On January 21 2014 03:17 raynpelikoneet wrote: Okay so you think VE could do pretty much all of these things as town aswell but not all in the same game? Or do you think too much little weird things that add up?
On January 21 2014 03:15 bumatlarge wrote: There is a threshold of how scummy you look by how poor you are playing that you are no longer town. I think VE passed that.
On January 21 2014 03:18 suki wrote: @Rayn I agree that he's not making strong statements and that he seems to be overthinking the 'what if I'm wrong' part of his argument. However, I had a peek at bum's previous games and he plays the same sort of non-commital game as townie.
I think his case makes sense minus the wishy-washiness, and I agree with him that VE has been playing scummy (kush being second on my list).
Do you have more on Kush rayn? If you have something more, I'd like to hear it. I find him difficult to read.
And I believe Barristan is the last person that needs to post. I'd suggest people start to vote now so we can see where we are at. I think there is enough content that people should be able to make some reasonable reads.
On January 21 2014 03:26 raynpelikoneet wrote: I am not even voting for him after his first clarification. Where did you get the idea that i am tunneling him?
- - -
On January 21 2014 02:49 raynpelikoneet wrote: I have absolutely no idea why bumatlarge is voting for VE because he did just say "he did some stuff i find out to be scummy but then again i remember him doing same kinda stuff as town too".
I have no idea what his read on VE is because it's inconsistent.
Perhaps it's just a difference in interpretation, but you start grilling bumatlarge for being 'inconsistent' when I don't see one.
On January 21 2014 03:31 bumatlarge wrote: Do you have more on Kush rayn? If you have something more, I'd like to hear it. I find him difficult to read.
And I believe Barristan is the last person that needs to post. I'd suggest people start to vote now so we can see where we are at. I think there is enough content that people should be able to make some reasonable reads.
What i have on kush is what i have said. He has a townread on half of the people in the game and refuses to explain why. If he is town he has reasons for his reads. If he is scum he has not. Seems like he has not.
On January 21 2014 03:33 kushm4sta wrote: you shouldn't even worry about my alignment, just like I won't worry about rayn's fail wagon on me. I will be pretty solidly town by EoD.
Yeah thats what I'm banking on, but I feel like that isn't a reliable thing for me to bank on.
rayn the reads were weak so there is not a lot of explanation. you kept asking about them, asking more detail, and it got annoying, so i made you stfu about it by leaving.
On January 21 2014 03:26 raynpelikoneet wrote: I am not even voting for him after his first clarification. Where did you get the idea that i am tunneling him?
On January 21 2014 02:49 raynpelikoneet wrote: I have absolutely no idea why bumatlarge is voting for VE because he did just say "he did some stuff i find out to be scummy but then again i remember him doing same kinda stuff as town too".
I have no idea what his read on VE is because it's inconsistent.
Perhaps it's just a difference in interpretation, but you start grilling bumatlarge for being 'inconsistent' when I don't see one.
What, you even agreed with me in saying the case is wishy-washy. How can you call me out for "twisting his words" when you agree with me, because that was what i was saying before he clarified his case?
On January 21 2014 03:31 bumatlarge wrote: Do you have more on Kush rayn? If you have something more, I'd like to hear it. I find him difficult to read.
And I believe Barristan is the last person that needs to post. I'd suggest people start to vote now so we can see where we are at. I think there is enough content that people should be able to make some reasonable reads.
What i have on kush is what i have said. He has a townread on half of the people in the game and refuses to explain why. If he is town he has reasons for his reads. If he is scum he has not. Seems like he has not.
EPT
