Themed Game Mafia - Page 32

On February 15 2013 01:19 Oatsmaster wrote:
##Unvote
##Vote: Hassybaby

This is a serious vote. Considering what happened with Hassybaby in Parallel where he was really active, this is disturbing.

On January 12 2013 01:53 marvellosity wrote:


I became incredibly suspicious of Djo right around where I ragequit. Witness the following posts:







All these questions/points are useless, and serve no direction. He's asking all the wrong questions.

On February 15 2013 01:42 Oatsmaster wrote:
Oh really keirathi? Guess I must of thought that with his huge picture and generally mod confirmed town after day 1, that he was more active.

Its still a problem. As austin has pointed out.

On February 15 2013 01:41 Keirathi wrote:
Speaking of which:

##Vote: Oatsmaster

This is the second time you've made a bullshit "read" with terrible reasoning. If you were town, you would be voting/giving town reads for real reasons, not something you just made up that sounded good.

Also, while I'm on the subject of Oats, a question for Marv:

(From the post-game of LVIII)


So why is it that when Oats does this same thing (asking irrelevent questions that serve no direction or purpose), you give Oats a town read?

If you were town, you would be voting/giving town reads for real reasons, not something you just made up that sounded good.

On February 15 2013 01:47 marvellosity wrote:


Hello, gentleman Keirathi. Simply enough, young Oats and Djodref are not the same gentleman.

On February 15 2013 01:52 marvellosity wrote:
Perhaps to elaborate a little for you, gentleman Keirathi. To me it is a sign of young Oats' good intent if he is willingly "making bullshit reads with terrible reasonining." As you are probably aware, sir, I was able to discern young Oats' bad intentions in the establishment named 'LIX', for the reasoning that he had no reads at all, 'bullshit' or otherwise.

Truly it can be argued that young Oats does not make arguments rigorously or perhaps even correctly; yet I have not seen the evil intentions that I have been able to discern before.

On February 15 2013 01:55 Oatsmaster wrote:

How about, NOPE?

You clearly agree with me on the BH read, so I dont know what your problem is there, even if I justified it with general reasoning rather than specific to BH.
Also, I was right on Hassybaby. He was more active and useful in Parallel than in here by a LARGE margin.

On February 15 2013 01:36 austinmcc wrote:
Maaaaaaaan, Keirathi beating people to comments again. I was trying to find a post of Hassy's in chaos to get a filter

I do remember Hassy being more active there, which isn't hard, but mainly remember him making some comments concerning current thread events that were in line with what I was thinking. Especially D1, there was a lot of spam about how we should vote to swap/lynch that game, and he made a few posts that just felt thought out concerning what he preferred.

Here, there's an absence of that entirely. You can summarize his posts in 2 bullet points basically, and one of those is just that he seems to have something concerning his role that he wants to discuss at an unknown time in the future.

On February 15 2013 02:07 austinmcc wrote:
I don't love saying Hassy was more active "by a large margin," but for reference: Hassy's filter from the world he started out in in Parallel mafia

At least within his D1, he's actively reading both threads. He discusses the general plan of who to swap where. He asks Foolishness, who was in the other thread, some questions concerning Foolishness's posts. When Darkfire posts his weird claim, Hassy questions Darkfire. When Dieno is being lynched (and after lynch), he's trying to draw conclusions from what was happening.

A lot of his activity was on that first day, and it somewhat tailed off afterwards. I would like to see hassy more active, but I don't currently want to vote him as #1.

On February 15 2013 02:12 austinmcc wrote:
ohai marv.

Hassy was an active participant in D1, see above. He felt less active during other day. D1 there also required a bit more planning, as we pretty much had to decide how to play that game on D1, whereas D1 here is just "okay instant majority."

If I take the setup posts out, there's still meat there. Questioning foolishness, questioning darkfire, generally keeping track of things. It's absent here. Gotta admit though, I haven't played with hassy much, and don't think I've played with scum hassy. That's one reason I don't want to lynch based purely on differences between Parallel and here...that's not really a sample size of his play that I can trust.

I'd rather be able to judge his posts and his decisions. If there isn't anything in that bucket to go off of, I'd be down to lynch him tomorrow I guess, but this is just a blind lynch at this point.

On February 15 2013 02:09 iamperfection wrote:

then who do you want to kill the most?