On May 25 2014 04:26 marvellosity wrote:
isn't the argument being made that

1) kush generally gives zero fucks
2) yet as town he'll make reads and stuff (despite giving (or looking like he gives) zero fucks)

in short I don't think giving zero fucks and making reads are mutually exclusive, which is what you're getting at i think?

^

If you need some clarification when I said the line "We can all agree Kush is a player who gives zero fucks" the thought process was as follows:

1) When Kush is town he will say things like "person X is scum" and "person Y is town" and he gives zero fucks about whether you agree or disagree with him. He'll go after whoever he damn well pleases.
2) When Kush is mafia he will say things like, "I give zero fucks" and just not give reads or do anything for the town.

In both cases he gives zero fucks, but it's what he's giving zero fucks about that's the key.

Don't know why you need to spend 4 pages debating a minor semantic issue. Really it's simple. You called Kush town and gave some reasons why. I used (essentially) the same reasons to say he's mafia. Either:

1) You disagree with the past-game analysis I did (i.e. I drew the wrong conclusion).
2) You agree with the past-game analysis but Kush is still town for other reasons.

If either is the case then say so now. As stated before, if you think that the cases are better on mtaburini, BlueyD, or Ritoky I will gladly move my vote to one of them and not look back. Debating semantics and calling into question me getting mafia lynched is not doing anything for the town.

mattisfoolish

United States76 Posts

May 24 2014 20:06 GMT

#3668

Oh also, who is this sandroba hydra?

mattisfoolish

United States76 Posts

May 26 2014 00:42 GMT

#4492

Can someone clarify for me that no pertinent information occurred which proves Kush is town so I know where to put my vote tomorrow?

mattisfoolish

United States76 Posts

May 26 2014 00:44 GMT

#4495

On May 26 2014 09:43 Erandorr wrote:

Show nested quote +

Can you pretty please start playing the game

Sad thing is I've probably done more than 75% of the players in the game.

mattisfoolish

United States76 Posts

May 26 2014 00:51 GMT

#4509

On May 26 2014 09:45 sqrtofneg1 wrote:

Show nested quote +

In 29 posts?

Yes, you did make cases on people like tambo, but never really stuck to it.

As I said, would still gladly lynch, but there are much better targets. Like the players who haven't contributed anything to the town.

Also trying to figure out factions and stuff in a non-PM like this is really difficult. Night actions will be the only way. In the meantime, just lynch people who aren't doing anything for the town (kushm1sta, etc.). Much more efficient use of time.

mattisfoolish

United States76 Posts

May 26 2014 00:59 GMT

#4519

On May 26 2014 09:54 sqrtofneg1 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Well, if you get vanilla town in a huge game like this, doesn't it take the fun away from it? Doesn't it remove the motivation for playing?
I believe kush complained about getting vanilla town early on this game.

No. Just go scumhunt using the basic techniques. Read my filter for an example.

mattisfoolish

United States76 Posts

May 26 2014 01:16 GMT

#4541

On May 26 2014 10:00 Erandorr wrote:

Show nested quote +

How do you scumhunt using basics when by that logic half the game could be killed.

Not true. You're mindset is messy right now so everyone looks awful. And even still, if you made ~15 cases on people being mafia I'm pretty sure we could easily narrow down the results.