|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
Poll: What is your opinion on the state of post-game analysis?I'd prefer more structured player specific analysis (10) 53% I'd prefer more structured game specific analysis (6) 32% I'd prefer more unstructured analysis (2) 11% I believe there is a sufficient amount of post-game content (1) 5% I'd prefer more structured setup specific analysis (0) 0% 19 total votes Your vote: What is your opinion on the state of post-game analysis? (Vote): I'd prefer more structured game specific analysis
(Vote): I'd prefer more structured player specific analysis
(Vote): I'd prefer more structured setup specific analysis
(Vote): I'd prefer more unstructured analysis
(Vote): I believe there is a sufficient amount of post-game content
Assuming all of the above is not an option, which would you like to see more of?
Game specific analysis refers to when a host, player, or observer agrees to write up a lengthy post discussing the major events of the game and the actions taken by the town or mafia team as a whole.
Player specific analysis refers to critique provided to individuals, discussing the decisions that they made and ways they may improve in future games.
Setup specific analysis refers to a discussion of the mechanics, roles, balance and potential improvements for future iterations of the setup.
Unstructured analysis refers to the general post game discussions that are usually more casual and not dominated by a single analyst.
|
Voted for "I'd prefer more structured player specific analysis". I am always a fan of knowing how i did in the game and how to improve. Usually though, talking with players in constructive manner after the game gives the same result so i could aswell vote for "I'd prefer more structured game specific analysis".
|
Player-specific is too much to ask IMO, unless you have dedicated analysts, though I'm sure some of it comes through in the game's overall analysis.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
Voted game-specific analysis.
I'm usually hyper aware of what I did wrong and right, it's pretty rare someone gives me feedback I'm not already aware of myself
|
Yeah game is probably more useful than player for people who know what they do wrong. For people like me I don't want some long thing analysis of my play, just something that says "Hey Risen you missed X or you look scummy when you do Y."
|
Really anything is better than the post-game flame fests of late.
Analysis in any form is fine, but people need to remember this is just a game and need to cut down on their level of emotional involvement.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On October 15 2013 09:58 Hapahauli wrote:
Really anything is better than the post-game flame fests of late.
Analysis in any form is fine, but people need to remember this is just a game and need to cut down on their level of emotional involvement.
This is akin to a person saying "Relax!" to a person in an agitated state 
|
On October 15 2013 18:31 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On October 15 2013 09:58 Hapahauli wrote:
Really anything is better than the post-game flame fests of late.
Analysis in any form is fine, but people need to remember this is just a game and need to cut down on their level of emotional involvement. This is akin to a person saying "Relax!" to a person in an agitated state
Doesn't mean it doesn't need to be said though =/
|
I'd rather see game-specific analysis overall, I think it would be the most helpful.
Although as someone who intends to host more than he plays, I wouldn't mind seeing some setup-specific analysis too.
|
|
|
note that I'm not Kitaman
Poll: Would you be interested in playing a Resistance game?Yes (15) 56% What is Resistance? (7) 26% No (4) 15% As a voice game (1) 4% 27 total votes Your vote: Would you be interested in playing a Resistance game? (Vote): Yes
(Vote): No
(Vote): What is Resistance?
(Vote): As a voice game
If you answered "What is Resistance?" check these
|
|
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
FirmTofu wanted to host a resistance game!
|
Im hosting one right now. should be interesting.
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On October 24 2013 15:00 Aquanim wrote:
note that I'm not Kitaman
Phew, you had me confused for a second.
Anyone is obviously more than welcome to post a poll at any time by the way!
|
Resistance is fun but I'm not so sure how much I'd like it in a forum format to be honest.
I like killing people
|
On October 24 2013 15:03 Foolishness wrote:
FirmTofu wanted to host a resistance game!
As did VE back in the day.
|
|
|
I think kita has some sort of portal into my mind.
-FT
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On October 25 2013 06:33 You-Know-Who wrote:
I think kita has some sort of portal into my mind.
-FT
It's not pretty in there.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
