|
On May 24 2014 03:32 layabout wrote:
"dude" your first game of mafia wasn't even student it was the 80 player one
@ hapa cephiro was one of if not the first players to move the discussion into the realms of because of A and B player C is Mafia
so what
that's not alignment indicative in the slightest
|
can we just get rid of tambo
i mean on top of everything else like end of day shenanigans or meta differences or whatnot the guy basically on pops up when someone says his name and he has to defend himself then goes back to lurkerland
|
On May 24 2014 04:21 Hapahauli wrote:
(snip)
Consider this: I am a factional player and I believe Valenius to be of another faction. Why would I not attempt to tunnel my top scumread to death and push my objective? Hell pushing Valenius would point MORE to be being mafia in this game.
(snip)
On May 24 2014 04:12 austinmcc wrote:
This makes it appear that Hapa doesn't actually have a real read on Valenius, because his read/vote never develop in the right way. People who don't have real reads are making them up. Making reads up is bad and a mafia thing.
you're not addressing his case/premise
he's suggesting that valenius is not actually a real scum read
|
i'm gonna head out for a bit to go climb
in the meantime i feel pretty safe just plopping down my vote on tambo
|
On May 24 2014 05:08 geript wrote:
Wasn't OnceKing a lurker mafia in one of his minis?
ooh saw this first
yep kinda? the game you're talking about is Newbie Mini Mafia LIV and i'll admit to completely lurking all of day 2 or whichever the completely inactive day was
but other than thought i feel like i talked a fair bit
|
Catching up I'm on page 166 now
setup speculation's pretty lame, BH wanted to let us know something, great, we don't even know what it really means how about we catch the mafia instead
like tambo
or as... whoever it is has been saying, kush
I don't think I've seen kush post anything useful they're all stupid statements like
On May 24 2014 06:46 kushm4sta wrote:
wat there is recruitment this game also??? are you fucking kidding me. scumhunting is 100% useless so good luck with that
|
caught up now
cool with lynching:
- tambo
- valenius
- kush
- ritoky
i needa read through thrawn's stuff though looks like a lotta people don't like 'im
|
ebwop totally hopping on dat kush wagon
|
whoops i forgot to add blueyd to the list of people i wouldn't mind see dying today
cav who are your scum reads?
|
what're your opinions on tambo and ritoky? and why ma-- elderly heterosexual peruvian man?
|
don't wanna lynch erandorr today cause i feel his pain as a replacement and want to give him a shot to start contributing
i have no idea how i feel about blueyd now. his defense strikes me as being super genuine and i feel good about mosta his reads buuuuuuuut what erandorr says in these three posts are also good points.
i see some people are having doubts on kush and are skeptical cuz meta case/people jumping on the wagon super fast. whether the case is meta or not doesn't change the fact that kush is objectively being scummy independent of the meta stuff, and we have still over a day before the lynch goes through so there's plenty of time to chinese fire drill/see if counterwagons and stuff start cropping up
|
why are we even speculating about setup when we can be talking about what thrawn or matt/fool have done that makes them town or scum?
someone tell me why thrawn is scum or town, same for matt/fool hydra while i go read their filters
|
thrawn and kush read pretty much the same to me, they're both not really playing
i'm not really seeing why thrawn is giving off worse vibes than kush to you austin but i guess you got that interaction thing (or lack thereof) going on so yea
i'm probably pretty confirmation biased about kush being scum atm, i'm worried about what this might mean since what austin writes makes sense to me so i'm gonna take a break to step back and reevaluate
|
austin, re: "who is tambo" catch
not actually a catch... maybe? reading through the filter the post in which he writes tambo before asking who tambo is was just a broken quote tag.
oh wait going back to check then he says he couldn't say anything about jampi/tambo in the same post
hmm dunno could go either way on this
|
k voting austin
sorry i haven't been around, last two days have been pretty hectic for me
other people who have dropped off the face of the earth: tambo, valenius, thrawn off the top of my head
i mean yeah tambo and valenius have posted recently but that doesn't change the fact that they're still just trying to just get by
now uncertain on ritoky. the defense "feels" genuine but i can't really put my finger on why; looking at his big post it's pretty much just commentary and i don't really agree with his reads lmao.
i dislike the defense of yell0w and hapa's standpoint makes sense to me. if you've got an actual strong scumread there's no purpose to go with rng over a read.
so after today's lynch, ok with lynching:
- tambo
- valenius
- thrawn
- yell0w
|
i think jampidampi's entire discussion of why he was suspicious of MZ after MZ is already dead is pretty pointless. thrawn of course with the ninja vote and not bothering to read the thread needs to go. i also think it's pretty stupid to try to speculate on what night actions as far as austin goes would be if we didn't lynch him today -- we gotta do what's best for the town NOW and barring any better suspects (anyone else have a not-town check on someone??) that's killing austin.
|
is it a peruvian blend
i want to lynch so many people right now it's ridiculous
|
my votes definitely have reasoning behind them
just because i haven't written out miles-long cases doesn't mean i'm just making up shit to vote with
why is it a problem that my lynch targets are people that are quieter
wow onceking is looking for mafia inside of people who don't post much/lurkers, what a terrible player. after all mafia never lurk so looking there is stupid right??
i was on your case before because you never posted any hard reads and this was the first real read you've had all game and it's an omgus
|
also i think it's hilarious that i'm your "read of the day" valenius
"woo i submitted my homework, one person i think is scum. alright my obligation is done now c u tomorrow"
|
who's in the third that's townier than you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
