|
On September 03 2014 11:38 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On September 03 2014 11:24 Tehpoofter wrote:On September 03 2014 11:21 Damdred wrote:
Few questions for you bats:
Why did you initially vote Templar and give no explanation and then unvote him? Did he do something to deserve your unvote?
You also pay attention to 3d posting and conclude that he has sounded that way since before the game started. Do you think that his ideas and reactions are towny in nature? I know you said you thought his apologetic tone wasn't scummy.
I must say bat this is not the normal town Bats i'm used to normally you are pretty crazy, which you showed with your first two posts (what was the first post from btw). But your posts feel really formulaic atm and it worries me. Hai I have no read on you. What are you reads? Why aren't you currently sheeping me onto Micchan? I'll answer the second question first. Currently, I am nervous about Micchan. He made his initial post (which i pointed out also), that complains about the thread atmosphere which honestly was not bad at the time of his post. I think we were still in setup talk and were startin to move towards actual talk. He did not stay in the thread and help improve the conversation or even say what the mess was. On his return his posts were an excuse and throwing more suspicion onto 3d with no follow up. He has since lurked obviously. This is worrisome to me, but it is not enough for a scum read currently I think. We still have a good many hours left to search for scum and their is just not much to go on in his filter, theres no real meta case to be made as he is a newb or a smurf. And well I really do not like going for low hanging fruit. The people who I would like to see more out of right now are: Batsnacks: His entrance to the thread was weird. On his re-entrance he ignored a lot of things that were posted against him, he never even showed interest in answering anything. His posts are really formulaic, right now they are reminding me of Neat and Tidy mafia instead of crazy bats in Cell or Titanic. Also usually hes really spammy, but his postings have been really hit and miss and even though he spared a lot of thoughts to 3d, his only reaction is that an apologetic tone is not scummy. But their are other things in 3ds posts that he could talk about and he does not really draw conclusions from that. Bunnies: Bunnies is a bit odd to me, a lot of her early filter is a lot of trolling with fluff thrown in. Suddenly she town reads templar and poof and gives little reason for it. Even goes far enough to meta read poof and giving him a town pass for not very good reasons. This is the worrying part to me, Bunnies talks about shooting people over gut feelings and saying that Bats is a third party (hypothetically). Has not returned to the thread yet and responded to why she would want to direct vig at this point to make a kill and push us towards lylo over nothing. Micchan for the reasons listed above 3D i'm not really sure about yet, he seems awkward which is not alignment indicative but he at least gives his views in the thread and then tries toe xplain himself. So more of a I want to see more of his thoughts.
Getting tired of this "yeah Micchan is being scummy and lurking but naa I don't want to vote him" Why do you think mafia isn't hoping on this lynch if Micchan is town? He is clearly just not trying and would be the easiest of all easy misslynches.
I'm starting to wonder if the mafia goal involves like not voting as there is a bunch of people who haven't even placed a vote as of yet.
I agree with your Bunnies read. I'm not too excited on how she talks about 3d parties and stuff wanting to kill them more than mafia as I think Oats pointed out.
3D Can you describe what you mean by awkward I think I know what you mean but not 100% also why would you bring it up that its a null in your opinion?
Do you have any town reads atm?
Batsnacks in the games you mentioned what alignment was he? I don't think I played in those.
|
On September 03 2014 11:46 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On September 03 2014 11:39 Tehpoofter wrote:On September 03 2014 11:33 Vivax wrote:On September 03 2014 11:19 The_Templar wrote:On September 03 2014 10:48 Vivax wrote:On September 03 2014 10:15 The_Templar wrote:On September 03 2014 08:20 Tehpoofter wrote:Bang: Vivax - His reads have aligned with mine I liked the way he answered the buddying question I asked him last night he felt like he while disagreeing with me had a townie mindset. Kill - Micchan - See my case on him he hasn't posted hardly anything and what he has posted has just set off scum alarms every single time we should all be voting this dude! Link to the post!The_Templar - His read on 3d12 that I was questioning him on felt really odd to me it seemed like to me a mafia either soft defending a newbish scumbuddy or soft defending a townie enough to hopefully not get blamed for his lynch. If his mission was defend several townies or a buddy this would make sense something about reading his post felt forced to me. I know also Templar as scum can come out of the gates firing as scum in the newbie game I saw him play in he had the 2nd if not the biggest filter and I think this reminds me of that game. To all of you so I can read you a bit better where do you stand? Have you voted Micchan yet? Your read on Vivax: As someone who has been mafia several times in a row recently, I can tell you that it's a terrible idea to town read someone based on their reads. Most players can give alignment-neutral reads and I've seen players get terribly confused later on because the people that had the same reads as them turned out to be mafia. Regarding the rest, can you say exactly how he has a "townie mindset"? I don't see it at all. Why would you write this about someone you never openly considered as scum in your filter. Last thing you said about me is how me bringing up something repeatedly was odd. It just looks like you try to discredit me for no reason, since your filter lacks the motivation to push me as a scumread. Sorry, forgot that I have to read someone as red to disagree with them and say that they could be red. Fine let's play it your way. You are red. Happy now? But you didn't disagree with me. You found some of my behaviour odd and disagreed with Poofter about me being town. Why act so mad now? Yeah we're going to be friends this game. Yo vivax I might propose to you if I feel the need to update my BMK. This line of questions you've been asking all game seems townie to me. How do you get your read on kush? for me its "does he seem to give a shit" if yes = town if no = mafia. So far he seemed to give a shit earlier now not so much. I think thats the read we had different so want to know more about that read. Kush is very capable of looking townie, as town. He will look interested and engaged and I will generally get the right vibe from him. As scum he talks a lot about irrelevant stuff and you will get the feeling that he doesn't care, he will usually join wagons on townies in a way that doesn't leave much room for alternatives (as in, he doesn't really care about other options).
Kush to me definitely seems like he was carrying but not really anymore.
KK I really hope you're town cause I think in almost every game we've played I've read you as really scummy and I think I might have finally figured out how to read you 
|
On September 03 2014 11:52 Damdred wrote:
Vivax, can we talk about mderg for a minute together.
What do you think of him rejoining the thread, saying that we should ignore all missions, and then just talking about 3d the whole time he was in the thread?
Oh I c just want to talk to Vivax and not me Damdred? jerk. I'm talking about him anyways.... cause lets be honest I forgot completely about mderg. He's not even in my BMK but I liked him as a Bang earlier his view on missions was weird but I felt like his reaction to when we discussed things earlier felt townie.
You think he's scummy?
|
On September 03 2014 11:54 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
Someone ask me some questions or some shit.
a/s/l?
|
On September 03 2014 11:59 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On September 03 2014 11:58 Tehpoofter wrote:On September 03 2014 11:54 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
Someone ask me some questions or some shit. a/s/l? 19/f/cali hbu?
12/m/mexico
Hey whats your read on Micchan? Are you just so insanely impressed by my case you've yet to vote on him out of respect so he may concede first?
Also what do you think of my BMK list? Can you do something similar?
|
On September 03 2014 12:06 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I love how almost everyone is okay with me doing nothing.
The pockets were that easy this game huh?
|
On September 03 2014 12:12 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I never post reads dude. I always hide them until I have an ironclad case or unless I have a really strong townread, of which I have neither.
Also, I haven't even read Micchan yet. I'm gonna be honest and say I really don't give a shit about him at all because he looks boring.
This is a really boring way to play imo. Share your ideas let us see where you mind is at. I posted my reads already which I'm sure obs is laughing at atm but fck it I want people to know where I'm at. If all townies just acted town game would be ezpz.
I don't like your responses. Also 19 is a little old.
|
On September 03 2014 12:15 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On September 03 2014 12:14 Tehpoofter wrote:On September 03 2014 12:06 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I love how almost everyone is okay with me doing nothing. The pockets were that easy this game huh? Apparently, lool.
You should see if you can pocket me by days end. Throw in Oats too for bonus points. I'd love to see what you can do with full pockets
|
On September 03 2014 12:24 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On September 03 2014 12:16 Tehpoofter wrote:On September 03 2014 12:12 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I never post reads dude. I always hide them until I have an ironclad case or unless I have a really strong townread, of which I have neither.
Also, I haven't even read Micchan yet. I'm gonna be honest and say I really don't give a shit about him at all because he looks boring. This is a really boring way to play imo. Share your ideas let us see where you mind is at. I posted my reads already which I'm sure obs is laughing at atm but fck it I want people to know where I'm at. If all townies just acted town game would be ezpz. I don't like your responses. Also 19 is a little old. I almost never post reads lists so I don't know why you're having an issue with me not doing it now.
Last game I was with you your activity got you lynched at lylo in Heavy Weight mafia (I got lynched before that so I can't talk much) I'd like to see if you're town that not happen to either of us this game and actually win. I don't necessarily care if you give a reads list or not that's easier for me seeing peoples ideas on paper. I'd just like to be able to read you and know where you're at.
Right now you've basically said "lawl I don't give reads unless I'm sure which I'm not" Micchan the guy you cased is boring. This gives me ZERO info to go off so I don't like it.
|
On September 03 2014 12:32 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm super tempted to start doing the Oberyn thing again though.
Whats that?
|
On September 03 2014 12:34 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On September 03 2014 12:34 Tehpoofter wrote:On September 03 2014 12:32 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm super tempted to start doing the Oberyn thing again though. Whats that? Go read Showdown and find out.
lol you were unlynchable? I didn't read the game so not sure what happened but I liked the post when I control F'd Oberyn. Take control I'd like to see it never seen you in that role tbh would be a nice change of pace.
|
On September 03 2014 12:57 ObiWanShinobi wrote:I can't tell if you're saying this because he's genuinely boring or if you're being a smug asshole. Is it both? It's probably both.
His first post was boring as fck I regret reading it.
|
We need new blood.
I'm about to get off work going home to play some dungeonworld so probably be afk for a couple hours I'll check in before bed.
Calling on Oats/Kush/Kita/Mderg to read my Micchan case and sheep me please. Or at least tell me why I'm wrong.
|
WOWOWWOWOW I just saw that
|
Getting into work going to see what I missed. This deadline is hella inconvenient for me.
Kush you actually around? Talk to me I saw flares of awesome early but you kinda faded down the home stretch. (inb4 you posted a bunch since I read  )
|
On September 04 2014 05:59 kushm4sta wrote:
i think flashes is a better metaphor there than flares
I'm sticking with flares.
If you had to pick 2 votes on the Micchan wagon that were scummy which ones would they be?
|
On September 03 2014 23:49 kitaman27 wrote:
@poofter, what were you referring to when you said kush had a good amount of content? Like specific posts?
There was a flourish where he posted about 5 ish posts (its not a lot honestly by normal standard but for kush) midway through the first day that felt townie too me. I'm still catching up but his posting has decreased. So I'll see where I'm at come my read.
It was his start of the day around page 10 that I got my read from.
|
On September 04 2014 06:05 batsnacks wrote:
Picking easy targets is good they said. Lynch the low hanging fruit they said. Well now the doctor is dead and none of you have reads because the doctor never said anything.
Taunting will help. Why don't you tell me what we should have done and who was most benefited by the doctor lynch?
|
On September 04 2014 06:39 batsnacks wrote:Show nested quote +On September 04 2014 06:37 ObiWanShinobi wrote:On September 04 2014 06:26 batsnacks wrote:On September 04 2014 06:16 Tehpoofter wrote:On September 04 2014 06:05 batsnacks wrote:
Picking easy targets is good they said. Lynch the low hanging fruit they said. Well now the doctor is dead and none of you have reads because the doctor never said anything. Taunting will help. Why don't you tell me what we should have done and who was most benefited by the doctor lynch? Taunting does help. It helps me cope with ya'll. We should have NOT voted the easiest possible target d1 and mafia is most benefited by the doctor lynch. Then why did you fuck off after you posted your case on kita? Why didn't you push your target harder? Why didn't you answer anyone else's questions when you came back into the thread? Why didn't you push/explain your scumreads on me/bunnies? I was busy. Why ask me these questions now and not when you are imagining they would be important? This discussion is meaningless now.
So is your bullshit taunt. Like how is it okay for you to be a dick about the lynch and say "omg I was right you guys are all dumb" .... "but i was busy so I couldn't say it at a relevant time now I'm going to bring it up and look like a genius while you guys look like idiots" Thats bullshit logic. You started the discussion if you can't handle the repercussions from it then don't bring it up.
|
On September 04 2014 06:47 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
You are literally lying if you claim that you were busy because you made your giant kita post and then posted your nonsensical scumreads on bunnies and me.
Townie.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
