|
God this is setting up so perfectly for scum to push double lynch. They're able to do what Thrawn did and just switch at any time, or do what Dieno is doing and say,"welll..... I don't really know, nor do I plan on contributing so Im gonna put a vote on the one with the least and hope for the best."
And they are in a win win situation.
Two town deaths: "Oh well they played so bad, blame them, fucking noobs" One town, One scum: "SEE, SEE WE TOLD YOU, WE'RE ALL TOWN"
I just don't see any evidence that someone can have as vanilla townie that suggest either are scum. Useless? Of course. Scum? I just don't see it.
|
On February 27 2013 12:55 cDgCorazon wrote:
I don't want to lynch both of them because if they both flip town, that would set the town back very much. The difference between a MYLO and a LYLO is huge, and I'd rather keep Kei around and see if he can turn his game around than let Adam run loose and do whatever he wants.
Corazone you said this prior to Adam's defense. Since then Adam has been active (ish) and providing some pretty good analysis. Acrofales is about to succesfully push a successful double lynch which you admitted would be a bad idea. Considering Keir has provided nothing since his nomination would you consider switching your vote?
If not why?
|
On February 28 2013 03:40 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2013 03:38 Alderan wrote: God this is setting up so perfectly for scum to push double lynch. They're able to do what Thrawn did and just switch at any time, or do what Dieno is doing and say,"welll..... I don't really know, nor do I plan on contributing so Im gonna put a vote on the one with the least and hope for the best."
And they are in a win win situation.
Two town deaths: "Oh well they played so bad, blame them, fucking noobs" One town, One scum: "SEE, SEE WE TOLD YOU, WE'RE ALL TOWN"
I just don't see any evidence that someone can have as vanilla townie that suggest either are scum. Useless? Of course. Scum? I just don't see it. maybe if you have something you want to say you should just say it. who is the scum then?
Why so defensive bro?
We have plenty of time for that, I'm not giving anyone any fodder to take this thread off track. The issue at hand is selecting this lynch, and in my opinion making sure it doesn't go to a double.
|
Sylencia similar question for you.
Do you agree a double lynch would be a bad idea? You never mention it in your filter, but you do seem to think that Adam's actions don't necessarily make him scum, just a bad town player.
Since the nomination do you think Adam is more dangerous to town than Keir?
If so, why?
|
On February 28 2013 03:48 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2013 03:44 Alderan wrote:On February 28 2013 03:40 iamperfection wrote:On February 28 2013 03:38 Alderan wrote: God this is setting up so perfectly for scum to push double lynch. They're able to do what Thrawn did and just switch at any time, or do what Dieno is doing and say,"welll..... I don't really know, nor do I plan on contributing so Im gonna put a vote on the one with the least and hope for the best."
And they are in a win win situation.
Two town deaths: "Oh well they played so bad, blame them, fucking noobs" One town, One scum: "SEE, SEE WE TOLD YOU, WE'RE ALL TOWN"
I just don't see any evidence that someone can have as vanilla townie that suggest either are scum. Useless? Of course. Scum? I just don't see it. maybe if you have something you want to say you should just say it. who is the scum then? Why so defensive bro? We have plenty of time for that, I'm not giving anyone any fodder to take this thread off track. The issue at hand is selecting this lynch, and in my opinion making sure it doesn't go to a double. the issue always at hand is to catch scum. And you casually throwing suspicion with out backing it with any reasoning what so ever is scummy as fuck. You just said oh double lynch so good for scum( why how the fuck do you know) are me or/and acro scum for pushing this idea. why are we showing scum traits??
Killing two people in one vote, particularly when its a vote like this and no one feels terribly strong that either should die, is extremely scummy. It's the first day for god's sake, killing 2 now favors scum incredibly.
|
On February 28 2013 03:58 Acrofales wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2013 03:51 Alderan wrote:On February 28 2013 03:48 iamperfection wrote:On February 28 2013 03:44 Alderan wrote:On February 28 2013 03:40 iamperfection wrote:On February 28 2013 03:38 Alderan wrote: God this is setting up so perfectly for scum to push double lynch. They're able to do what Thrawn did and just switch at any time, or do what Dieno is doing and say,"welll..... I don't really know, nor do I plan on contributing so Im gonna put a vote on the one with the least and hope for the best."
And they are in a win win situation.
Two town deaths: "Oh well they played so bad, blame them, fucking noobs" One town, One scum: "SEE, SEE WE TOLD YOU, WE'RE ALL TOWN"
I just don't see any evidence that someone can have as vanilla townie that suggest either are scum. Useless? Of course. Scum? I just don't see it. maybe if you have something you want to say you should just say it. who is the scum then? Why so defensive bro? We have plenty of time for that, I'm not giving anyone any fodder to take this thread off track. The issue at hand is selecting this lynch, and in my opinion making sure it doesn't go to a double. the issue always at hand is to catch scum. And you casually throwing suspicion with out backing it with any reasoning what so ever is scummy as fuck. You just said oh double lynch so good for scum( why how the fuck do you know) are me or/and acro scum for pushing this idea. why are we showing scum traits?? Killing two people in one vote, particularly when its a vote like this and no one feels terribly strong that either should die, is extremely scummy. It's the first day for god's sake, killing 2 now favors scum incredibly. You have some kind of knowledge you're not sharing with us?
? I don't follow?
Killing two players.... that no one feels that strongly about......on the first day.....
|
On February 28 2013 03:58 Acrofales wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2013 03:51 Alderan wrote:On February 28 2013 03:48 iamperfection wrote:On February 28 2013 03:44 Alderan wrote:On February 28 2013 03:40 iamperfection wrote:On February 28 2013 03:38 Alderan wrote: God this is setting up so perfectly for scum to push double lynch. They're able to do what Thrawn did and just switch at any time, or do what Dieno is doing and say,"welll..... I don't really know, nor do I plan on contributing so Im gonna put a vote on the one with the least and hope for the best."
And they are in a win win situation.
Two town deaths: "Oh well they played so bad, blame them, fucking noobs" One town, One scum: "SEE, SEE WE TOLD YOU, WE'RE ALL TOWN"
I just don't see any evidence that someone can have as vanilla townie that suggest either are scum. Useless? Of course. Scum? I just don't see it. maybe if you have something you want to say you should just say it. who is the scum then? Why so defensive bro? We have plenty of time for that, I'm not giving anyone any fodder to take this thread off track. The issue at hand is selecting this lynch, and in my opinion making sure it doesn't go to a double. the issue always at hand is to catch scum. And you casually throwing suspicion with out backing it with any reasoning what so ever is scummy as fuck. You just said oh double lynch so good for scum( why how the fuck do you know) are me or/and acro scum for pushing this idea. why are we showing scum traits?? Killing two people in one vote, particularly when its a vote like this and no one feels terribly strong that either should die, is extremely scummy. It's the first day for god's sake, killing 2 now favors scum incredibly. You have some kind of knowledge you're not sharing with us?
Oh..... you're blue baiting.... Nice. More solid town play from Acrofales
|
On February 28 2013 04:33 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2013 04:20 yamato77 wrote:On February 28 2013 04:17 Acrofales wrote: Hrmm, yamato, have you read the arguments? Or are you just opposed to a double lynch on general principle?
Do you have an updated opinion on Keirathi? How about Adam? Why are you voting for Adam? I've read the arguments, but you're so far into fantasy land with this that it makes zero sense. Adam's play makes plenty of sense from a town perspective, he's just not trying very hard to show it.. Wat
Frankly I'm sick of the iamp/Acro double lynch circle jerk. The only other person that supports it is Thrawn...
Great company that you guys keep.
|
Just waiting on Sylencia and Cora, they are our only hope right now.
|
On February 28 2013 04:40 thrawn2112 wrote: bro u wanna fight
Thrawn explain why you would prefer a double lynch.
|
On February 28 2013 04:14 Acrofales wrote: Alderan, have you played Mafia somewhere else since Game of Thrones? Your last game here, my first.
No I have not, and I fail to see the relevance.
|
On February 28 2013 05:11 cDgCorazon wrote: That was 7...unless I'm missing something?
If you switch its 7, switch on over.
|
Can't say I expected that, impressive call by Adam.
|
On February 28 2013 05:47 zarepath wrote: This is actually fantastic, because mafia would not want to vote for a double lynch OR Keirathi (especially when all votes were so close and they could easily justify going one way or another), which narrows down the suspicious votes quite a bit.
See I was thinking the exact opposite actually, and not only because I was one of the most vocal against the double lynch.
I think Kier was probably just as inactive with the scum as he was in this thread. As soon as they realized he got dueled and it was going to be close, their best option was to propose a double lynch, mitigate damage and appear pro town when it worked out.
It makes a lot of sense.
|
On February 28 2013 05:48 cDgCorazon wrote: I would love to see a Dieno vs Syl duel...seeing as they are the only ones who did not vote for Kei, and they are the two players who have been under the most suspicion...
I like this a lot.
|
On February 28 2013 05:50 Acrofales wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2013 05:47 Alderan wrote: Can't say I expected that, impressive call by Adam. How the hell was that Adam's call? All Adam did was follow the thread majority's opinion that Keir was scum and twitchy fingers ##duel him.
Was Kier really the majority opinion? I didn't think so but that was while I was reading through 20+ pages of the thread at one sitting.
|
On February 28 2013 06:30 iamperfection wrote: Acro you think alderan is town? I think it would be weird for him as scum to call it a double town lynch as scum like he did earlier
While this hurts your opinion of me, your premise is wrong.
Didn't say it was double town, said I didn't feel good about either being scum (read: Null).
|
Can someone please tell me why we're giving town reads during the night period?
|
On February 28 2013 06:36 Acrofales wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2013 06:34 Alderan wrote: Can someone please tell me why we're giving town reads during the night period?
I seriously doubt you're getting shot.
Not worried about me, big dog.
|
BTW Thrawn I like your list. A lot.
|
|
|
|