Balla's played a few games Jay. Did his vote on LM then leaving strike you oddly?

This isn't even worth discussing anymore. No one's being lynched for having 39 quality pro-town posts. It's a fine benchmark.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 00:31 GMT

#104

Oh you're back. Why did you vote lm so quickly?

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 00:41 GMT

#109

Balla's been scum in 3 outta 4 games we played. I'm forcing myself not to call him scum out of habit. Jay you've made me think I should put my games in my profile as well. Hmm...I'll do that now actually.

I actually like your reasoning looking at it again. He comes in and justifies lurking. Huh?

I still agree with his second post.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 00:51 GMT

#111

Sure. Setting up profile right now. I'll copy/paste it into database thread.

Not inquisitive. And no thread presence. His filters in the town games are like 3x the size of the scum games.

Basic mafia trying to misdirect attention.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 01:20 GMT

#115

Suki I instinctively hated the vote. Everyone was discussing that policy which i think is silly and LM's post didn't stand out to me.

I agreed with his second post and dismissed the other one. That first one is an excuse for lurking. I dunno if that's scummy or not. Let's see how LM proceeds from here. Maybe I have a soft spot from him hosting one of our newbie games.

And no balla it's 3/4

NMM xlvii, L and normal mini I

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 01:21 GMT

#116

Doesn't matter ss. If you read my filter from normal mini you'll see them all.

I used that as my only credentials for not being lynched in that game. If Balla's scum, he'll die.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 02:14 GMT

#124

LM hasn't given us quality or quantity yet. He says one thing then does another. It's early in the game for me to demand more quality of his posting. At least as far as considering lynching him.

Hi cakeman. Please don't become lynch bait by not posting if you're town.

+ Show Spoiler [@balla] +

This is driving me nuts. I literally just looked at those games as i changed my profile.

nmm xlvii end gamed by balla scum

nmm L, I was shot n2, balla shot N3

nmm LI, balla shot jonnylaw N1

normal mini mafia iballa lynched day 1

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 02:39 GMT

#126

I want to play answer the questions too.

Suki always thinks what I say is scummy. null read.
no towniest read.
scummiest read - koshi
lynch the lurkers
post as much as needed to get scum lynched.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 02:48 GMT

#131

Meh, okay so she dislikes everything I say. I think they mean the same thing. I guess it could be taken as she thinks im misguided sometimes rather than simply scummy.

Her question seemed legit enough but balla's right. At the start of day 1 I want to see what someone is willing or able to bring to the game. There's no point saying much until they show what they're committing.

At this point LM's first post was shit but says nothing about his alignment until other actions take place in the game.

Koshi on the other hand created two pages of shit posting. This allowed LM and other LM like people to pop in, say nothing and fuck off out of here acting as though they participated in the game.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 02:54 GMT

#137

Koshi's euro cakeman he's asleep i'd guess.

What did you specifically dislike about Jayb's post Suki? I see reason to dislike it but I'm interested in your opinion.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 03:05 GMT

#141

I'd say it could feel like bussing scum buddy.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 03:14 GMT

#147

Jayb I do have one question.

Why did you pick SS out of everyone who hasn't done much yet? Looking at the list there are a number of other candidates. Why him in particular?

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 03:20 GMT

#154

Oats I've never seen you as town. Can you show any recent games please?

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 03:41 GMT

#162

You played with him a month ago in lolpyp

Anyway, I'm not waffling on anything. I'm trying to figure out the game. If you have firm convictions this early you're an idiot or a god.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 15:38 GMT

#255

On February 04 2014 22:50 Koshi wrote:
I never said it was nonsense. It's a good policy but in the end I knew I wouldn't follow through with it anyway. And take away everything people said about my first post in the game and we would have a 6 page thread. So yeah, I am pretty happy with it.

You're making the same point I made.

You posted something stupid that you admittedly don't want to follow through with in the end. If we take away everyone talking about your first post then maybe we'd have better content instead of discussion about post counts. Did the discussion about that post tell you where the scum are at in this game Koshi?

I don't think that discussion will ever point out scum. Why even go there when you don't want to follow through anyway? I'm trying to understand your motives here.

I'm heading to work very soon. Just checking the thread before I go.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 23:55 GMT

#373

I'll be in and out for the next few hours. First I'm going to go find some Oats town games. I played with him as scum and it looks similar to this game. I have a nagging suspicion that's how he plays every game though. I asked him yesterday to link me town games but he never responded.

I'll address Koshi's post afterwards. Not too worried about it at the moment.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 04 2014 23:56 GMT

#374

Oh and they're in his profile. That makes this easier.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 05 2014 00:03 GMT

#378

Yeah, I'm reading the normal game. You caught koshi and sn0man d2. No one listened. Poor oats.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 05 2014 00:07 GMT

#380

Anyway, that was fruitless. The filters could be from the same game. Oats put a little more effort into the normal game but it was a much larger and faster game. I'm going to reread the thread. I'm missing something obvious and the game's still short.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

February 05 2014 01:27 GMT

#385

I want to talk about Jay.

After Jay's done talking about policy he starts posting that he's doing what a good townie would be doing. But I don't believe he's actually doing it. Just talking.

He starts off talking about Sidesprang out of all of the lurkers. I ask him why Sidesprang and his answer made sense to me originally.

I should properly preface this by saying that before the game as I was looking at some of the games from other players. I noticed sidesprang had a worrying about of posts in his town game. Perhaps like 2 - 3 posts a cycle and that was pushing it. I noted that and planned to put alot of pressure on him this game. I was considering trying to start a policy lynch on him with my first post to get conversation moving and put pressure.

Then he reveals he hasn't really looked into others later. I think his filter dive on sidesprang could be a bus or he did it when pressured about why he wanted to go after sidesprang. LM, cakeman and prob others have short filters in their recent games as well. Who are these other people he looked into then? Jay's saying "look I did super town things hunting scum."

On February 04 2014 08:58 jaybrundage wrote:
Balla is this your first mafia game? I was browsing some of this towns old games and didn't see you.

On February 04 2014 09:47 jaybrundage wrote:
Guess your not in the database either huh jonny XD If your gonna compile your games you might as well make a post in the mafia database with them listed and a quick review :o

On February 04 2014 12:31 jaybrundage wrote:

Show nested quote +

Whats up Masta of the Oats?

Been a long time since we played ill have to look ya up. Tho I don't like the buddying atm :o

Then there's the entire interaction with Suki.

This is out of the big list thread. Which I hated by the way. Jay's telling the town to post clearly and giving advice while doing the exact opposite the entire game. There's not one concise read.

On February 04 2014 12:24 jaybrundage wrote:

10. Suki scummy I don't like suki so far she just seems like she has no real motivation behind her posting. Her poke at jonnys waffleing was ok but then when balla inquired about it she said she never said she implied hes scum or anything LIke wtf? Why poke at someone but have no real reason behind it. It would seem that she didn't understand him but then she didn't say that she got very defensive. Said she didn't see anything with LM posting slight defending I dont like her atm

He goes from that to this. I can understand changing your mind but I don't think that case was straightforward or even particularly good.

On February 05 2014 02:35 jaybrundage wrote:
SUKI GONNA RUSTLE SOME JIMMIES

I like your case seems well thought out and pretty straight forward logic. The first big case of the thread :D

On February 05 2014 02:48 jaybrundage wrote:

Show nested quote +

So looking at my posting the thing that you might perceive as "scummy" Is that I am not posting my own opinion as much as prodding other's for information. And that is intentional I want to see more posting from lurkers that is my number 1 concern at the moment. I want to be able to separate the town lurkers to the scum lurkers.

My other question is why did you vote Lonemeow but then vote Oatsmaster when suki and Balla made cases and votes against him. What was your initial intention to vote lone meow in the first place?

Why switch over to Oats just cause thread sentiment is going in that direction.

Town should be posting opinions and hunting scum. Yet there's none of that here.

When are you going to start playing this game Jay? Pressuring and even voting lurkers is fine by me. You're not above the game though.

Lets chat.