|
You seriously have a strong enough townread on Coag to be certain he's not flipping scum?
The way I see it, if there's even the faintest possibility he flips scum we should lynch him now - because he doesn't even count as a townie. If we get to LYLO with coag, we've already lost.
On that basis, even if he's town we lose nothing by lynching him today.
|
On February 11 2014 16:43 Aquanim wrote: You seriously have a strong enough townread on Coag to be certain he's not flipping scum?
The way I see it, if there's even the faintest possibility he flips scum we should lynch him now - because he doesn't even count as a townie. If we get to LYLO with coag, we've already lost.
On that basis, even if he's town we lose nothing by lynching him today.
This is pretty much how I see things aswell. And I had a scum read on Alakaslam before he was replaced.
|
Yeah I do actually. And he will play the game if people dont get irrationally mad when coag posts anything. I would totally like a lylo with coag. We lose a nightkill to to get rid of an obvious townie. Thats not nothing. And then we start day 3 the same as day 2 but without a strong townie.
|
On February 11 2014 16:57 Oatsmaster wrote: Yeah I do actually. And he will play the game if people dont get irrationally mad when coag posts anything. I would totally like a lylo with coag. We lose a nightkill to to get rid of an obvious townie. Thats not nothing. And then we start day 3 the same as day 2 but without a strong townie. Show me someone getting irrationally mad when Coag posts.
|
Everyone currently voting for him like hopeless and jay
|
You think that coag will never ever be useful ever?
|
Do you think I'm irrationally mad?
|
On February 11 2014 17:01 Oatsmaster wrote: You think that coag will never ever be useful ever? That's exactly what I think. In all the games I have ever seen him I have never ever seen coag be useful, ever.
|
He was useful in pyp 4. Caused 2 scum deaths. I dont even know why coag keeps playing when you guys keep shitting on him every game when he doesnt do what you want
|
On February 11 2014 17:03 Aquanim wrote:Show nested quote +On February 11 2014 17:01 Oatsmaster wrote: You think that coag will never ever be useful ever? That's exactly what I think. In all the games I have ever seen him I have never ever seen coag be useful, ever.
Totally agree with this.
@Oats, What makes him obvious towny?
|
Because he wouldnt even bother posting as scum and there would be no way he would be so angry
|
On February 11 2014 17:05 Oatsmaster wrote: He was useful in pyp 4. Caused 2 scum deaths. I dont even know why coag keeps playing when you guys keep shitting on him every game when he doesnt do what you want <shrug> I don't read theme games.
And I don't see what's so unreasonable about asking someone to justify their views.
|
On February 11 2014 17:01 Oatsmaster wrote: Everyone currently voting for him like hopeless and jay
So I'm irrationally mad also? For voting him because I had a strong scum read on Alakaslam and didn't think Coagulation had done anything since coming in to show he's town? I don't quite follow.
|
Why are you lynching coag that makes him scum other than not showing that he is town?
|
On February 11 2014 17:14 Oatsmaster wrote: Why are you lynching coag that makes him scum other than not showing that he is town?
1. Alakaslam did not look good. 2. Coag will be disruptive to the town for the rest of the game, just see page 63 3. Coag will be unreadable and dangerous as either alignment for town in LYLO.
|
On February 11 2014 17:14 Oatsmaster wrote: Why are you lynching coag that makes him scum other than not showing that he is town?
Because I think Alakaslam was scum before he replaced out.
We know he has no problem phone posting utter nonsense without even reading the thread as town. He didn't here. He's incredibly vague about reads, summarizes without conclusion. Uses truly terrible reasoning why jaybrundage is scum. Does not comment on JonnyLaw at all, despite JonnyLaw being the leading wagon when he's around the thread.
|
|
LM, is that referring to coag or alak? I wanna know what makes coag scun
|
On February 11 2014 17:30 Oatsmaster wrote: LM, is that referring to coag or alak? I wanna know what makes coag scun
The scummiest thing about Coagulation is how he does not provide any real justification for his reads. And how he did not comment on the lynch wagon on D1 at all, with just a "placeholder vote" on JonnyLaw. Then there's the martyr, which pretty much begins without any real reason. Despite how he claims "seems like you guys have already decided to lynch me based on slams actions" it was by not majority of players who were pushing Alakaslam as scum at that point.
|
Did you read his scum games? Because you should
|
|
|
|