This Town Ain't Big Enough Mafia
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
clearly not shying away from the spotlight. thats the only thing useful from the last page and a half | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 07:02 yamato77 wrote: The last thing town needs is a bunch of people yelling at each other to duel someone else. But whatever, do what you want. I'm only going to duel someone if things go bad, which I think they will. If they go your way, good, but I doubt it. Town is rarely that cooperative. meh you just haven't experienced many good towns im gonna guess mafia will be under pressure from this setup im gonna guess since time is on our side. And looking at the player list some of the better players will likely be town so we will be able to sweat the mafia i would say | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 09:08 Acrofales wrote: I disagree with Iamp. I have no clue about yamato's meta, but being incredibly dumb about a pro-town policy without proposing a viable, useful, alternative is not a town trait. Yamato's participation in the thread so far has been to try to disrupt Marv's policy. That is not in town's best interest and the whole policy discussion so far has been all the dumber for it. @Marv: why do you feel Cora is scummy for opposing your policy, yet have said nothing about Yamato? just because someone is acting dumb dosen't mean they are scum. Yamato has shown an interest in the game doesn't care that he is making a spectacle of himself has shown aggression those good sir are town traits | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 03:06 Snarfs wrote: Ahhh yesss!! Finally a game where I'm not mafia! It's been too long. Far too long. Obvious rule number 1: no one calls for a duel unless we have a majority of the thread agreeing on it. Obvious rule number 2: we use as much of the day as possible before calling for duels. Anyone ignoring rules 1 or 2 should be put under extreme scrutiny for acting against town goals. this guy is the scummiest guy in the game so far in my view says he is excited he is town then proceeds to do nothing discuss. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 10:07 Sylencia wrote: Not mafia != town, could be third party as far as we know. ya lets speculate on that for no reason. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 10:07 marvellosity wrote: Snarfs is not scummier than thrawn after that abomination of a post. Dunno what you're smoking, iamp he attacked me means he is probably town since i hadn't mentioned him at all. scum thrawn should no better than to attack me | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 10:13 marvellosity wrote: worst reasoning ever, iamp. your posts so far have all been useless, so you're an easy target to attack right now. dont know what your talking about i will be figuring out everyones alignment one by one if you want to help me your welcome or we could spend another couple pages wasting time talking about the setup. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 10:29 cDgCorazon wrote: Right now, I would kill Yamato because he looks like he is going to go rogue the whole game and not listen to us at all. He's also expecting me to have scum reads 6-7 pages into the game and expecting every post I make to be an attack on someone. He changed the subject to put the focus on my lack of scum reads this early in the game (sheeping on your notion earlier that I was being wishy-washy, it's an unoriginal argument which is really scummy seeing as there's been so little discussion). Basically, he wants the thread to be like the "Reign of Terror" from the French Revolution. I'm pretty sure that is not necessary for us to catch the scum. A close second is Adam who has displayed the same desire to go rogue but hasn't been as abrasive. what a terrible answer we want to lynch scum not people who want to go rouge | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 10:31 cDgCorazon wrote: Don't pressure me into making an answer that you want. I can think for myself, thank you very much. Snarfs' first post a bit scummier than Dinoman's is. Do you expect everyone to be 100% convinced about the scum team this early on in the game as well? dont really care what you think just want to figure out your alignment. and hint hint all reads subject to change deal with it | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 10:33 cDgCorazon wrote: Did you read anything besides the first line of my answer? i did actually yamotas aggressiveness is a town tell i will defend him for the rest of the game probally unless there is drastic change in his play | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 11:03 Hapahauli wrote: @ Yamato + Cora Can you both take a breather and calmly explain who your scumreads are and why? Both of you are at the throat of every person who accuses you, and I can't keep track of it for the life of me. hey you ive been looking at you. you haven't said a god damn thing yet (you can check your filter its all policy and useless stuff) you have just kind of been here with your pretty looking posts and your playing peace keeper why you not putting anything original in the thread you scum dog? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 11:22 Hapahauli wrote: I can finally get to work since players not named Marv, Yamato, or Corazon are finally starting to post. As for you, what the hell have you done that's useful? I see a lot of random name-dropping and not much of substance. You've championed "Yamato is Town, I will defend him 'till the end," yet everything else in your filter is completely unexplained and or nonsensical. Case in point: did you find dino and snarfs entry to be town entrances?????????????? as for the thrawn thing we have history bro and i dont think he is stupid. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
the rude thing is not a tell. i have read a lot of marv discussion over | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 11:22 Hapahauli wrote: I can finally get to work since players not named Marv, Yamato, or Corazon are finally starting to post. As for you, what the hell have you done that's useful? I see a lot of random name-dropping and not much of substance. You've championed "Yamato is Town, I will defend him 'till the end," yet everything else in your filter is completely unexplained and or nonsensical. Case in point: also you still haven't said anything. except fling a little dirt on me got to have a little something by now no? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 11:30 Hapahauli wrote: How the fuck are those first-posts allignment indicative? Thrawn read still makes zero sense given that he gave you a scumread when you'd made like 2 inconsequential posts in several hours. yo bro you can question my logic all you want. im just telling you what i think i caught thrawn in our last game together. he attacked me after lurking i dont think as scum he would be stupid enough to go after me again. but if this is all your going to be doing hapa your scum in my eyes. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 11:34 cDgCorazon wrote: I know I should really shut up about Yamato but: Why are you guys getting on each other for having such early town reads and not get on Yamato for having such early scum reads? because it would be easy for mafia to just dump a bunch of town reads because they would be right. good way to look like your contributing | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 11:38 Hapahauli wrote: Naw man. This game is coming way too easily to you right now. Especially the bolded: not once have you explained why you think those posts (by Snarf and Dieno) are scummy. You just name-drop and move on. You're telling us plenty of what you think, but nothing about why you think so. Y u so scummy iamp? lol i have to explain why dino first post was scummy to you??? how about you go read it. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 11:41 Hapahauli wrote: Newbie player makes wishy-washy newbie post. Your turn. dino was so easy to read in chrono checkmate | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 11:46 Acrofales wrote: That's a complete misrepresentation of dino in that game and you know it. Dieno's claim to townhood was making a plan which was ridiculous and coming up with a crazy campaign for team leader. He also claimed in order to get included in the party. All-in-all, it was enough for a town read on a complete newbie. Dieno is no longer a complete newbie. Also, Dieno was mislynched in Parallel Universe for his wishy washy opening post and not delivering afterwards. If you're trying to say Dieno is scum for not living up to CT, you need to do better than that and read his other games as well. So far I have no clue about Dieno's alignment, but the meta you just plonked in here is completely wrong. not really everybody else needed that stuff i had him pegged as town after two posts. didnt read parallel | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 11:57 Hapahauli wrote: Missing the point. He was being an attention-whore in Chrono and posting wild pictures to be elected mayor (first few posts). That's a completely different situation from what we're in. do you have a point? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 12:03 Hapahauli wrote: False pretenses? That's just one of the several reasons I'm suspicious of him right now. I think he's scummy due to his his nonsensical Thrawn read, as well has him name-dropping Dieno. Also, this post in general is really scummy in context. Why on earth is he answering a question for Corazon? In fact his posts right after that suggests that he's suspicious of Cora at point: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=398360¤tpage=12#221 http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=398360¤tpage=12#222 The thought-process makes no sense. He's suspicious of Cora, yet he's willing to answer questions for him? Nope. for someone that has played a ton of games with me it seems like you are puzzled by my actions. dont get it hapa and this is still the only thing you are doing is commenting on me. If this is what you plan on doing all cycle i think you have to be scum. your tunneling of me for no reason other than you dont like some of my reads. explain how any of my actions are scummy am i afraid of the spotlight? am i interested in lynching scum? you havent done any of that and wont comment on anything else despite saying you have more material. maybe your just bad at scum hapa | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 12:13 Hapahauli wrote: I'll admit you're getting better with the "spotlight" and "activity" thing. Though answer what I posted above: why were you answering questions for Corazon? because i felt like it. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
implying he wasn't lazy and actually bothered to go look up my past games. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 12:33 Dienosore wrote: @marv: I've already mentioned that I trust you. If you sincerely believe that he isn't scum, then I will reconsider my hard stance. However, I would be a fool to not remain extremely suspicious until something happens that definitively clears up the situation. @Hapa: He didn't just make a post about me. He called me out for a duel with his first post based on my first post. To me, this screams scum. why would you think someone being super aggressive is scummy should mean the opposite no? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 12:35 Acrofales wrote: But he's had that attitude all game. Thrawn thought he was scum for it, you think he's town for it. I have no clue, I'd say he's playing pretty similar to the start of CT, where he was town, but I thought he could be scum. He is aggressive and doesn't give a shit. However, the reasons I doubt him are still the same: he gives no reasons, isn't forceful about his reads and has this post: This post is pointless, but a suspicious mind might think why even bother bringing it up? How does Iamp know that good players are likely town, rather than scum? because im town seriously though extremely unlikely every good player is mafia come on man | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 13:11 Dienosore wrote: Good to hear that you are willing to disarm, even if ever so slightly. Unfortunately, I am not the best scum hunter. I rely on my maps a lot, as you probably know, which usually require days of information and copious cross referencing before the incriminating connections really stand out. I'll try to whip up something before I go to bed tonight, though. oh god i love the map but ill have to wait until morning. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 22:42 marvellosity wrote: ya I agree on both points. The interesting/funny/odd thing is this - in Mario Mafia, Hapa was scum, iamp was town, and Hapa accused iamp of being scum. I pretty much hard-defended iamp, and in any case the end result of the episode was this: In other words, it's a very similar mirror. It's actually quite bemusing because it seems almost ludicrous that a scum-Hapa would fall into exactly the same trap again, and yet as you note, iamp's playstyle didn't really change. Like, I can easily grab a couple of quotes from the first page of iamp's filter with the same attitude as Hapa claimed made him change his read. i too was experiencing deja vu all over again. Hapa still ,despite saying he has material, has not added anything original to the thread. I think he has good chance of flipping scum. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 05:54 Keirathi wrote: Hola gents. Fear the 10 paces, filthy scum. where you at? dont make me start organizing my search parties | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 23:32 Oatsmaster wrote: So if I agree that hapa is scummy, what does that mean about my reads on you and Acro? And If I think that hapa is town, what does it mean about my reads on you and Acro? i think your overall attitude says more about your alignment than your individual reads. It seems to me you are super suspicious of a lot of people which is a townie trait in my eyes | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 23:56 Oatsmaster wrote: Its called keeping them to yourself :D who is scum Iamp? hapa and snarfs are the two strongest right now good chance there is scum in the lurkers as well dino looks a bit better still wary of him though. Seems like he is more interested in the game though. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 00:27 cDgCorazon wrote: Well why can Yamato get away with stuff but Iamp can't? You have to admit that it's a little unfair. It's not being consistent. Why is it when you attack Iamp for making town reads and not attack Yamato for the same thing? If you think it's a scummy action, it's at least slightly scummy everytime someone does it. It's not scummy when Iamp does it and not when Yamato does it. It can be scummier due to metas, but you can't let Yamato get off scot free with it. That's why I'm going to re-read the thread and see if I can sort all of these attacks out. even if he was attacking who cares if he is being fair. you treat different players differently. also life isn't fair | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 25 2013 23:48 marvellosity wrote: there's 5 players by my count who haven't really started playing the game yet. It's an unfortunately high percentage. snarfs/kei/sylencia/alderan/zare never seen kier not play before alderan has done this this before he was scum you actually replaced him. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 02:54 Acrofales wrote: Regarding Thrawn: Iamp has a meta town read on him. Iamp, mind elaborating on that read? He doesn't post as scum | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 02:57 Acrofales wrote: Dieno posted the map, do you still think he's scum? you reading the thread? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
i commented on dino | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 03:02 Acrofales wrote: You offhandedly mentioned "he looked a bit better". I was expecting more after you specifically made a comment that you were excited to see his map. Do you think he could fake the map as scum? excited because it entertains me not that i think it would be a secret to figuring out his alignment. If he is town he will continue to be enthusiastic about the game and trying to catch scum. as for the fake thing im sure he could. he seem like wily guy. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
you should know the only way to prove your town if you are in fact town......... | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 06:07 zarepath wrote: I'm going to be mostly AFK for the rest of the Night so here are some reads/suspicions for the moment. Hapa The very first thing he does is claim town, which I really dislike. Proposes a policy. Suggests that all Cora wants to do is call Sylencia a dick... stoking the flames The 180 on iamp with not a lot of justification In the end he makes a fairly good defense (last post in his filter). The iamp 180 does look awful, but I can see the reasoning behind it. Oats Super spastic. Tons of questions. The other game I've played with Oats, this is how he played Day 1 in order to get information/discussion flowing. I am pretty sure that is his tactic now. But if literally zero cases or reads come out of it, his behavior is going to look scummy in retrospect. Keirathi Somebody else who soft-claimed town immediately, a thing I hate. Supposedly caught up with the thread but hasn't made his presence known in any substantial way. He needs to have opinions or something. Dienosore I feel like he is the stuffed animal of this game of mafia. He is cute and friendly and makes sweet pictures and hard to hate, but when night strikes he turns into an Agent of Evil and creepily plots our demise. Okay, so not really. His picture is potentially helpful/useful, and I like his tone, but he has really gone out of his way to talk about how friendly he is, which strikes me a little bit of Stranger In An Unmarked Van syndrome. He opts to be the nice welcoming guy to Cora when everyone else is finding excuses to hate him, and it just makes my heart swell. Then in his defense of his defense of Cora, he mentions multiple times how friendly he is. Why is he so concerned with looking friendly? Town doesn't need to worry how they look, just what they accomplish. Note that he also went out of his way to express how he is NOT good at catching scum. Why would town advertise that? Don't they want their arguments to hold sway? I want to see more of his conclusions from his mapping; undoubtedly several occur to him while he does the research. Adam What does Adam think about people not named Dienosore? Hard to tell. Snarfs Unless Snarfs has been mafia a million times in a row, his first line was a super annoying soft-town-claim that is not justified, in my opinion. Now that he's caught up I wonder what his other thoughts are. Sylencia I mentioned this earlier, but Sylencia looks the scummiest right now of all of the players. Others have contributed less/none, but the few things Sylencia has popped in to post fall easily under the Scum Motivated category. He has more work to do to stop looking scummy than anybody else. Just check his filter and the case makes itself. iamperfection His player list comment (assuming town will have the good players for some reason) sounds awful but when looked at, I can understand how it's simply just saying that there are so many good players we're bound to have at least one as town. His logic fails to account for the fact that mafia will also have good players, so it's not like town will now have it easy . He calls someone town REALLY early in the game, which something you can usually only do with confidence when you are scum. He calls Snarfs scummy also very early in the game, then tells other people to discuss it. I think this is kind of null, but worth bringing up because it was a unique read. He goes out of his way to answer for corazon, tell him who is scum. I don't know that I can see scum acting this... forwardly. He is unforgiving in his opinions and doesn't really bend at all to town, and he just has this weird vibe. I get a sense of unique thoughts coming from this man. He gives a bunch of town reads, which is apparently something he just does. This man is a Wild Card. I think I like him. (And I can also understand how someone would be certain that he's scum and then suddenly decide he's no longer scum.) this post is scummy as fuck at the top he says these are reads and suspicions but they aren't. 1. all he does is sum up what people did with no real conclusions 2. wishy washy as fuck( sums up several players actions..ie me hapa dino kier) but then has no conclusion on those players alignments one way or the other. This is scummy because hit is a good way to look like your contributing when you are in fact not 3. says stuff that doesn't make sense. ie hapa's 180 looks awful but he can see the reasoning behind it..... (then it is not awful) | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 07:55 iamperfection wrote: this post is scummy as fuck at the top he says these are reads and suspicions but they aren't. 1. all he does is sum up what people did with no real conclusions 2. wishy washy as fuck( sums up several players actions..ie me hapa dino kier) but then has no conclusion on those players alignments one way or the other. This is scummy because hit is a good way to look like your contributing when you are in fact not 3. says stuff that doesn't make sense. ie hapa's 180 looks awful but he can see the reasoning behind it..... (then it is not awful) anybody agree with me here? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 07:59 marvellosity wrote: zarepath - I like what he's done since he's been here. Picking up on good things, effort blabla. you like that last big post.............? wat | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 08:06 Hapahauli wrote: Oh waht the fuck goddamnit I thought hte deadline was at 7 i thought it was 8 | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 08:06 cDgCorazon wrote: After reading Zare's post again, I do think you have a point. I also think this post is full of ideas that have been said already. It really just looks like an unfocused list of his reads based on what others have said. If I may be so bold Iamp, would you like to reciprocate and give me some feedback on my suspicion towards Oats? + Show Spoiler + On February 26 2013 06:17 cDgCorazon wrote: A few other things I would like to point out: Oats' play so far has been a bit shaky for me. I already pointed out the fact that he is being inconsistent towards Iamp and other players, but he hasn't made any clear effort to scumhunt. Most of his filter has been directing discussion and debates with others, but he hasn't brought in any clear direction with his posts. He has made several hints to him thinking players are scummy: The points where he has shown doubt and suspicion on another player (and not their arguments) have been thrown out there, but he hasn't put anything behind them. The one time where he expanded on one of these points: Acro's response basically explains how I feel about this: The moment after Oats makes this illogical statement, he tries to get everyone to not think about it: And when he gets challenged on the point, he tries to throw the discussion elsewhere: He's trying to dodge the fact that he made an illogical argument. To me, that is a strong scum tell. He refuses to elaborate on why Marv playing like his town meta makes him scummy because he knows it is a bad argument. Why would scum try to avoid this? They need to make up arguments that are not true so that the town will not vote them off. Why would he make this silly argument in the first place if he wasn't scum? Why would he not own up to his mistake and take the blame for a bad argument and instead try to sidestep it? These are the questions I would love to see Oats answer. oats hasnt bugged me at all i think he is town | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
Hapahauli- scummy just a bunh of policy stuff. thought question to marv about cor was wierd. complains about stuff hasnt given any real reads. just questioning my logic not doing anything else tunnels me like crazy and wont comment on anything else. backs off just like in mario mini. so much defense no scum huinting Acrofales-meh opening. disagreed with me whatever. more meh just challenging logic not hunting scum. looked up my past games slight town meh made a bunch of reads that some i agree with seems alright null closer to town now Oatsmaster- like his tone seems aggresive not afraid of anybody it seems Alderan- who is he? Keirathi-scummy made a useless post and ran away. still hasnt done shit thrawn2112- attacked me. he aint stupid town Dienosore worst opening post i have ever seen. so wishy washy and useless more recent posts seem ok more agression looks more intrested in the game leaning town now zarepath- scummy as fuck. made a huge list posst that was scummy as fuck didnt explain what was scummy just sumed up shit Adam4167- i dont know. seems somewhat active though marvellosity- seems confident maybe town not shying away at all seems intrested. confused by yamtos actions somewhat town tell possibly trying to figure out yamato. called out cdg not afraid of calling out early. seems intrested in whats going on. somewhat confusing that he likes zarepth Snarfs-scummy- excited that he rolled town.... but didnt do shit. cDgCorazon-meh - came back with useless post pointing out diffrence but didnt say anything of alignment. wouldnt answer when asked for alignments.shits up the thread with useless crap with syl had a post where he said the vets where stupid and using meta wrong means he is probally town Sylencia-meh slightly scummy- threw shit on cdg but said nothing of his alignment. shits up the thread with useless crap with cdg slight agresive tone though maybe town look closely iamperfection-Innocent child yamato77- town- not afriad of spot light | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 08:11 cDgCorazon wrote: So do you feel like my points are not scum tells? Or that they are not strong enough to sway you from your current read of Oats? im not a big scum slip guy i look more into mindset and contribution. do they care about the lynch are they trying to figure shit out to me it looks like oats is trying to figure shit out | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
Keir had time to pop in and say "hai gaiz, I'm town", then bugger off for 15 hours, say he was reading the thread, and ask a pointless question. The only motivation I can see for this behaviour is to say "dudes, I'm in the game and doing stuff", which is behaviour I associate with scums.[/QUOTE] I agree with this post. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
do zare vs snarf or zare vs kier i would like to give hapa some more time. Is there anyone that is with me? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 10:22 Acrofales wrote: Tell me again why Thrawn is town. His calling you out is not enough given the rest of his play. I have played town with him once and he played well. I read 2 other of his town games and they were also fine. This is not his townplay. i just dont think he is stupid. call it gut or whatever but his last scum games he did not post at all like we are talking 4 or 5 posts. is it possible he is scum yeah but i think there are better candidates and my gut says he is town. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 11:01 Keirathi wrote: No solid reads yet. I'm interested in thrawn, obviously. The town thrawn I know is logical and takes his time to look at all sides of the situation, and I just haven't seen that from him this game. He's just been flying by the seat of his pants (iamp scum, no town, no scum again! Hapa should be a dueler tomorrow!) with little to no reasoning for his "reads". how the fuck can you not have a solid read yet.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... i just gave you my longest period silence ever becasue frankly keir if you dont have a solid read you must not be reading the thread which makes me think your scum. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 26 2013 11:18 Keirathi wrote: I honestly haven't put a whole lot of effort into the game at this point because I've just been busy. I'm not going to force reads I don't believe in though, nor am I going to apologize for that. You act like this is something new, though. In fact, iirc, this isn't even the first time you've made that statement about me on day 1 ("OMG you must be scum if you aren't sure about reads 24 hours into the game!"). Sorry, I'll work at my own pace and have reads when I have them. how about instead of pissing and moaning you do something. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 00:09 The Macho Man wrote: Why would adam as scum initiate a duel? seem to me he was far from being the most likely to be called out. for my filter | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
hrmm can kill adam for being stupid can kill kier for being useless must ponder that. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
We need to lynch scum and for those saying killing both isnt taking a stance it is. It means i can see arguments for either one being scum. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 00:59 Alderan wrote: Taking a stance?... wat.... Hey town, how about we not take a stance on things like double lynching townies. Neither of those are good enough reasons to lynch. So again, let's NOT "take a stand". you know something i dont? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 01:09 Alderan wrote: I know that one being stupid and one being useless is not reason enough to lynch both. If I see some significant scum evidence on BOTH then I would advocate a double lynch, but because it's fairly certain they are not both scum then what you are proposing is essentially a random lynch. i dont know what your expecting some sort of smoking gun evidence that so and so is mafia it isnt gonna happen This is an educated guessing game after all. Kier doesn't care about this game. He is not interested in finding scum Adam did something stuipd that acro points out should be punished. both can be mafia | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 04:05 Alderan wrote: Got off on a rant the first time I answered this question and accidentally closed the tab. Do you really need to explain to you why lynching twice on the first day is less effective than lynching once? yes | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 07:42 thrawn2112 wrote: so we have two people up for lynch. we have to lynch at least one of them. 1) both scum. this is dumb but if it's true then it's not a possibility worth worrying about. win-win 2) both town. if this is the case then we are fucked either way. lose-lose 3) one town, the other scum. win-lose Option 3 is the only option worth worrying about. If 1 is true, it's a win-win and if 2 is true we're in a lose-lose. So there's not much use in considering either option as a real possibility. 1/2 might be true but in either case there's nothing we can do about it. So now we are in a position where it makes sense that for the rest of the cycle, we might as well at least assume that only one of them is likely to be scum. Don't place your votes based on which option you think is the lesser of two evil, I want reasons for why the person you're voting for has a higher chance to flip scum than the other. Which explanation makes more sense: A townie haves an emotional omgus reaction and duels his accuser or a mafia player making a similar omgus styled play? Then you have to look at each of their filters. Even if you like keir's point about adam's possible self-promotion, you cannot ignore that it's all keir has talked about. He's said a few things about how I wasn't playing up to my town meta, and lately he's said that I've been hopping around on thread sentiment. These points are lazy and anyone could make them. And those 2 'reads' are keir's entire contribution to the game thus far. I am having a hard time believing that out of all the things that have happened in the thread, an early meta read on me and the tunneling of a single point about adam is all he would be able to come up and be suspicious of if he were town. i change my mind about thrawn what a useless post. your scum aren't you? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 11:57 thrawn2112 wrote: that dienosore is hella scummy for not being suspicious of obviously scummy keir. keir's actual alignment probably doesn't even factor into it. town dienosore should not be looking at someone who hardcore lurked and only introduced 1 unique point to the thread and seeing them as not scummy. i approve of this post. i change my mind again on thrawn. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 12:02 The Macho Man wrote: because he isn't doing anything and it doesn't look like he cares about the game..... | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
i am | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
We get to know kier's and we get to know adam's alignment how much more information could you want!!!! | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 13:01 Adam4167 wrote: By that logic iam, you should want to kill everyone, to generate the most 'information'. what do you care your super scum kier dies with you no? Some times we have to make sacrifices for the town.... unless your survival is super important to you adam...................................... | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 13:05 Adam4167 wrote: Survival is important to every alignment, so that's irrelevant. you would think the guy that was so sure that someone was scum that he stifiled all conversation to be hero would be willing to be the Jesus Christ that we need | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 16:44 yamato77 wrote: So let me break the game down here, because I have a decent idea of what's going on. Based on the complete uselessness of both parties involved in this lynch, Adam and Keirathi, I think the likelihood of them both being town is high. Mafia in this position would be more concerned with the possibility of being lynched here, and do something about it. Neither of these players seems to be trying particularly hard to live, so by default they're probably just town. It's unfortunate that one, or perhaps both, might die in this situation, but if I had to pick one, I would pick Adam. Keirathi, I think, is the better town among the two, and could potentially be valuable to us later on if left alive. That said, at this point, it doesn't matter too much to me which one lives, because I don't think either of them is particularly useful this game. THAT said, I don't want both to die. The mere thought of a double lynch is hilariously stupid in this situation, and I don't like the idea of not choosing either of them at all. Mafia have an unprecedented ability to hide in this situation, because they don't even have to FAKE a read on a player and justify it, they can just say they think they're both worth lynching and not vote, causing a double lynch. So who is doing this? Iamperfection. I initially thought he was fairly townie, but his interest in this lynch is tremendously low. Like, I don't think he's given a read on either of these people that was longer than a sentence or deeper than "He's mafia because XX and I said so." In fact, that's basically how all of his reads have been so far, town or scum. But what is really damning, to me, is the fact that he's pushing this double lynch thing with no good logic to back it up. Acro, I can believe. Iamp is just kinda on that wagon and has pushed it without a clear motive like Acro's. If these two really are townies, like I think, then mafia is more likely to be disinterested in picking sides, and has clear motivation to want them both dead. It's the same heuristic I used to catch on to Snarfs in Nomination; mafia players don't care which townie dies, and won't spend much effort picking one. Only iamp isn't even picking one. Hilariously scummy. lol herp derp two guys not contributing........ therefore they must be town. what game you playing? adam dumped some reads after this post so at least he seems like he cares. How anyone can think kier is town at this point mind boggling. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
I think the mafia team has probably gotten together at this point and know they cant touch me. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 23:33 Oatsmaster wrote: Lol Iamp when is the last time you got mislynched? also double lynch? :D i have never been mislynched and never will | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 27 2013 16:05 Dienosore wrote: Wait, hold on... Did I read this right? Quoting this for preservation purposes. this kid is mafia by the way. quoting for preservation purposes you kidding me......... would scum oats say something like this guy is town but fuck him kill him anyways. probably not. this post looks like scum just finding something controversial and not doing anything with it. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 01:44 Acrofales wrote: Oh, dafuq. What is it with you people and your lack of reading comprehension Adam is an evil 3P who cares jack shit about the wellbeing of this town Keirathi is evil scum who needs to die Both must die. I will duel the next person who asks for my reads on adam and keir, because I hereby declare a policy lynch on people not reading the thread. This post has the iamperfection seal of approval. stop being scared little girls and lets put some heads on stakes. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 01:48 Oatsmaster wrote: Iamp, why is adam a 3p? I see know way kier can be town and acro is completely right about adams actions. They where so stupid and adam knows it the 3p argument makes a lot of sense. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 01:58 zarepath wrote: People don't play with labels on their heads reading "SCUM" or "TOWN," and they do not always play optimally or ideally, especially in weird formats like this one. I don't think you can declare someone 3P just because they don't play exactly according to your definition of what an ideal town or scum would do. adam isnt stupid he can make a lot of sense when he wants to. 3p fits his actions a lot. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 02:21 Oatsmaster wrote: Actually thrawn you too, why did Adam basically claim 3P as Acro said instead of playing more like what a townie looks like? Your asking impossible questions. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 02:25 zarepath wrote: If you are so sure about Kier then vote for him. Doing anything else is a lack of conviction I think I will kill both thank you very much | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 02:27 Oatsmaster wrote: No, what adam did was basically saying, 'I voted for that dude cause I wanted a mislynch' He pretty much 'claimed' 3P right there. Except nobody does that. So what he is just stupid? I don't think Adam is dumb when I saw what Adam did I thought it was stupid and he is not | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 03:38 Alderan wrote: God this is setting up so perfectly for scum to push double lynch. They're able to do what Thrawn did and just switch at any time, or do what Dieno is doing and say,"welll..... I don't really know, nor do I plan on contributing so Im gonna put a vote on the one with the least and hope for the best." And they are in a win win situation. Two town deaths: "Oh well they played so bad, blame them, fucking noobs" One town, One scum: "SEE, SEE WE TOLD YOU, WE'RE ALL TOWN" I just don't see any evidence that someone can have as vanilla townie that suggest either are scum. Useless? Of course. Scum? I just don't see it. maybe if you have something you want to say you should just say it. who is the scum then? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 03:44 Alderan wrote: Why so defensive bro? We have plenty of time for that, I'm not giving anyone any fodder to take this thread off track. The issue at hand is selecting this lynch, and in my opinion making sure it doesn't go to a double. the issue always at hand is to catch scum. And you casually throwing suspicion with out backing it with any reasoning what so ever is scummy as fuck. You just said oh double lynch so good for scum( why how the fuck do you know) are me or/and acro scum for pushing this idea. why are we showing scum traits?? | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 04:20 yamato77 wrote: I've read the arguments, but you're so far into fantasy land with this that it makes zero sense. Adam's play makes plenty of sense from a town perspective, he's just not trying very hard to show it.. Wat | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 06:33 Alderan wrote: While this hurts your opinion of me, your premise is wrong. Didn't say it was double town, said I didn't feel good about either being scum (read: Null). Same thing | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
Its actually an I'm better than each every one of you quality | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
Guys Guys Guys I have a sick case for hapa On February 28 2013 02:52 Hapahauli wrote: I'll be back in an hour. Till then, someone needs to explain to me why we're so sure that Adam is a 3rd party that we're willing to lynch him solely on that basis. 'Cause I don't get it at all. He said he would be back in an hour and then he didn't You know what this means well do you? It means he does not care about town. hapa can die. He can be a leader and he isnt he could name the whole scum team as town by now he isnt hapa is Mafia | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 12:01 The Macho Man wrote: so you think hapa is town??????????????????????????????????????????????????? why dont you enlighten the rest of class | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 12:03 Oatsmaster wrote: Nah. Hey Iamp I also think hapa has been really fucking passive this game, However, was it a bus on Keirathi? His reasoning was suspect and I dont really know :/ Again, however, his posts leading up to the lynch where he blasted Acro for saying Adam was 3P were pretty townie. there is no way hapa could say kier wasn't scum regardless of alignment. He would be claiming scum if he didn't say kier was scum towards the end. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 12:09 Alderan wrote: I don't know... I think if you, iamp, and Thrawn flipped it would not surprise me if there was one scum. you know you keep saying that and you seem to keep on forgetting to put you know reasoning behind it. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 12:11 Acrofales wrote: That's the point, he said it at the start. well my definition of end for kier was since the cycle start. I had him as bold red. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 12:15 Adam4167 wrote: And if I take another scum with me, then Ill happily do it. you will not initiate a duel | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 12:24 Acrofales wrote: Are Australia and Romania the same thing? wat | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 12:23 Adam4167 wrote: If you want me to stop initialing duels then stop coming up with garbage like this for scum cases: Push legitimate cases. Then Ill agree with your duel choices. we are talking about Hapahauli. he can easily look town he is not at all. HE should be right here with us talking about the game he is not. THAT IS MAFIA MOTIVATED | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 12:29 Adam4167 wrote: No, that is called being unavailable. How the hell is not being here 24/7 mafia motivated? its calling having a life outside this forum. hapa is in the same time zone as me. Hapa knows that playing mafia is a commitment hapa knows proving your towniness is important hapa knows that activity and discussion are how you catch mafia He has shown no interest in those things top it off with his shit start that was all defense and no scum hunting and the simple explanation is that hapa is mafia. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On February 28 2013 12:45 The Macho Man wrote: i think dino can be scum as well hapa vs dino hapa i believe has a scum read on dino as well. Then we can double lynch god damn it | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On March 01 2013 01:20 The Macho Man wrote: i was completly ok with double lynch as well so i dont really see a problem we should only worry about acro at endgame imo. He has shown no scum traits he is active he cares about the lynch that is not scummy and there is no way he should be the candidate tomorrow. | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On March 01 2013 01:31 yamato77 wrote: Tomorrow, at the crack of day, I am dueling Acro. It's him or me. Pick me first, I don't care, but if I die you lynch him after. no | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
syl and dino that who | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
Gl town | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On March 07 2013 01:01 HiroPro wrote: Snarfs had no KP and would have needed 6 mislynches to win. So tough task lol. so he didn't have kp that sucks for him | ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
| ||
iamperfection
United States9521 Posts
On March 07 2013 01:57 Keirathi wrote: Oh game is over. I just wanted to apologize to everyone for my (lack of) play. I just got super busy with a random job where i was working long ass days and not getting home until 7-8 pm and I was exhausted. It was so hard to try to catch up on 30-50 pages and try to come up with relevant thoughts I definitely had some ideas that I wanted to push, but I just didn't have time/energy to do it. GG everyone, sorry again. It didn't bother me | ||
| ||