Read through the shenanigans of the night.

I really like the play of HF, the fake vigi claim was really good and I like his cop check. It fits with hf's logic to check someone in the OO wagon and he also said that he wasn't sure about HF earlier in n1, I read him as town around the votes and the night phase so I believe the claim.

Hopeless has been null to me most of the game, however there are some things that make me uncomfortable about this lynch. hopeless was null to a lot of people and hf said he wasn't sure why he was reading him town, he was in the OO vote which is where I am sure a mafia lies. It could possibly be that he was framed.

Secondly obi is one of the people who is totally on board this wagon. Now I am pretty sure obi is scummy. Also obi said that he thinks the lynch is outside the OO wagon.
But his two scum are now lynch lian/hope. both of them voted for OO.
I don't like lynching someone who my top scum is really happy to bandwagon behind.

Also obi had hf as one of his top mafia reads but now doesn't even question the legitimacy of a fake vig,fake medic, real cop.

I like hf as cop but I really don't think hope is mafia.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

October 09 2014 07:06 GMT

#1354

Thank you for revealing yourself.

liancourt

1563 Posts

October 09 2014 07:09 GMT

#1355

On October 09 2014 16:02 Holyflare wrote:
Who cares who checked what? Hopeless is mafia. Lynch him.

what is this logic? did you or did you not check anyone at all at night?

what are you trying to get reactions off hopeless?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

October 09 2014 07:11 GMT

#1356

So let's assume you're wrong on obi (you probably are), there's 2 pretty much confirmed town on the wagon. Why have you jumped to the massive conclusion that not only did someone check hopeless who wasn't even a big scum read/likely check but that he's also framed instead of lian (if hes town) and why haven't you instead thought that your read on obi might be wrong instead?

KelsierSC

United Kingdom10443 Posts

October 09 2014 07:15 GMT

#1357

On October 09 2014 16:11 Holyflare wrote:
So let's assume you're wrong on obi (you probably are), there's 2 pretty much confirmed town on the wagon. Why have you jumped to the massive conclusion that not only did someone check hopeless who wasn't even a big scum read/likely check but that he's also framed instead of lian (if hes town) and why haven't you instead thought that your read on obi might be wrong instead?

I think hopeless was a very likely check if you are the cop, for the reasons I posted.

I don't think I am wrong on obi, his play has been very scummy and inconsistent.

KelsierSC

United Kingdom10443 Posts

October 09 2014 07:15 GMT

#1358

if obi is town...

then hope and lian are probably mafia

KelsierSC

United Kingdom10443 Posts

October 09 2014 07:18 GMT

#1359

but I really don't like how obi is so quick to bandwagon behind you considering you were his top mafia read.

He hasn't even questioned you being cop but is happy to go with it.

He asks "has anyone given thoughts on hope"
next post "lynch this guy #vote"

His post was "lynch lian/hope" even though he said n1 to lynch outside the OO vote

I'm not lynching someone this guy is happy to lynch,

liancourt

1563 Posts

October 09 2014 07:18 GMT

#1360

aren't you the one who had it in for obi up until today. And if you are indeed the cop wouldn't you want to confirm obi as scum rather than check me or hopeless. Who are the two confirmed town I don't see any? Grack as vigi and the dead oats?
I don't see how people can claim on day 2 when we don't even know what roles are in play and we're expected to blindly follow. For all I know it's a trap/ploy. I can't believe anything after that shenannigan at night.