Hogwarts Mafia - Page 201

On October 25 2013 03:57 Holyflare wrote:


Do you know what the scum powers are? If hopeless potion stops someone from voting, don't you think that is a counter to secret votes? We only know about invunerability so far, how do we know he isn't lying? Plus there are potentially 2 other scum when cephiro flips red and you don't know their powers. Or do YOU?

On October 24 2013 16:32 syllogism wrote:
Mafia would have given the potion away on n1. When I received potion, I also got a PM telling exactly what it does. He can next give the "if target dies they live another 24 hours" potion. These potions make absolutely no sense for mafia, especially considering the person who gets the potion is told what they do.

On October 24 2013 16:38 syllogism wrote:
Correcion: when I drank the potion I was told what it did.

On October 25 2013 03:58 Holyflare wrote:


You're so full of crap, I've pushed plenty of scummy things. Mattchew, you, etc.

On October 25 2013 03:58 Onegu wrote:



No, my abilty is still useful and I wont claim yet.

On October 25 2013 04:00 Holyflare wrote:
Oh it looked like you were telling me to get interesting, sorry.



totally why everyones votes are on you

On October 25 2013 00:06 Cephiro wrote:


Fighting against releasing house lists. At this point in the game, there are 3 flipped scum in different houses, which means the only one it benefits is scum. As I proved earlier in the game by statistics, it is also very unlikely (~9%), that scum would not have this information. He was trying to prevent others from gaining information he already has as scum.

Onegu also constantly apologises, which is something some players consider a scumtell. (For me personally, I don't completely agree on that.)



This post on ET. If you check Pandain's filter at start, he was always having a go at ET. It looks to me like it was agreed upon in the scum QT that ET would be someone the majority could buss and gain towncred from.



Wants to make a case on Mattchew, but he never makes one, although he ends up voting for him without proper reasoning.



Could be considered as trying to fish for more information about the check. (Maybe there are two scum in hufflepuff? Although unlikely.)



This a great post. 3 town targets to easily choose from, pick the afk-medic. (Not saying they knew it at this point, but it is a possibility.)

These are his amazing filter reading skills:


into



Conviniently enough, he never even follows up with a one-liner of his skanjabs opinion. Maybe because they are scumbuddies?



He never mentions who this another flip is, or why it would affect his read on skanjab1s. He's just not interested in lynching scum.



Funny yes. That's exactly what he did, he bussed ET.



More fire on BH, as well as stupid theories for the modkills. It's like he wants to distract attention from the one scum remaining in hufflepuff. (Holyflare?)



^ Can syllo confirm this?

He posts a lot to chime his opinion in, but he's not actively working towards anything. Add that he seems to have a role with powers which he hasn't claimed, I just can't find anything about this guy pushing a pro-town motive. It's more like "I'm quietly here, chiming in my opinion sometimes, keep ignoring me."

On October 25 2013 04:19 Holyflare wrote:
Where the hell did I say immortality was a lie? He has 4 different potions, immortality certainly isn't town aligned but yes the reveal in pm suggests otherwise. The point is that you don't know scum powers so you do not know what counters secret votes.