Desert Mini Mafia - Page 3

On August 30 2013 14:26 sciberbia wrote:
What do you guys think of Oats? Maybe it's partly because he did the vast majority of his posting while I was sleeping, but he seems very 'under the radar' to me. I have no good reasons to think he's town, and a few parts of his filter make me raise my eyebrows:

-- insistence that TK is scum based solely on his opening rayn vote and posting some wishy wash reads. This just seems like a very easy case for Oats to make and could be easily fabricated. I don't see any spark of analytical insight, which I think I'm correct in expecting from a town Oats.
+ Show Spoiler [oats insisting] +

-- speaking of easy criticisms, he repeatedly criticizes rayn, which would be fine if he ever went somewhere with it, but he doesn't, and in fact outright says he doesn't think rayn is scum, so why all the criticisms? To try to make rayn look bad? Why?
+ Show Spoiler [criticisms] +

---

I will be very interested to see where he goes next since it seems he has been sleeping/busy since this game really got rolling, but for now he is another one I'm leaning scum on.

On August 29 2013 20:10 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Oats can you clarify to me why exactly are you suspicious of Tutankoopa? Has his policy vote something to do with it and if it does, what?

On August 29 2013 22:46 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Oats can you make a case on me if you think i am scum? I would really like your thought process gathered together in a well-construced post.

On August 29 2013 08:35 Oatsmaster wrote:
I have no fucking idea why you would vote for someone then 5 minutes later say that they are town.
NO CLUE.
Also that post doesnt make him scum or town. Remember Titanic?

On August 29 2013 21:35 Oatsmaster wrote:
Thats a horrible way to find a day 1 lynch Rayn.

Marv wanna lynch Rayn?

On August 29 2013 23:32 Oatsmaster wrote:
hey rayn, why did you vote for sno? I still dont get it.

On August 31 2013 06:06 Oatsmaster wrote:
I sheep you like every fucking game rayn. Dont beg, its unbecoming.

On August 30 2013 14:26 sciberbia wrote:
What do you guys think of Oats? Maybe it's partly because he did the vast majority of his posting while I was sleeping, but he seems very 'under the radar' to me. I have no good reasons to think he's town, and a few parts of his filter make me raise my eyebrows:

-- insistence that TK is scum based solely on his opening rayn vote and posting some wishy wash reads. This just seems like a very easy case for Oats to make and could be easily fabricated. I don't see any spark of analytical insight, which I think I'm correct in expecting from a town Oats.
+ Show Spoiler [oats insisting] +

-- speaking of easy criticisms, he repeatedly criticizes rayn, which would be fine if he ever went somewhere with it, but he doesn't, and in fact outright says he doesn't think rayn is scum, so why all the criticisms? To try to make rayn look bad? Why?
+ Show Spoiler [criticisms] +

---

I will be very interested to see where he goes next since it seems he has been sleeping/busy since this game really got rolling, but for now he is another one I'm leaning scum on.

On August 31 2013 07:06 sciberbia wrote:

@hapa
yea so I was just making another post on him and I think that's the direction I want to go.

Here is my summary of his first day of posting, which was scummy.
+ Show Spoiler [me] +

Notice how at the bottom I conclude that he's been scummy so far, but in fairness I point out that he hasn't had too many chances to contribute yet. Well what has he done today? Nothing at all.

His re-entrance to the thread was very suspicious to me and I agree with what you and marv wrote about it. He just completely back-flipped on all his previous reads to conform with thread sentiment.

He has also had the chance to contribute towards this lynch but has completely refrained from doing so. I honestly don't know what he has been doing since he first disappeared from the thread like 30 hours ago. At least Sylencia is genuinely sleeping right now.

I'd like to add that all of his posts seem completely unconstructive to me. That is the vibe I get from him. It's like he is just sitting around in the thread, debunking other people's ideas when he sees an opportunity, without making any sustained push of his own. He has also spent an inordinate amount of time criticizing other players, especially rayn, which strikes me as scum motivated.

I don't know why I'm not getting more support for an Oats lynch but I hope that changes. I think I'd actually be surprised to see Oats flip town which I can't say about anyone else right now.

##Vote: Oatsmaster