Smurf Mini Mafia - Page 34

On May 31 2013 22:41 A McGann wrote:


I've liked what I've seen out of Eccleston as of late. His confusion and questioning of Hurndall's wagon hopping antics feels legitimate. This post in particular, I like. Having the presence of mind to admit when you're reaching and making a crappy post shows a more care-free nature than id expect from scum. I'd be comfortable taking him off the table.


JPertwee on the other hand, I am not so sure. This post bothers me. JPertwee says that Dr. Tennant is a good lynch today for the reasons everyone else has brought forward, yet wants to derail that lynch in favour of killing the RP'er with a single post. Further on JPertwee backtracks his initial verdict on Dr.Tennant saying that the case on Dr.Tennant isn't a slam dunk and the points against Dr.Tennant are not exclusive to a scum mindset. I particularly don't like the way JPertwee states 'I'll consolidate on Dr.Tennant if it comes to that' - If the case has merit and you agree that he is a good lynch (as he seems to), then no one should have to twist your arm to get you to vote your scum read.


I'm suspicious on the push on PTroughton. He looks like the kind of bait that scum usually latch onto and try to vilify as anti-town. That said, he could stand to voice some more opinions and preferably leave the flavour text to the hosts.

On May 30 2013 10:08 DrTennant wrote:
Smocoy i don't really care that you think im scum the only part that concerns me is the last part of your post where you say that your unlikely to change. Now i think with your effort and you confidence that your most likely to be town. Misguided town but town nonetheless. And that all the information that i care about from your case. Now it seems like you have gone into tunnel mode with that last part of your post and i think thats insanely stupid one because im not scum and two a ton of people haven't posted.

For what its worth yes i do actually think town are more likely to thrown town reads out there. Scum are more worried about keeping a "story" straight so they are more reluctant to give out reads then be called out later if they flip flop. Mafia have an information advantage and usually are reluctant to give it out.

You seem to think that your post communicated a lot more than it did. I took as wishy washy and filler post and that is scummy

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That said i dont really mind the spotlight i i thrive in it. And most importantly it helps to make reads. With a ton of people not posting i think there is a definite possibility of 1 or even 2 scum being completely inactive.

Of the "active" posters the ones that concern me the most are eccleston and baker.

Eccelston despite being active early seems to have just decided to fuck off while i been in the spotlight despite his hig activity early. He hasn't given an opinion on anything that has happened despite showing he was active early on.

Baker it appears from my perspective has just decided to sheep who i think is the towniest guy in mccoy and who might have the largest thread control. Baker never gave reasoning he just called mccoy smart and it looks like he is just trying to latch on to an early wagon.

On June 03 2013 05:09 Hurndall3 wrote:
##vote td
jp is looking town from that last post. going with the alternate wagon. Besides I thought td looked scummy from his first post.

On June 03 2013 07:53 Hurndall3 wrote:
ya ecc or td id lynch either of those

On June 03 2013 08:11 Hurndall3 wrote:


his recent post looks hella town.

On June 04 2013 11:10 Hurndall3 wrote:
fuck I guess my vote is really outdated.
##unvote
##vote JP
NOT THAT IT MATTERS