EPTAlso comment on my scum reads post thx
"##" Mafia - Page 30
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Promethelax
Canada7089 Posts
Also comment on my scum reads post thx | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On October 28 2013 21:26 marvellosity wrote: Why not? I see no reason to force things 12 hours or so into the game. I've said what I want to say for now. Weird that you're having a go at me for this when in Hogwarts Mocsta+Hopeless+possibly others had a big go at me for "only" talking about revealing houses when a bunch of other stuff had gone on in the thread. So i guess your reads from what i have gathered so far are scumread on Seuss, townread on Prome and idk on everyone else you commented on? There is this Pandabearguy who currently has three votes on him. Do you have anything to say about him atm? | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
| ||
|
Oatsmaster
United States16628 Posts
On October 28 2013 21:21 Promethelax wrote: So Marv tells you town and you do t lay down the support you already kinda gave, what gives? We're you only going to support me if he said scum? uh. I didnt post since then? Why so worried man? | ||
|
Oatsmaster
United States16628 Posts
Yeah still dunno why you are worried. Also this is odd. Were you only going to support me if he said scum? Why would you think this? I think marv is town, so if marv says you are scum, then I give you powers? That doesnt make sense to me. Please explain. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
| ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
| ||
|
Oatsmaster
United States16628 Posts
i dunno, its hard to express for me. But it doesnt feel like marv is trying to trick us into powering him up. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
On October 28 2013 06:51 WaveofShadow wrote: Hai guise.2) I miss being mafia (or even 3P).  3) My power is boring and semi-useless. I'll use it on somebody later in the day I thinks. 4) It's super pro-town. Be back in a couple hours-ish. On October 28 2013 08:28 WaveofShadow wrote: I find the fact that Pandain even gets a slight scumread from my opening post hilarious. He's played games with me and should know almost every single opening post of mine is along the lines of what I rolled and 1) I often whine about something, often what I rolled.  + Show Spoiler + To me Pandain it looks more like YOU are the one who is trying to contribute something to look good---I don't find anything you picked out regarding me OR Rayn scum-indicative in any way, and as such I find your posting incredibly weak thus far. Oh and I suppose I should have mentioned this before the game started but considering my not-so-great play and the embarrassing length of my filter in Thug, I plan on keeping things way more concise than usual. I do not plan to be in the top few posters lengthwise this game. Make of that what you will. Anyway I'm tempted to fuck off until whatever Sentinel did resolves but I suppose that wouldn't be very helpful. Guess we'll see If we believe what WoS said in (1), then we see him whining about not being mafia in (2). Him being mafia makes it logical he does (1) about (3). (3) and (4) contradict themselves if he is town. How can something be semi-useless and be super pro-town at the same time? Time will tell! Because WoS promised to do it day 1. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On October 28 2013 22:16 Oatsmaster wrote: I dont actually think he will play scum the same way as he did previously, that was a long time ago, but this game fits a lot into town marv. He doesnt wanna talk about people he doesnt want to talk about. i dunno, its hard to express for me. But it doesnt feel like marv is trying to trick us into powering him up. I just read scum!marv and town!marv D1's and this apathy of his does not fit into each one of them. Then i read Catch 22 and it doesn't fit into there. I have no fucking idea what to think. 4th party? Since when has marv not commented on the leading lynch candidate in no way as any alignment? marv what do you you want to talk about? Or are you just going to watch what happens and then what? And why? | ||
|
Oatsmaster
United States16628 Posts
On October 28 2013 22:20 Koshi wrote: If we believe what WoS said in (1), then we see him whining about not being mafia in (2). Him being mafia makes it logical he does (1) about (3). (3) and (4) contradict themselves if he is town. How can something be semi-useless and be super pro-town at the same time? Time will tell! Because WoS promised to do it day 1. uh. He did whine that he didnt roll scum and that he rolled tow. So thats doesnt make him mafia. And pro town =/= useful. Could make him like IC or something, thats pretty boring but really pro town. | ||
|
Oatsmaster
United States16628 Posts
On October 28 2013 22:20 raynpelikoneet wrote: I just read scum!marv and town!marv D1's and this apathy of his does not fit into each one of them. Then i read Catch 22 and it doesn't fit into there. I have no fucking idea what to think. 4th party? Since when has marv not commented on the leading lynch candidate in no way as any alignment? marv what do you you want to talk about? Or are you just going to watch what happens and then what? And why? why dont you read his more recent games? | ||
|
Oatsmaster
United States16628 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On October 28 2013 22:20 raynpelikoneet wrote: I just read scum!marv and town!marv D1's and this apathy of his does not fit into each one of them. Then i read Catch 22 and it doesn't fit into there. I have no fucking idea what to think. 4th party? Since when has marv not commented on the leading lynch candidate in no way as any alignment? marv what do you you want to talk about? Or are you just going to watch what happens and then what? And why? Literally my only relevant towngame is Hogwarts mafia. Mafia games, look at whatever the deuce you like. To the bolded, I don't know why I'm having to repeat myself, but I literally totally declined to comment on the main thing being pushed in the thread near the start of the game in Hogwarts. I've no idea how you're missing this given you're in that game yourself, or given I've already said it once this game. Oats and Cottoncandy have both provided the correct reasons why I can be viewed as town at this stage (not that I'm stating I should be viewed as certain town, before you have a bitchfit). Perhaps you should pay attention? | ||
|
Seuss
United States10536 Posts
On October 28 2013 19:24 marvellosity wrote: You see this followup doesn't make sense. If Seuss is surprised/disappointed at how people were coming out and claiming asap, why then exacerbate the situation by making multiple comments with relation to guessing what these roles and powers were? If you're concerened about people claiming early, why then guess at powers and even ask other people to guess at powers? Boo. I'm an analyst. At the heart of my approach to mafia is finding all the puzzle pieces and putting them together. You can go back to the recent newbie mini mafia game and look through my coach QT with WaveOfShadow and see that it's exactly what I was doing there as well. When I'm given information I try to make sense of it and fit it into the puzzle. Perhaps it was a little egotistical of me, but the purpose of my post was largely admonishment. I wasn't asking others to guess at powers, but pointing out that revealing powers for no reason was stupid because people could guess at them. A bunch of people pulled out their powers immediately, several of whom (including you!) had to backtrack because apparently now wasn't the appropriate or best time for it. That, and the flurry of thoughtless power ups, is what got me in a tizzy. You've let the mafia know you have powers at a point in the game where you apparently don't even want to use them. I don't see how that's good town play. I wouldn't be so mad/confused if I knew you all had good reasons for bringing out your powers, and if I could be certain all of the powers coming into play are town powers. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
On October 28 2013 22:20 raynpelikoneet wrote: I just read scum!marv and town!marv D1's and this apathy of his does not fit into each one of them. Then i read Catch 22 and it doesn't fit into there. I have no fucking idea what to think. 4th party? Since when has marv not commented on the leading lynch candidate in no way as any alignment? marv what do you you want to talk about? Or are you just going to watch what happens and then what? And why? Hmm. Marv in Noir was not really pushing anything hard D1, it felt like he was gathering reads. D2 he fixed that and concentrated more on specific people but still didn't rally town to vote for Cephiro and then N2 he guaranteed Cephiro scumread. LastArgument was an awesome guy but also didn't rally town to vote D1 in Hogwarts. He didn't comment too much on Cephiro except say that his big post was enough to not vote him D1 and then later asked Cephiro some questions. His vote on Palmar was simply explained by "sheep syllo". Marv plays to town meta. But I guess he can emulate that as scum because he is marv. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On October 28 2013 22:24 Oatsmaster wrote: why dont you read his more recent games? What, i read Hogwarts and Golden Sun D1's. If there is more recent town/scum games from him feel free to point them out. Afaik marv has not rolled 3p since Catch 22... On October 28 2013 22:24 Oatsmaster wrote: Also Rayn, what apathy? That he doesnt want to talk about Pandain? He does this shit in every game. He does not comment on what me & you have said about Pandain. He does not comment on Prome's weird "gut scum read on Pandain with no real reasoning". He does not really do anything about his suspicion on Seuss. He points out something that looks bad but doesn't really follow that up in any way. In fact all his posts just point out something without actually trying to do anything to form a better read on anyone (barring WoS - maybe). He just *is* here, but he is not doing anything. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
On October 28 2013 22:27 Seuss wrote: I'm an analyst. At the heart of my approach to mafia is finding all the puzzle pieces and putting them together. You can go back to the recent newbie mini mafia game and look through my coach QT with WaveOfShadow and see that it's exactly what I was doing there as well. When I'm given information I try to make sense of it and fit it into the puzzle. Perhaps it was a little egotistical of me, but the purpose of my post was largely admonishment. I wasn't asking others to guess at powers, but pointing out that revealing powers for no reason was stupid because people could guess at them. A bunch of people pulled out their powers immediately, several of whom (including you!) had to backtrack because apparently now wasn't the appropriate or best time for it. That, and the flurry of thoughtless power ups, is what got me in a tizzy. You've let the mafia know you have powers at a point in the game where you apparently don't even want to use them. I don't see how that's good town play. I wouldn't be so mad/confused if I knew you all had good reasons for bringing out your powers, and if I could be certain all of the powers coming into play are town powers. Just saying I didn't backtrack and ##Update Koshi Is still something all the cool kids do. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On October 28 2013 22:27 Seuss wrote: I'm an analyst. At the heart of my approach to mafia is finding all the puzzle pieces and putting them together. You can go back to the recent newbie mini mafia game and look through my coach QT with WaveOfShadow and see that it's exactly what I was doing there as well. When I'm given information I try to make sense of it and fit it into the puzzle. Perhaps it was a little egotistical of me, but the purpose of my post was largely admonishment. I wasn't asking others to guess at powers, but pointing out that revealing powers for no reason was stupid because people could guess at them. A bunch of people pulled out their powers immediately, several of whom (including you!) had to backtrack because apparently now wasn't the appropriate or best time for it. That, and the flurry of thoughtless power ups, is what got me in a tizzy. You've let the mafia know you have powers at a point in the game where you apparently don't even want to use them. I don't see how that's good town play. I wouldn't be so mad/confused if I knew you all had good reasons for bringing out your powers, and if I could be certain all of the powers coming into play are town powers. I have powers to use night 1 that I can only use with people's cooperation on Day 1. Your 'admonishment' is totally out of place when you do not know the circumstances with which people are talking about their roles. Given that it was made *extremely* obvious by how people posted in the thread that their roles required the cooperation of other people to work (my twerk, sentinel, prome, one or two others i forget probably), your entire angle is totally out of place. I can also tell you free of charge that you can't possibly hope to guess what my powers are based on what I've asked people to type or what people can probably guess my role name is. But no, don't consider this, just criticise... Like, your last sentence... What's the alternative? If both town and mafia need cooperation to use their powers, then they're going to try to achieve said cooperation. Bitching about it is ridiculous. | ||
| ||
