EPTThe Resistance: Avalon - Page 39
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Blazinghand
United States25562 Posts
| ||
|
liancourt
1563 Posts
On October 25 2014 07:53 batsnacks wrote: Further, Liam and oats are mafia. Oats sabotaged because his name was first on his list mission 2. ##Suggest: Bat Marv Slam Palmar you put yourself first lol | ||
|
liancourt
1563 Posts
On October 25 2014 07:54 batsnacks wrote: And I'm yaying btw but of of course you suggested it. and um lets not announce how we're voting. Spies get too much info through it | ||
|
liancourt
1563 Posts
On October 25 2014 07:55 Blazinghand wrote: OK, I'm voting no to any team that includes batsnacks from now on since he tried to communicate a scum strat. seems clear enough to me. Also, his team includes marv, who is scum. Lots of reasons! i think hf posted that before the game even began but through that logic marv must be town | ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25562 Posts
On October 25 2014 08:05 liancourt wrote: but of of course you suggested it. and um lets not announce how we're voting. Spies get too much info through it fine, i'm not gonna announce how i'm voting, except to say that everyone should, like me, nayvote this team | ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25562 Posts
On October 25 2014 08:07 liancourt wrote: i think hf posted that before the game even began but through that logic marv must be town why | ||
|
liancourt
1563 Posts
| ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25562 Posts
On October 25 2014 08:25 liancourt wrote: marv's team succeeded and he was first...no wait that doesn't make sense. If marv and bats were spy marv was first so he'd sabo. But since it was only bats spy he prolly thought not to sabo on the first mission to get himself a town read. If there's 2 spies on the same team they have to think whether or not to sabo or not taking into consideration of the other spy in the team. If it's a rule of thumb that when there's 2 spy on the same team that the first person sabos then marv should have sabo'd but he didn't so makes him town in my eyes. I may be misunderstanding you here, so tell me if this is correct. You're saying: If Marv and Bats were both spies, Marv would sabo and Bats wouldn't. You think Bats was the only spy, and he played the long game and held back. If there were two spies, they might run into coordination problems with saboing or not. If there are 2 spies, usually the first person sabos (as Bats said), so if they were both spies, marv would have saboed. I don't think you're wrong that in a marv + bats spy situation, bats always passes the mission. Since marv suggested the mission, he's in charge of saboing or not saboing. Where I think you're wrong is where you assume that marv always sabos when he brings along a scum bats. Admittedly, it's more likely that marv is scum and brought two townies with him (bats and oats are great choices since they're both super bad at defending), and played the long game. I think that's good evidence for marv being scum over marv + bats. But I dont' get how you come to the "therefore, bats is scum and marv isn't". Like, sure, it's kinda a risky move to bring bats with you on the first mission if you're a scum marv and bats is scum. But why does this mean that Bats is scum and not Marv? Since Marv is significantly smarter and a better player than bats, a high level strat like holding your fire on the first mission to gain towncred is something that he's more likely to do than bats. If we go with the "there's one scum" theory, which is a reasonable theory, that theory points to the expert scum-player Marv choosing two weak townies to go with him and blending in for one mission. regardless, we gotta nayvote this mission as it has both Marv and Bats | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
BLAZINGHAND I am not an idiot. U no call me I-idiot. (Reads filter, /YAAA HEYY DERR/ /Rusty chevrolet/ /argue with a yooper/) No srsly | ||
|
Oatsmaster
United States16628 Posts
Your reasoning makes no sense. Why would I send the same team Lian did and throw suspicion on both of us for like no reason whatsoever? ANYONE ELSE PUT IN WOULD LOOK BAD if one of the initial 3 were scum. WHY PUT IN HIS SCUMBUDDY???? Man this game. nay4lyfe | ||
|
Oatsmaster
United States16628 Posts
That would make me unhappy. Boo.  | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
Voting yay to everything and assuming mafia wins at this point. gg | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22634 Posts
marv, channel your inner townie. Is slam mafia or town? | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
i literally gave a final answer list of reads. | ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25562 Posts
| ||
|
liancourt
1563 Posts
seems like a scummy thing to say to just give up or a really frustrated townie, but i can't see marv actually trying hard as bh has so i don't see why marv should frustrated to make that post. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On October 25 2014 21:56 liancourt wrote: man i wanna roll scum just to see how i play. seems like a scummy thing to say to just give up or a really frustrated townie, but i can't see marv actually trying hard as bh has so i don't see why marv should frustrated to make that post. this is why i'm stopping, people seem to be playing a different game to me. just nonsense. | ||
|
liancourt
1563 Posts
| ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22634 Posts
On October 25 2014 19:07 marvellosity wrote: why are you asking me that???? i literally gave a final answer list of reads. yeah but I'm mafia on it so I decided to ignore it on grounds of aids and bads. | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22634 Posts
If we decide oats was the one who sabotaged last mission, we need to find a third mafia. If it isn't me, then who is it? I can't read slam, I never try to read slam, you claim he's easy to read (if I recall correctly). If you're convinced that slam has much less chance of being mafia than damdred, we should send this team, assuming you're town. | ||
| ||
