Newbie Mafia XXXIX - Page 17

On March 27 2013 02:46 Rainbows wrote:
Ray has fair potential to be scum. He's tunneled my town read (or at least, not an entirely scummy guy) the entire game.

His aggressive posting style i like but it seems that hes heading in the opposite direction i am with it.

If virtu doesnt post or just pulls a krafla i will vote him in seconds. I'll be more than happy to take full credit for lynching that dude.

It seems like people this game hate taking stances... Who the heck are you guys' biggest scumreads, with, you know, good reasons?

On March 27 2013 03:11 Krafla wrote:


Right OK here's what I think, we've got two scum in nw and TRN. They've both voting for each other to cover and spread their votes. If there's another scum in the game I believe it's between virtu and JarJar. Here are my reads.


Rainbows - I think you're town, but I think you're wrong to defend TRN.

ray - I think you're town, you started off aggressive but you've calmed down and you seem to have the town's best interest at heart.

JarJar - I'm on the fence with JarJar. You seem about as clueless as me when it comes to trying to make a reasonable read on anyone.

nw - I don't like the fact he got away without voting in D1, where I put myself in a compromising position to avoid not voting.

virtu - Same goes for virtu as nw however we've got the roleblock claim which no-one has commented on. I believe his claim partially because no one else claimed an RB. What is there in it for him to fake claim an RB. He wasn't the killer because we had a kill. Where does this leave us. His lack of posting is not helping us at all.

Right, I'm going to go drive home so I'll be away for an hour or so...


Oh I almost forgot TRN!! If you're town do me a favour and tell me who you cop checked on the first day and I'll move my vote off you.

On March 27 2013 02:45 JarJarDrinks wrote:
I can't really decide between the 2 vote leaders (NW and TRN). I'm gonna reread the thread again and see if I can pick anything new up.

On March 27 2013 03:23 TheRavensName wrote:

Wait... my defense as town is to fake a blue claim? You better lynch me now then, I am not that stupid. Your either the cop and are trying to bait me into fake claiming so you can call me on it sense out of 9 people there is no way I can be the cop, or your trying to find out if I am cop, lynch someone else and then make me useless the rest of the game.

On the side note: Why would me and NW keep this voting thing up if we were both mafia? We have been both set to be lynched today, and could have swapped to virtu to make it so he would by lynched over us right now. I think the fact that jarjar changed so quickly to someone that it is extremly unlikely to get enough votes (No one is going to swap off me for Virtu as long as I am the confirmed lynch, especially assuming at least two of them are mafia, and the only person who can break the tie to save me is Virtu himself.) should be viewed as suspicious. I am willing to bet NW and Jarjar are both mafia, and this is Jar jar's way of causing a myslynch and saving NW.

On March 27 2013 03:24 TheRavensName wrote:

If you couldn't decide why would you have voted for NW, and why didn't you do that before you swapped toVirtu?

On March 27 2013 03:33 JarJarDrinks wrote:
I made my case on NW. Ray then pointed out a flaw in it which I acknowledged. So while it doesn't negate my whole case against him, he's probably not my top suspect anymore.

On March 27 2013 03:36 TheRavensName wrote:

You also said you didn't think Virtu was scum either so.... Again this brings the question of why Virtu to the table.

Wait... my defense as town is to fake a blue claim? You better lynch me now then, I am not that stupid. Your either the cop and are trying to bait me into fake claiming so you can call me on it sense out of 9 people there is no way I can be the cop, or your trying to find out if I am cop, lynch someone else and then make me useless the rest of the game.

On March 22 2013 12:16 TheRavensName wrote:
Hello guys... I'm going to use my opening post to say One thing and one thing only:


I haven't read any of the books after Chamber of Secrets or Watched a movie sense Goblet of fire. Am I going to have to wikipedia Dumbledores Army to get most the flavor text?

On March 27 2013 04:24 Krafla wrote:


Ooh I'm glad you said this! So you're definitely not a cop then. Excellent. Please explain your first post;




I believe this is a scum slip right from the start. You throw down a fake blue breadcrumb, that you're a 1shot watcher, to give you something to come back to later in the game. But hang on a minute, this game doesn't have any 1-shot roles. Whoops, guess I can't carry on this charade, lets hope no one spots it.

On March 27 2013 04:27 Rainbows wrote:
Krafla.. What is this i dont even....

And people wonder why i dont like raven cases.

On March 27 2013 04:44 Rainbows wrote:
Honestly Raven, i have no fucking clue. A town being this stupid is probably more likely than scum flailing his arms around trying to influence the lynch.

Like, its just so.... Bad....