Hogwarts Mafia - Page 28

On November 02 2013 21:13 syllogism wrote:
One of the reasons why the game never made sense to me was that it was difficult to believe mafia had one person posting actively and two people essentially not doing anything, but it's easy to lurker lynch when the game was essentially over on n1. Even easier when you seemingly have red checks supporting the lynches. Yet, it didn't feel like mafia considered the game lost, so the checks probably weren't reliable.

I couldn't figure out what mafia framer was doing on n1 since it didn't target Ravenclaw, seemingly didn't target Huffle and framing Gryffin or Slytherin also seemed bad options. Gryffin had Pandain who people were ignoring and Slytherin had at least two mafia + miller. Grack concluding very early that everyone in Huffle was weird, but not thinking or reading and just playing on autopilot is easier. If the mafia framer can also make someone look innocent to checks, it makes most sense to target a house with 2 mafia or more mafia in it. After 3 flips the framer will obviously target houses that haven't been checked and guilty framing.

Skanjab was absolutely correct in that it didn't make sense for one house to have 3 mafia + self-aware miller, but again when you can just lynch through all the possibilities it's easier to just not care.