Noir Mini Mafia: Chapter 2 - Page 4

On July 18 2014 06:22 IAmRobik wrote:
For the record, if no one CC's, I will be CCing by EOD

On July 18 2014 15:32 gobbledydook wrote:


yeah it's fucked up, when I wrote my vote on you it was only robik, so if it wasn't him then it was you, but now this. I still think MM1 and snickers are trolling, but don't troll with such serious business -.-

On July 18 2014 15:33 gobbledydook wrote:


Because when robik claimed blue the trolling hadn't started yet and I doubt robik set out to troll.

On July 18 2014 15:01 MysteryMeat1 wrote:
Still think obi is obvious scum, but ill be on a plane flyin to chi town in a few minutes.

On July 18 2014 15:02 MysteryMeat1 wrote:
Also i thought it was pretty obvious that i softed that i was blue...

On July 18 2014 15:09 gobbledydook wrote:
cool, so we have BH cop claim and robik counter claim blue.

Only one of them can be blue, and the other is VT or mafia. I doubt a VT fake counterclaiming because that just doesn't make sense. BH fakeclaiming blue as VT would be counterproductive, because a blue counterclaim would ensure a townie gets lynched, not a good idea.

It's not certain that if BH is blue, that he actually is cop. He may be a non-cop blue pretending to be a cop to throw mafia off. That way, because he is the real blue, he's safe, but mafia are misled as to what town can do.

Case 1: BH is blue, robik mafia

Why would robik counterclaim as mafia? If he was mafia, and he got BH lynched and BH turned blue, then he's next. At the end of day 2 it would be 5-1 which is very town favoured. So I don't think that's likely.

Case 2: BH is mafia, robik blue

We can assume that BH was genuinely concerned that he would get lynched. So if he was mafia, either he gets lynched if he says nothing, or by fakeclaiming at least he has a chance of getting town to mislynch the actual blue. This might be the case, in which case we lynch BH.

Case 3: BH is VT, robik blue

It's not very possible to tell Case 2 from Case 3. I don't think BH would do something as dumb as VT fakeclaim blue, confusing town more than it confuses mafia. I think this isn't likely.

So I think we lynch BH, as he's not likely to be blue or VT, and more likely a desperate mafia.

##unvote
##vote Blazinghand

On July 18 2014 15:51 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
kush, do you know how many games gg has played?

On July 18 2014 16:07 gobbledydook wrote:


You have one game of me as mafia and none as town. I'm sure that's a very good representation of my meta. /s