|
On March 27 2013 05:04 ObviousOne wrote:
EBWOP:
To add, it reads to me like you are potentially looking for support on lynching people who are suspicious of you without calling them scum. You are also indirectly defending Grack by having me consider him as a candidate today.
No, i will not support lynching Cora. Because i think he is town.
|
Don't y'all just love how pro-town snb is being right now?
Dude totally tries to find scum. totally.
pro-town guys.
|
On March 27 2013 05:05 ObviousOne wrote:
EBWOP: (sorry for triple)
To finish the thought, you're really just defending Grack outright without giving me a proper alternative and I don't like it.
I just gave you some names who are not you.
Oats / Smurf. Why not lynch them?
|
On March 27 2013 05:06 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 27 2013 05:04 ObviousOne wrote:
EBWOP:
To add, it reads to me like you are potentially looking for support on lynching people who are suspicious of you without calling them scum. You are also indirectly defending Grack by having me consider him as a candidate today. No, i will not support lynching Cora. Because i think he is town.
K then garner your support elsewhere or provide a scummier target; I'm set on Grack for now.
|
On March 27 2013 04:56 Keirathi wrote:Show nested quote +On March 27 2013 04:53 Nisani201 wrote:On March 27 2013 04:47 Keirathi wrote:On March 27 2013 04:45 Nisani201 wrote:On March 27 2013 04:40 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Nisani: Why does Smurf look town now? He never looked scum. The case he made was scumbait, it didn't catch anyone, he backpedaled, and now he's contributing to the thread. Why are you so sure it was a "scumbait" case? Smurf never said "okay, okay. I was faking this case" or anything of the sort. He admitted that he was wrong, but that's a pretty huge difference. Well it's possible that he believed the case when he wrote it. I don't think he did, but I can't explain his actions. Why do you not think that he believed it when he made it? That's the part I'm confused about. Literally everything his has said about it after-the-fact points to him believing it when he said it, then changing his mind after people pointed out how terrible it was and him doing a bit more research.
Because it was a really bad case. Even if he wasn't wrong about his meta analysis, it still would have been a bad case.
I think we should stop discussing this until Smurf himself comes back to clear this up.
|
On March 27 2013 04:28 Nisani201 wrote:
Good morning everyone.
The case on Grack is really weak, and if it were made by someone other than Palmar it probably wouldn't be getting nearly as far as it is now.
Just because Smurf made a bad case doesn't mean he's scum. He looks town now and there shouldn't be any suspicion on him.
Acrofales is making a bit more sense but his case on me is just a bunch of OMGUS. Acro, who is your secondary suspect?
So... you have gone from having me as a scumspect for a terrible reason to throwing out some town reads. Who do you think is scum?
There are a bunch of people I think could be scum as well. Cora, Sinani and OO are currently vying for second spot. I just looked over OO's town meta in Fruity and LX and it is very different from his play this game. Far more engaged and discussing things with people, less over-analysing and vague reads.
|
@sinani206 Why haven't you been playing mafia for ages and what made you suddenly come back to this game?
@Acrofales What you think about Palmar? What did Nisani201 say to make you think that he is scum? Just a line or two, I'm not a big fan of huge posts. And yes, I did read your filter so please bear with me if there was something I didn't understand and say it one more time 
@InsertSmurfHere
On March 26 2013 23:38 InsertSmurfHere wrote:
[...]
Prplhz I have seen be lurky early as town, but by the end of day 1 I expect to know his alignment. He's good enough as town to put forth effort justifying his suspicions.
[...]
That can't be true unless you're like ... no, that can't be true.
|
On March 27 2013 05:09 prplhz wrote:@sinani206 Why haven't you been playing mafia for ages and what made you suddenly come back to this game? @Acrofales What you think about Palmar? What did Nisani201 say to make you think that he is scum? Just a line or two, I'm not a big fan of huge posts. And yes, I did read your filter so please bear with me if there was something I didn't understand and say it one more time @InsertSmurfHere Show nested quote +On March 26 2013 23:38 InsertSmurfHere wrote:
[...]
Prplhz I have seen be lurky early as town, but by the end of day 1 I expect to know his alignment. He's good enough as town to put forth effort justifying his suspicions.
[...]
That can't be true unless you're like ... no, that can't be true.
Why did you vote Grack?
Why haven't you given a shit about this game so far?
|
On March 27 2013 05:08 Acrofales wrote:Show nested quote +On March 27 2013 04:28 Nisani201 wrote:
Good morning everyone.
The case on Grack is really weak, and if it were made by someone other than Palmar it probably wouldn't be getting nearly as far as it is now.
Just because Smurf made a bad case doesn't mean he's scum. He looks town now and there shouldn't be any suspicion on him.
Acrofales is making a bit more sense but his case on me is just a bunch of OMGUS. Acro, who is your secondary suspect? So... you have gone from having me as a scumspect for a terrible reason to throwing out some town reads. Who do you think is scum? There are a bunch of people I think could be scum as well. Cora, Sinani and OO are currently vying for second spot. I just looked over OO's town meta in Fruity and LX and it is very different from his play this game. Far more engaged and discussing things with people, less over-analysing and vague reads.
Please clarify what you are saying here about me. The sentence structure lends itself to misinterpretation.
|
On March 27 2013 05:07 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 27 2013 05:05 ObviousOne wrote:
EBWOP: (sorry for triple)
To finish the thought, you're really just defending Grack outright without giving me a proper alternative and I don't like it. I just gave you some names who are not you. Oats / Smurf. Why not lynch them?
Get off your ridiculous reasoning and tell us why other than 'go look at my filter, I cba to explain it to you'
If you dont know specifically why or if you cant concisely put down a few reasons, how could we think of these people as scum? (yes it includes me, no thats not the point)
|
holy shit prplhz is back
prplhz could you comment on the grackaroni cases as presented variously by palmar, keirathi, and others?
Who do you think is the best lynch for today?
|
I'd also very much like to hear Hapahauli's updated opinion of Marvellosity.
|
@Keirathi @strongandbig
I voted Grackaroni for all the reasons presented by Palmar, Hapahauli and Keirathi. I liked them all. He's also the best lynch.
I haven't been around much so far which is the explanation for why I didn't post a lot. Just got up to date on the thread. My Grackaroni vote was around page 16 and nothing has changed my mind since that.
|
Nisani can you go into more detail as to why you think Grackaroni is town? I feel like that's kind of too important a point to just throw out like that without any explanation or discussion, given that he's the vote leader at the moment (i think).
|
On March 27 2013 05:18 prplhz wrote:
@Keirathi @strongandbig
I voted Grackaroni for all the reasons presented by Palmar, Hapahauli and Keirathi. I liked them all. He's also the best lynch.
I haven't been around much so far which is the explanation for why I didn't post a lot. Just got up to date on the thread. My Grackaroni vote was around page 16 and nothing has changed my mind since that.
Cool. Now we need a second scum read from you, so take a few minutes to digest the thread and tell us one other player you would lynch today and a few brief reasons why.
|
Okay prp, that makes sense but I'm trying to get you to put a little more of your reasoning out here in the thread. Could you comment on one of the various 1v1's that appear to be going on right now? (examples: acrofales vs nisani, ryan vs obviousone, etc)
|
On March 27 2013 05:20 strongandbig wrote:
Nisani can you go into more detail as to why you think Grackaroni is town? I feel like that's kind of too important a point to just throw out like that without any explanation or discussion, given that he's the vote leader at the moment (i think).
SNB: unless I'm misremembering which is entirely possible given this headache, the only two people who think Grackaroni is town and have expressed as much are Nisani and Rayn? Do you think this is a good sign that the lynch is indeed mafia or is their resistance to his lynch coming from a town mindset? I feel like that's where you're going with this question so I would like to hear the answer to it as well.
|
The initial case on Grack was bad, it was based off of his reactions to certain things, which weren't really scummy. He didn't do anything scummy after that. As I said earlier, the only reason people are voting for him is because of Palmar.
|
@strongandbig I didn't really follow the raynpelikoneet debacles because he's posting a lot and picking fights with everybody and he's grandmother and that's a plus for now.
|
On March 27 2013 05:30 Nisani201 wrote:
The initial case on Grack was bad, it was based off of his reactions to certain things, which weren't really scummy. He didn't do anything scummy after that. As I said earlier, the only reason people are voting for him is because of Palmar.
Aren't you worried that Palmar is making bad cases and people are just sheeping them? It kinda seems like you think it's a bad thing but you're perfectly fine with it.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
