|
I was surprised when I learned that Koshi was scum in the ObsQT. I must say that you played the role of a newbie townie very well  Chezinu didn't really surprise me, and I wonder why I didn't pursue him at all after D1...? It was also pretty clever by Oatsmaster to save me D1 and then coast by not doing much (even saving Ace lol). DI played... well, more like didn't play, which is his scum meta apparently, so it's a shame we didn't lynch him D1. Ace played well to fool me (and most others) during D2, although he messed up a bit during N1.
Overall I think scum deserved to win and town (as an average) deserved to lose. Both sides had unmotivated lurkers, but scum was pretty much in control of the game from start to finish (plus town self-destructed constantly, myself included - for example the ON lynch and the jampidampi lynch).
|
Oh btw,
My role PM:
Original Message From Artanis[Xp]: You are Zombie Kim Jong Il! You managed to create a nuke. Unfortunately, it's very unstable and will self explode within 48 hours, killing you instantly unless you fire it. To nuke someone, simply post ##Nuke Playername in the thread and that player will be nuked at the end of the next deadline. Your teammates are: Dandel Ion, Ace, Oatsmaster, Ghost_403, and MajuGarzett. You can find the QT here: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/EhT7HRZnbFE
TOLD YOU GUYS I WAS ALREADY DEAD!!!
|
Haha such an active ScumQT..
|
GG. I knew Chez was the scum, Oats I had a hunch on, but Koshi I would've never guessed. I even thought he redeemed ghost and avoided looking in that direction.
GG
|
Oh Almost forgot!
Dandelion broke the Chezinu rule!! IT IS STILL FLAWLESS!!!
I pretended Xara broke the rule. hehe
|
On July 21 2013 07:49 Chezinu wrote:
Oh Almost forgot!
Dandelion broke the Chezinu rule!! IT IS STILL FLAWLESS!!!
I pretended Xara broke the rule. hehe
Next time I get a nuke I'll just nuke you right away
|
On July 21 2013 07:49 Chezinu wrote:
Oh Almost forgot!
Dandelion broke the Chezinu rule!! IT IS STILL FLAWLESS!!!
I pretended Xara broke the rule. hehe
Once u tell me what it is I might stop breaking it.
Probably not though.
also
gg yo
|
We were pretty lucky that right after that nuke fell on CA people started dieing mysteriously. Was perfect because it was 24h earlier that I visited them with the rad nuke from Ace. We really needed that lynch on CA. He was immune to nukes and had still an extra NK live.
This post below was the funniest post in this thread, when Chez thought he was going to die.
On July 18 2013 05:32 Chezinu wrote:
Johnny, before I blow up. I want you to know something.
I am your father. You were right. You are going to be the next great dictator. When I am gone, please wear the otter-fur hat in remembrance of me. It was not your fault. The reason I'm going to die is not because of you. Do not let them scum deceive you. You are a great son. You will be a great leader!
If anyone does not mourn for me, there will be consequences.
|
Ugh.
Gg scum, we defs deserved to lose this.
Too much derp and too much lurk.
|
Lolz Chezinu...
"Remember that scum can be logical and town can be illogical (geript is a prime example)" -Xata
LOL
more like:
Remember that scum can be logical and town can be illogical (Xata is a prime example)
I don't see where I did anything as illogical as geript 1) not saving me or Meapak, 2) then saving jampi, and 3) then wasting the lynch on him?
|
Pretty funny to read through the scumQT  Now I'm sad that I (or we Immune Ones) roleclaimed... Otherwise at least one of us would have probably been infected (a waste for scum and more KP for town!). Damn. Also there's a chance I might have been spared from NK without that stupid nuke-receiving mess. I'm too open with my information it seems 
|
Although there was no way to know that only scum had Radiation....
|
Yeah this game had some really lucky coincidences for scum, all the immune ones claiming and then all the immune ones fighting each other who the immune scum was :D
|
GG guys. This game got me modkilled in Sicilian.
|
/worship Lord Chezinu of the Chezinu Banking System.
|
On July 21 2013 08:36 FirmTofu wrote:
GG guys. This game got me modkilled in Sicilian.
Why?
|
On July 21 2013 08:39 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2013 08:36 FirmTofu wrote:
GG guys. This game got me modkilled in Sicilian. Why?
Posting PM roles like a boss.
|
Few things...
I think Koshi was catchable based on a drastic change to his tone. Look at how he started the game:
On July 11 2013 08:47 Koshi wrote:
I can't make anything concrete out of this game. But I'll add some ideas I had while trying to catch up. I don't know if they are useful for the game, but they might be useful for you guys to profile me. They are in a random order.
- Stutters695 is doing nothing. His last post was 30 hours ago saying that he was "in full force".
- During the vote for lynch there were so many people going for random targets. I don't understand why anyone would want to do that.
- FirmTofu is pointing fingers a lot (7 players) but most of the time to targets that are never going to get lynched. Or at least not in the first 96 hours. During the lynch he stayed on VA while his first scum target was DI. OriginalName was one of the guys that wasn't yet called out by him. I don't understand why he didn't vote on DI. And now he is on jampidampi...
- austinmcc his posts are clear and well constructed. I could see myself following his lead. He looks a bit like me in my previous game (this is not a compliment), a lot of suspicious post in the first day but completely picking his game up after that. I don't really understand how the bickering with Oats started, but I can find myself in the reasoning. However, with Xatalos bringing up that defense... Also, wouldn't it be smart for Oats to just not defend and keep his mouth shut? Now he lost his defensive missile on Day 1. But like I said, austinmcc is town for me.
- Chezina is completely random. Too much imagination or too much time on his hands, probably both. Scum or blue role that doesn't want to die? Anyway, I like the content of his posts. For amusement.
- Z-Boson is another completely random guy, but unlike Chez he seems to have an agenda. I don't know, he posts like he is not part of the town, like a guy on his own. If I knew from myself I wouldn't be superactive, I would be more like a sheep, following the active guys. I see him as 3rd party but that is only because he is not playing ball.
- I dont understand why Ryan died. I actually wanted to make a post about how he was probably scum, I was pretty proud of myself until I saw he died during night 1...
- I can't figure out Ace, WoS, geript. I read their posts and my brain just can't comprehend what is happening. It might be because I joined this game late. I did like geript his analysis on the 2 night kills.
Anyway, I am also going to bed. I will be posting a lot tomorrow when I am at work :D
On July 13 2013 05:59 Koshi wrote:
geript, can you explain to me how people search for scum in mafia? Because clearly I am doing it wrong. Isn't it by picking unlogical posts and analyze them?
Just a couple selections, but the trend is pretty consistent. We are to believe that this guy doesn't know how to find scum/doesn't know or understand much of anything. Contrast this with his later posts.
On July 16 2013 19:03 Koshi wrote:
Geript is 100% scum, nuke from MG is probably a fake nuke. MG & geript are scum
Geript
1) He shoots down nuke from MG to save jampi
2) He votes MG
3) He changes MG and seals the the deal on jampi. ( I checked, he was the guy who sealed the deal)
4) He keeps whining about MG
5) More whining about MG and votes MG again
6) Changes for gumshoe and doesn't vote MG
7) Whines about MG
8) Flames me the third time, I really don't see why but w.e
9) Votes on MG and says he goes afk for 40 hours
10) Derails the thread with bullshit.
At the end of this day?
11) geript changes votes of MG
12) Nuke on geript is fake
Fuck you geript. Piece of shit.
On July 16 2013 23:54 Koshi wrote:
Scumteam
Ace
Geript
MG
SnB/CA
Here we go. I am quite certain it is something like this.
On July 18 2013 02:01 Koshi wrote:
Seriously if you guys can't read 100% scums now I am going to be disappointed.
Now he's got 100% scum reads and is picking out the whole scum team? Even with replacing in, there is really no solid explanation for the drastic change in play-style. This would have raised my eyebrows if I was playing. Also asking a scum read for advice on how to find scum was lol ;D
Ace+Chezinu
THIS POST
On July 09 2013 01:33 Ace wrote:
##unvote Chezinu
His nuke is possibly harmless, and he only nuked Xata because he was retaliating. Of course he didn't read the thread and realized the nuke wasn't real because he's a troll.
A scum flip from either should have caused a lynch on the other based on this quote alone. Ace backing off here was waaaay weird.
Like Marv said in the obs, Chez nuke on Xata should have gotten him into a lot of hot water. Not sure how he skated by so long, nonsense posting or not.
|
I knew it was some combo of Koshi/Oats/Chez/CA but CA was my main choice and Koshi had a couple inconsistencies I noticed but nothing I felt was that bad compared to how anti town everyone else(town included) was.
GGWP
|
And by that I mean I really wouldn't have lynched Koshi unless we got through the others without getting endgamed. GG, def had me fooled.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
