TL Mafia LIX - Page 11

On January 25 2013 12:05 Adam4167 wrote:


Interesting welcome. I have read exactly none of this game, have I subbed into a train wreck?

You'll have to be patient while I catch up 120 pages.

On January 25 2013 12:19 DearestSnot wrote:
as for annul (sorry, I neglected to respond to that) I still am quite unsure how to read him, but I'm leaning town on him for an almost singular reason.

Basically when gonzaw was outted as a mason he took the time to ask if anyone had been masoned by gonzaw. I do not think that as scum in that position he would have done that. He had been afk for quite a while already up to that point, why bother trying to clear up the situation? He could have simply continued doing what he had already been doing.

Perhaps this is a minor point, and he really hasn't done anything else, but I somehow don't feel like annul is actually scum.

On January 25 2013 12:36 DearestSnot wrote:
Something interesting I noticed:




Why does grush call gonzaw townie, but vote Chezinu for mayor?

Both Chezinu and Axle swapped off onto gonzaw from Chez later, why did grush not do so?

the fact that he was given mason seems really weird, but perhaps it's one of those "is this too dumb to be scum?" kind of moments where thinking about it in that fashion really doesn't accomplish anything.

On January 25 2013 22:15 Toadesstern wrote:
palmar / marv. I'm 90% certain both BKE and Chez are mafia. If you had to choose, which one would you choose?

On January 24 2013 08:29 BroodKingEXE wrote:
Annul is obvscum, at the moment he isn't doing anything, but putting out weak scum reads and useless setup speculation. His posting style is that of a scum who knows he's in a bad spot. He says his D1 was non-existant, but I dont see a town directed change out of him.

##Vote: Annul

On January 24 2013 14:45 BroodKingEXE wrote:

Quite honestly I can understand why you think I am scum. The problem I am finding, in my readthrough of filters, I am feeling really disconnected with the thread, due to initial missing the onset of the game. If you have anything you want my opinion or read on you can ask me. I just aren't finding relevant topics for me to post on. Please ask away.

On January 25 2013 23:42 Vivax wrote:

→ By not stating clearly that he is going to 100 % jail BKE, Toad is creating problems for an eventual medic who has to pick someone to protect. He says he considers me as option for a jail, but tells the medics they should only protect Bugs. That is a contradiction in mindset. He should disregard me completely as a jail target in that case and rather be coinflipping between BKE and Bugs, right?

→ By not stating clearly that he's 100 % jailing BKE, Toad shows that he doesn't think his unblockable DT check is the best play in any case. Force him to jail BKE or you won't know if he's scum tomorrow.

→ FT just posted reasons for BKE to be scum without saying if we should jail him and thus check him or lynch him tomorrow. He ignored my question so far.

→ Toad protected Bugs letting Sandro die, I still don't know why he did that. He just got upset when I told him that without expanding on his reasons saying "You say I'm bad while I'm trying to save lives".
I just don't see town Toad risking the "best town player" (by his own words) to get killed.
Scum hit all right targets N1. Decide for yourself if that's a coincidence and just luck or if they knew what was up. Ockham's razor tells a story.

On January 26 2013 00:09 Toadesstern wrote:

gonna be honest. Never thought about tossing a coin and already sent in "jail BKE" 10 hours ago...
I just need the medic to listen to me and the medic knows what I'm doing so again: medic listen to everything I say, it is of utmost importance tonight that you do exactly as I say and not protect vivax.

Not even kidding.

On January 26 2013 01:35 Toadesstern wrote:

yeah I really thought about that as well and think i might be better of jailing Chez but I don't want to change everything now that I told vigs I'm jailing BKE and medics to protect you and bodyguards...

On January 26 2013 01:37 yamato77 wrote:
Adam, I am glad you've come out with a mafia read on Austin. I agree, he is fairly sketchy at times and fluffy at others. What concerns me about him is that he seemed perfectly willing to play along with Vivax and not lynch the mafia with a red check on him, which is highly suspicious to me, especially after the flip. I think Austin deserves a fair amount of scrutiny, and I am going to make sure that happens in the coming days.

While you may find Axle suspicious, I find his play this game fairly consistent with that if his town game in the one I played with him. He isn't overly involved in the conversation town is having, he comes in with his own take on something and basically ignores everything else. I don't see much reason to have a mafia read on him at this point in the game.

As for BKE, I want to ask this question to everyone: Who thinks he's not a good lynch tomorrow?

On January 26 2013 01:44 yamato77 wrote:

Maybe it is, maybe it isn't, I'm not sure if town Axle would be involved in the game enough to vote for a mayor in a manner which is indicative about his alignment.

His activity dropping off is also consistent with his town game, tbh, so I'm not worried about him. It's like you guys' read on Chezinu, there's really not much to say either way.

On January 26 2013 01:47 DearestSnot wrote:


Yeah, what's up?

Also @Vivax, I never asked Chezinu about being masoned.