|
On May 24 2014 08:16 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
I think yellow is town.
Not so sure on ritoky tho. I'm leaning town, just from meta read.
Okay, going on meta reads right now:
Yellow - town
Val - leaning town
Cav - leaning town
Bunnies - town
tambo - not sure
ritoky - leaning town
Now that I look at them, they're pretty much all town.
"meta read" is bullshit
You have to know a persons play very well to do so correctly why don't you weight in on something that matters. Perhaps you can explain in detail why you think what you think about something relevant?
|
Those two posts frm ritoky look CAREFUL.
He is a great bet for mafia, i had a lot of people agreeing with me but no votes. What gives?
+ Show Spoiler +people were over, i alcoholed sue me
Thing is, (and this is part of why i gave up on jamp,) his list was actually a pretty good assessment of the game at that point
we have 14or so/28 votes cast is it too much to ask for people to be more forthcoming with votes and opinions? Thread feels flat.
|
my notes say that i think mtamburini and kush and probably mafias
i have a reasonable pool of players that i am confident are town
ive been waiting for sqrootnegwhatever to do something today since i don't feel like i could push him at the moment.
erandorr and thrawn need to die.
tbh most of the people i thought or now think might be mafia have stopped playing and the lynch is between people i am fine with
|
oh yeah i don't trust marv but i don't think we need to do anything about it at the moment.
i liked blueuy yesterday and i don't care for the case on him
|
This is why large games suck.
The start is super chaotic and annoying then everyone stops playing.
|
On May 25 2014 10:06 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
What do you suggest?
actually playing mafia for cool points to counterbalance those lost from your name in the eyes of some?
|
oh ive been waiting on valenius too
TAKE NOTE:
marv said that he and BH were confirmed town to each other but i cannot for the life of me find BH agreeing with this which should have been a priority of his the moment he saw that marv had written it. If they are confirmed to each other regardless of whether if helps us now we need to know it before one of them flips. It would leave us exposed to a flip manipulating role but since it's alignment flip it would be a ridiculous level of host setup bullshit for such a role o be there.
|
On May 25 2014 10:37 Alakaslam wrote:Show nested quote +On May 25 2014 10:18 layabout wrote:
oh ive been waiting on valenius too
TAKE NOTE:
marv said that he and BH were confirmed town to each other but i cannot for the life of me find BH agreeing with this which should have been a priority of his the moment he saw that marv had written it. If they are confirmed to each other regardless of whether if helps us now we need to know it before one of them flips. It would leave us exposed to a flip manipulating role but since it's alignment flip it would be a ridiculous level of host setup bullshit for such a role o be there. Call me a fool and hypocrite, but. Say again? No CHUPAZI, no grammar bads, I think I might possibly get what you are saying. I believe it is not complex but my duncery requires you state it differently
CLICK ME
On May 24 2014 06:43 marvellosity wrote:
anyway BH and I are confirmed town to each other, so can we just stop this please?
bh was around bh totally ignored this. Major wtfs if they are both town and and confirmed to each other and that happened
|
On May 25 2014 10:58 Blazinghand wrote:Show nested quote +On May 25 2014 10:47 layabout wrote:On May 25 2014 10:37 Alakaslam wrote:On May 25 2014 10:18 layabout wrote:
oh ive been waiting on valenius too
TAKE NOTE:
marv said that he and BH were confirmed town to each other but i cannot for the life of me find BH agreeing with this which should have been a priority of his the moment he saw that marv had written it. If they are confirmed to each other regardless of whether if helps us now we need to know it before one of them flips. It would leave us exposed to a flip manipulating role but since it's alignment flip it would be a ridiculous level of host setup bullshit for such a role o be there. Call me a fool and hypocrite, but. Say again? No CHUPAZI, no grammar bads, I think I might possibly get what you are saying. I believe it is not complex but my duncery requires you state it differently CLICK MEOn May 24 2014 06:43 marvellosity wrote:
anyway BH and I are confirmed town to each other, so can we just stop this please? bh was around bh totally ignored this. Major wtfs if they are both town and and confirmed to each other and that happened And I'm still ignoring it now! Look at that. 
this is just another bullet point on the imaginary list of reasons for why i hate your play and always want a gun
|
On May 25 2014 11:02 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On May 25 2014 10:09 layabout wrote:On May 25 2014 10:06 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
What do you suggest? actually playing mafia for cool points to counterbalance those lost from your name in the eyes of some? hey you. I think ritoky's recent posts (and especially the last one) is pretty good. why don't you?
Marv just said this
My heuristic is - long walls of text - not alignment indicative
are the long walls of text eminently reasonable? -> mafia
are the long walls of text not that reasonable, tunnelly, hammering away at a certain point, convoluted -> town
marv you asked him stuff and he responded with a wall that you think is good by your own metric that makes him more likely to be maifa.
i think his earlier play very much suggests that he is mafia and a few reasonable looking walls doesn't change that. What are his priorities when he is posting? His recent posts still look like his image is at the top of his agenda.
|
W/e the important bit is the 2nd paragraph
night
|
I refuse to work on the assumption that there are multiple recruiting factions
Ritoky sounds like a rolechecker. I don't understand the timing of his claim nor the fact that he doesn't appear to understand the mechanics of his role. Rito pls, can you clarify?
We need to decide if we are banking on winning with 3p which seems dumb or just killing slam/bh/austin.
Also, congratulations to anybody aligned to the adepts with a non-vanilla role that hasn't claimed halfway into day 2.
|
On May 25 2014 19:48 Xatalos wrote:
Also LOL @ Slam for becoming so townish after being "shot". I think this makes him town for almost certain.
An exposed 3p faction has to appear to be working in towns best interest if they want any chance of town taking a risk and letting them live.
|
On May 25 2014 20:51 ritoky wrote:Show nested quote +On May 25 2014 19:55 layabout wrote:
I refuse to work on the assumption that there are multiple recruiting factions
Ritoky sounds like a rolechecker. I don't understand the timing of his claim nor the fact that he doesn't appear to understand the mechanics of his role. Rito pls, can you clarify?
We need to decide if we are banking on winning with 3p which seems dumb or just killing slam/bh/austin.
Also, congratulations to anybody aligned to the adepts with a non-vanilla role that hasn't claimed halfway into day 2. I am getting ready for work, so I have about 15 minutes to vote and clarify things for anyone if they want it. Won't be back at deadline time. Yes I think in general my role is basically a rolechecker, with a slight variation. As for why I claimed...I thought it was a good time to claim given the state of the game at that time. There wasn't a whole lot of reliable information or stuff in general going on at that point in the phase. Currently I am leaning toward voting austin cuz he hasn't convinced me that his faction's win condition isn't exclusive from town's.
Rolechecker is traditionally a mafia power. But if we work with the assumption that you are town:
Have you asked what happens if you were to target a non-town vanilla role?
When you got the result surely ninja would either be a town blue or scum. The response to this is to stay quiet (you think she is blue) or try to pressure/build a case etc (you think she is mafia).
So why tell us you are unsure about her and then share the check? You are potentially exposing two town blues to mafia, and you haven't used your check to try to influence the lynch, or any other clear town oriented benefit.
|
On May 25 2014 21:18 Xatalos wrote:
He seems like the safest lynch, but not necessarily the best one. If he really can win with town, it'd be good to have him on our side.
It mostly comes down to whether we deal with him or the faction he is against deals with him
On May 25 2014 14:44 austinmcc wrote:
Steve, at least for me, I recruit as a night action.
IF there were other recruiters and IF they work in the same fashion, BH/slam couldn't have recruited each other or anything before the start of D2 basically, so one wouldn't have known about the other or anything.
I think this means we have to lynch him
|
On May 25 2014 21:45 Tehpoofter wrote:
If Austin is telling the truth were missing mafia for two days. I'm out of touch in the thread so I know my voice counts for little but the way Austin acted doesn't seem like caught scum to me.
It doesn't matter that he can with with town since recruiting town reduces town numbers and since he can win when we lose letting him live is a huge and unnecessary risk
|
If we are taking a risk i think there is a pretty good chance kush will flip red.
I don't like how he is happy about austin. I also don't feel like killing austin.
|
i love the way day1 started with an rng lynch and we supposedly have an rng nightshot.
I want to try something convoluted but everything i think of seems really fuckwithable
|
|
|
another hour?
i wanted fire and shit
i soo could of got recruited and got fire powers tonight, this sucks
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
