actually SnB not dying leaves reasonable doubt that he could be mafia, although I dont plan on lynching him anytime soon. Remember that VE was a traitor and he did not knowingly kill scum either way.

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

April 19 2014 17:31 GMT

#5924

You have a point but he has been the only towny person for ages so...

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

April 19 2014 22:58 GMT

#5925

I think s&b is green because he lynched VE.
I think vayneauthority and geript are green (because of VE's role PM)

None of these are certain but I think it's a pretty good baseline.

Between sandroba and JAT why not lynch sandroba? If JAT is honest he wins and leaves the game and you can lynch Killing. If JAT stays in the game he is lying and you can always lynch him tomorrow.

But the most important is pls give me an item ;_;

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

April 19 2014 23:08 GMT

#5926

I'll prob just vote however geript says to though ^^

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

April 19 2014 23:30 GMT

#5927

On April 20 2014 08:08 Amiko wrote:
I'll prob just vote however geript says to though ^^

Why? It's not like geript is the towniest or best player here. Are you afraid that he will rb you?

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

April 19 2014 23:42 GMT

#5928

On April 20 2014 07:58 Amiko wrote:
I think s&b is green because he lynched VE.
I think vayneauthority and geript are green (because of VE's role PM)

None of these are certain but I think it's a pretty good baseline.

Between sandroba and JAT why not lynch sandroba? If JAT is honest he wins and leaves the game and you can lynch Killing. If JAT stays in the game he is lying and you can always lynch him tomorrow.

But the most important is pls give me an item ;_;

As long as people agree on the rolepm part this is actually the correct play here.

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

April 20 2014 00:13 GMT

#5929

I lose if geript takes my items so I must obey

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

April 20 2014 00:21 GMT

#5930

How can he take your items? I thought that happened when you tried to steal from him?

geript

10024 Posts

April 20 2014 00:33 GMT

#5931

Amiko. I like you. You may steal from me tonight.

Killing

Canada530 Posts

April 20 2014 00:40 GMT

#5932

There's no way I'm getting lynched. On the off chance that a mafia somehow infiltrated the pm circle of jerk then we're in some fucking trouble. Paperscraps and I instantly swapped roles once pms were enabled because we knew that each other were town. Here's why I'm town and we're not killing me:

1) I reduced chaos to 0 and delayed rb'ed a mafia ( LSB, this isn't confirmed but fuck you it's true)
2) My role is hilariously dumb to the point of I could not have made it up. If you think I'm mafia, then this is the worst mafia role ever made. I'm assuming this was some contrived support town role where someone tells me to find a wizard or a dragon and I find the shit out of them.
3) I knew paperscraps was OPOPOPOP medic since like day 2. If I was mafia, he woulda insta died cause that shit sounds ridiculous.

Anyways,here's my thoughts on lynches:

JAT: Probably the best bet for a 3p that is actually not good for town. He'd probably be my top lynch.
Amiko: Could also be lying. He should die at some point.
VA: I'm inclined to believe that he's town due to the nature and flavor of VE's role but god that guy is dumb. Maybe lynch him so I can stop reading his posts.
Sandro: Has been pretty town. From what I understand, he was one of the leaders of the pm circles that seem to have brought the town lots of sucess so he'd be my last.

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

April 20 2014 00:55 GMT

#5933

On April 20 2014 09:40 Killing wrote:
There's no way I'm getting lynched. On the off chance that a mafia somehow infiltrated the pm circle of jerk then we're in some fucking trouble. Paperscraps and I instantly swapped roles once pms were enabled because we knew that each other were town. Here's why I'm town and we're not killing me:

1) I reduced chaos to 0 and delayed rb'ed a mafia ( LSB, this isn't confirmed but fuck you it's true)
2) My role is hilariously dumb to the point of I could not have made it up. If you think I'm mafia, then this is the worst mafia role ever made. I'm assuming this was some contrived support town role where someone tells me to find a wizard or a dragon and I find the shit out of them.
3) I knew paperscraps was OPOPOPOP medic since like day 2. If I was mafia, he woulda insta died cause that shit sounds ridiculous.

Anyways,here's my thoughts on lynches:

JAT: Probably the best bet for a 3p that is actually not good for town. He'd probably be my top lynch.
Amiko: Could also be lying. He should die at some point.
VA: I'm inclined to believe that he's town due to the nature and flavor of VE's role but god that guy is dumb. Maybe lynch him so I can stop reading his posts.
Sandro: Has been pretty town. From what I understand, he was one of the leaders of the pm circles that seem to have brought the town lots of sucess so he'd be my last.

1) First of all you don't mention snb and geript. Those are your townreads then I guess?
2) If you knew about papers role that early then reducing chaos to 0 is NOT VERY PROTOWN, right?
3) Let me explain the situation to you. There are almost certainly 2 scum left. If you believe that Amiko and me are 3P this means you instantly lose if you lynch me.
Now: 3 town, 2 scum, 2 3P
lynch me: 3:2:1
nightkill: 2:2:1
Game over.

So you better start looking for a person that can actually be scum as a lynch target.

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

April 20 2014 00:57 GMT

#5934

Killing doesn't seem to have any scumread and just tries to lynch down the list of 3P. Good lynch.

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

April 20 2014 01:08 GMT

#5935

The 2 scum are between VA, Killing, Sandroba and Geript. Any lynch outside of those people loses town the game almost 100 %.

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

April 20 2014 01:12 GMT

#5936

Since noone (besides me) seems to suspect geript and he is able to keep me in check you can cross him off the list for today.
That leaves VA, Killing and sandro.

geript

10024 Posts

April 20 2014 08:05 GMT

#5937

OK so here's the world where I'm in. Sandroba has said that he's not going to contribute until monday. If he's town that's 100% unacceptable. That's not acceptable whatsoever. Like this is potentially LYLO and he left without giving anything to anyone. He didn't claim. He didn't help. He didn't leave anything whatsoever for direction. Like this is getting pretty ridiculous. Like I would prefer if we could know that he would be modkilled but that's not likely to happen. So instead, lynching Sandroba as a policy lynch. It's just like sleeping. Honestly at this point, I wish I hadn't subbed in because I've been one of the only people to actually give a damn since I actually joined this game.

strongandbig

United States4858 Posts

April 20 2014 13:50 GMT

#5938

Paper said killing knew his role since day 2

It's unlikely scum let paper live if they know his role, esp since he hadn't been strongly townread and wasn't likely to get protected by anyone else

On the other hand the way killing's power is claimed to work doesn't feel right to me. It seems much more like a power that lowers chaos would be scum favored not town favored

But still, the paper flip makes me grudgingly pass on lynching paper for now.

strongandbig

United States4858 Posts

April 20 2014 13:52 GMT

#5939

As for geript, he was the other person who I thought might've used the prince of darkness power, since he subbed in after pm day and if scum had pod on pm day they presumably would have used it then, but geript has played way more townie than I would expect a scum substitute to play especially after missing pm day

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

April 20 2014 13:59 GMT

#5940

Snb, you are the universal townread and the most reasonable person here. Who do you want me to vote for? I will vote for whoever you want as long as it is not me. It would be nice if you could tell me in the next couple of hours since it is absolutely possible that I won't be around at deadline today since it is easter sunday.