Newbie Mafia XXXIX - Page 28

On March 29 2013 22:29 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Okay doctor vs roleblocker makes sense so virtu is probably telling the truth and Raven is Rainbow's scumbuddy.

On March 29 2013 22:35 virtu wrote:


Why does doctor vs roleblocker make sense? why doesn't cop + rb?

On March 29 2013 23:14 virtu wrote:
I've already explained it - Because I don't think both of them are town.

On March 29 2013 23:17 TheRavensName wrote:
Well Jarjar, your so certain Ray is town but... have you ever considered maybe both claims ARE true? What if Virtu rolled GF and Ray rolled Mafia Roll blocker? What are your thoughts on Ray being a lier? He lurked pretty hard after the cop claim till you started to doubt it.

On March 29 2013 23:18 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Really, that's all the effort you are willing to put into this?

On March 29 2013 23:21 raynpelikoneet wrote:

That's pretty damn bad assumption right there. There is no way mafia has both GF and roleblocker. And if that was true why the fuck would we not use our roleblock and have the GF instead claim being roleblocked? That's like the stupidest thing to do when you can actually prevent roles from acting instead.

On March 29 2013 23:33 virtu wrote:
EBWOP: For the record, I don't think TRN has been particularly townie looking either, but I feel I have no choice but to trust Rainbows claim over JarJar's. Either i'm right and ray/JarJar are scum, or i'm wrong and Rainbows/TRN are scum. It's as simple as that.

You attempting to question me (by the way, all you've done all game is ask people questions, which at first glance looks quite useful, but a lot of what I'm reading looks like attempts to divert the conversation, distract etc), doesn't suddenly make Rainbows claim look fake and JarJar's real.

On March 29 2013 23:47 raynpelikoneet wrote:

It's distracting only if you don't make conclusions from your questions. I think i have been clear to offer my thoughts after people have answered me - i mean, i ask question, they answer, i make conclusions from the answers and point them out in thread.

My reason behind the question is this. If you are town you can easily come up with any possible scum combos assuming Rainbows/JarJar are both telling the truth and have a reasonable answer (if you think it's possible or not). If you are mafia it's much harder because you do not want to out your scumbuddy and you want to lynch a townie this phase and other players might see the flaws in your logic. That's what i was after.

Now it's irrelevant becauase you dodged the question already and threw the ball back at me by discrediting my playstyle.

On March 29 2013 22:18 virtu wrote:
JarJar moved his vote to TRN here, meaning at some point during this day he's voted for every single other person that has had a vote, I can't bring myself to believe this is town play, voting for 4 different people when there aren't even 4 mafia?

On March 29 2013 23:52 JarJarDrinks wrote:
You're looking @ things through a vacuum. Read the entire day and see how things went down and you'll see how my votes made sense:

I voted for NW after making what I thought was a decent case. The case kinda fell apart as the day went on cause it relied on 2 things:

- that Fishgle was a likely lynch candidate for the day which Ray pointed out to me that the Fishgle suspicion mostly occured after the action deadline

- that Ray and Rainbows were both town. As the day went on, Rainbows started looking scummier and scummier.

So I moved off of NW and on to you. Surely you can't blame me there right? You hadn't voted/posted/done anything. And I wanted to get you to respond.

So then w/ like an hour left in the day Krafla makes one of the scummier posts I've seen. After having his vote on raven for a while, he decides to listen to a raging Rainbows (who I'm already reading as scum @ this point) and change his vote to NW stating that if he flips town, he'll know who the scum team is.

So then I switched to Raven @ the end of the day because thats where two votes were and I was pretty sure NW was town @ that point. I knew it was unlikely to do anything since it only tied it, but maybe someone would switch or maybe you'd show up last minute. Like I said, it was unlikely to help, but there was literally no reason not to switch @ that point.

So maybe me switching my vote around around a bunch wasn't that great in hindsight. But it all made sense @ the time.

And no matter what happened. Nothing makes Rainbows cop claim look legit whatsoever. Like I get that this is a noob game, but a cop investigating to confirm his town read is the dumbest thing imaginable.

Virtu, say I'm a bad townie all you want. But you're saying that you believe a cop would actually investigate to confirm town. How can you even consider that to be true?

On March 29 2013 23:50 TheRavensName wrote:

Because your play style has worked out so well so far... Lets Tunnel Raven and let some myslynches happen while I push another myslynch cause I don't think you should scum hunt more then one person at a time!

On March 29 2013 23:58 raynpelikoneet wrote:

I can't lynch more than one scum in a day and you have been obv-scum from the beginning. There is no reason for me to vote for anyone else. And saying i have not been fighting against the other lynches is just bullshit. I have been very clearly trying to lynch you from D1 because you are scum, and besides that i have trying to figure out who is another person who is mafia. I found that out today.

On March 30 2013 00:05 raynpelikoneet wrote:
You just called me town. :D