Normal Mini Mafia IV - Page 12

On February 04 2013 19:13 Promethelax wrote:


I've bolded the scummy things in this post to help you improve next time you roll scum.

On February 04 2013 20:11 Mocsta wrote:
As we know, this is your defense of Sharrant



Apparently you defended him because you got a cop check on him?

These are the subsequent posts in your filter: Ctrl+F "Sharrant"

Sounds to me, your having a dig @ Sharrant, even though hes meant to be confirmed town?


Again having a dig @ Sharrant, but apparently he is confirmed town? When are you proposing he is GF.. your not!

Then you have the case against Vivax
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=394344&currentpage=66#1310
Oddly enough, you decide to defend Sharrant here (even though you just been digging into him the past 2 posts)

Vivax points on you pretty much confirm you as scum anyways.

Key Points

• He is scum because of the DT claim? Yet you never mention yourself as DT to contest it.. What the? Isnt the way to oust a claim, by counter claiming; there is none of this?
  
• Then you accuse him of thinking GF about xsksc.. yet, when you got green on Sharrant, you still treat him like scum? When do you accuse him of being GF.. wait.. you dont
  
• Then there is the interplay with Thrawn.. most importantly.. you even admitted you voted on him purely as a pressure vote.
  
  On January 30 2013 21:42 JieXian wrote:
  Yes I did. What seems to be the problem? Heard of a pressure vote before?
  

JieXian, I hate to be so cocky, but I think you might as well concede as well. The evidence is not in your favour.

On February 05 2013 00:11 Vivax wrote:
The funny thing is that JX knows who the SK is, and he's asking for iamp lynch.

That's giving me thoughts atm. But JX, if he's indeed scum, could tell us anything and we wouldn't know if he favours town or the SK.

On February 04 2013 19:57 Mocsta wrote:
Seriously JieXian, your not doing yourself any favours.



& now


Quite a stark change in read.
How did this transition occur?

On February 04 2013 09:09 Mocsta wrote:
Now I haven't filter dived JX yet (at work, so will have to do it tonight); but, I had some problems with what he wrote.

Specifically if he was 1-shot cop that already used power, he is now a VT (a la Vivax); there is nothing to hide from claiming (esp. when requested by EZ) and later again by Djo.

Also

The phrasing of this is completely off. Town dont want a chance to test luck. They want to prove innocence.(e.g. look at my reaction when Djo trying to confirm me via setup speculation; "Thanks but no thanks"). This to me just stinks of scum.

So im sticking with JX being scum for this lynch.

If SK is present deal with it Day5.

##Vote: JieXian

On February 04 2013 07:58 JieXian wrote:
Secondly, were I mafia, nothing is stopping my from claiming VT right away. Djo and Mochsta look like they
may very well lynch iamp and I'd still have a chance if I were to test my luck with that, especially with
the possibility of there being an SK

I'm down to lynch in the following order : iamp > mochsta (if needed) > prome (if needed)

Now I'm back to sleep, go to work later.

On February 02 2013 19:06 Mocsta wrote:

---

On February 02 2013 17:24 JieXian wrote:
That was the most telling one. I can't find anything nearly as strong to argue for xsk or yamato. I mean they were basically not around at all

---

@JieXian
This is my interpretation of how the Thrawn lynch initiated (if you want to take iamp as the catalyst) - technically EZ voted first.

Do you think otherwise?
You were in the moment, I wasn't; perhaps it felt like he was a genuine catalyst as opposed to being cheeky; perhaps that why you were the first to join the vote.

If it was a light comment that then turned into a lynch:

• can you see reasons for iamp not to try and soak town cred?
  
  
• If Thrawn is useless scum as others have pointed out; can you see reasons for iamp to be "annoyed" at him?
  
  
• Do you think killing annoying townies = scum hunting? If so, why isnt Vivax lynched?

On February 05 2013 00:44 Mocsta wrote:


(1) Therein lies the problem. Who is scum to you JX? Your filter has a marked lack of actual scum hunting; you thrown iamp name in recently, based on what? He was your only confirmed town, and now you are recommending him for lynch? On what grounds?

Your good mate Toad, says, early game, dont discuss town reads. For mafia, they know the town reads and dont have to lie - its easy; its much harder for mafia to build a case against someone they know is town.

So yes, you didn't say Sharrant is scum; but you stood up for him, and then suggested you would be comfortable with his lynch due to his low page filter count. Thats not normal for a cop check.

(2) Counter claim has already been discussed in subequent posts (i.e. You are a VT, and can confirm a townie to prevent their mislynch, or mis-vig.... if you actually checked Sharrant and cleared him.. Prome coulda used the bullet on Yamato. Why did this situation NOT occur?

On February 02 2013 00:24 iamperfection wrote:

yeah

i don't trust your so called "plans"

On February 02 2013 01:35 iamperfection wrote:


green check probably less

out for a bit

On February 04 2013 07:58 JieXian wrote:
Secondly, were I mafia, nothing is stopping my from claiming VT right away. Djo and Mochsta look like they
may very well lynch iamp and I'd still have a chance if I were to test my luck with that, especially with
the possibility of there being an SK

I'm down to lynch in the following order : iamp > mochsta (if needed) > prome (if needed)

Now I'm back to sleep, go to work later.

On February 03 2013 14:47 Mocsta wrote:
hmm its very disconcerting JX has been as present as Yamato's defense.

Just when I was starting to feel better about him too.

On February 02 2013 19:31 Djodref wrote:
so yeah

GG y u no concede ?
The scum team is iamp and yamato, game over guys

On February 04 2013 07:58 JieXian wrote:
Secondly, were I mafia, nothing is stopping my from claiming VT right away. Djo and Mochsta look like they
may very well lynch iamp and I'd still have a chance if I were to test my luck with that, especially with
the possibility of there being an SK

I'm down to lynch in the following order : iamp > mochsta (if needed) > prome (if needed)

Now I'm back to sleep, go to work later.

On February 03 2013 14:47 Mocsta wrote:
hmm its very disconcerting JX has been as present as Yamato's defense.

Just when I was starting to feel better about him too.

On February 02 2013 19:31 Djodref wrote:
so yeah

GG y u no concede ?
The scum team is iamp and yamato, game over guys