hurting us, more info good for town cause of the info imbalance between town and mafia. IGNORE 3P. Interesting that you brought up 3p though, why do you think this game has a 3p? Thank you Oats. See this is the answer I was looking for HF and Obi plz take note. Oh and because the Cat specifically mentioned finding and killing the horde (im paraphasing) And the horde isn't alignment indicative of mafia or town. Show nested quote +
3p could be win with any alignment, win with 1 of the alignments, win alone, there could be multiple 3p conditions?! who knows in this game????
I already posted this and you criticise me too???
#getrekt
|
On October 31 2014 14:58 Seuss wrote:
Oh hey.
##Analyze: GlowingBear
i dont even...whats with everyone and their first posts
|
United States10536 Posts
I got married so I haven't played in a long while. Excited about the new jungle. But let's talk Mafia.
We have this weird analyze thing going on and nobody seems to care. I think we should Analyze somebody well in advance of the deadline, preferably somebody we think is scummy.
I like GlowingBear for that role.
|
On October 31 2014 15:03 Oatsmaster wrote:town
GB town or ss town?
|
United States10536 Posts
On October 31 2014 15:03 liancourt wrote:i dont even...whats with everyone and their first posts
Hi my name is Seuss AKA Monte.
Are we still in joke phase? I like joke phase.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On October 31 2014 15:04 Seuss wrote:
I got married so I haven't played in a long while. Excited about the new jungle. But let's talk Mafia.
We have this weird analyze thing going on and nobody seems to care. I think we should Analyze somebody well in advance of the deadline, preferably somebody we think is scummy.
I like GlowingBear for that role.
Explain
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
