Newbie Mini Mafia XXXVI - Page 3

On February 03 2013 02:19 cDgCorazon wrote:
Fine Cake, I shall rephrase.

He's trying to convince us he is not scum with an argument that, to me, does not compute. How could I possibly vote for Sn0 over him?

On February 03 2013 02:05 cakepie wrote:
Corazon, you've chosen to ignore everything I've said over the earlier part of D3.

On February 01 2013 04:00 cakepie wrote:sheep opinions that are already expressed by other players, and wagon their vote without justification.

On February 03 2013 03:49 cDgCorazon wrote:
I'm going to play the fucking game the way I want to

On February 01 2013 11:40 cakepie wrote:
I'm going to start with this and see where it takes us with regard to my two strongest scumreads.

##Vote: Slayalot
##FoS: glurio


Reason:


as well as voting patterns

On February 03 2013 02:37 Acid~ wrote:
There's not enough activity from glurio to make a case. Bottom line is, I think glurio's activity is consistent with a lazy townie. It's also consistent with scum.

On February 01 2013 10:00 cakepie wrote:
Sn0_Man: There is no way a scum Sn0 could safely claim cop when he did. I don't think we're looking at some complicated and daring scum gambit. This is more likely to be a true, goodwill attempt to prevent a Corazon mislynch.

On February 02 2013 07:15 cakepie wrote:
I'm not saying that I consider Sn0's claim to be a lie -- the claim is fairly strong. It serves as great backing evidence to go with my own reads.

On February 02 2013 07:15 cakepie wrote: it is not 100% unassailable,

On February 03 2013 06:16 Acid~ wrote:
First I want to see who/if I can get behind on a Cora lynch.

On January 30 2013 02:04 warbaby wrote:


I'd love to discuss what actually happened N1, which I see as a great win for town.

Note that there is one variation of the setup that allows for both JK and Doc (if I'm not reading the wiki wrong here -- love to see our authority on math and statistics, Acid~, to contribute on this point, but he's probably won't bother responding to this post, assuming he ever reads it).

If the blue is doc, should they claim? I don't think it was clairvoyant that nobody died N1 (and I think you sound like a sadscum by saying this), I think it was just damned lucky. Probably won't happen again, and there's a chance the Doc (if there is one) will be killed before they can do anything more useful.

If the doc exists and claims, and scum kills them, we end up with a 100% confirmed town and a no kill on Night 1. Is this good for town?

I'm not sure if this makes sense. I haven't put a lot of thought into reasons and possible results around town power role claims.

On February 01 2013 10:00 zarepath wrote:
If Sn0_Man is not killed, I really suggest that you look at his filter, and the thread leading up to his cop claim. He only cop claimed after Cora was under a lot of attack and Acid is the one who suggested that he was breadcrumbing and cop claiming before he actually cop claimed -- and his earlier posts make it seem as though he didn't know the setup blue possibilities despite bieng cop. His breadcrumbs aren't entirely justified.

And his late post seems SUPER scummy. The thing is, I can totally see and understand a scum team realizing that if they don't do something, they're pretty much done for, and they ahve to take the 1-in-3 chance (closer to 1-in-2 because there was no evidence of a JK) to cop claim. It wasn't really meditated; Acid kind of just forced him into it (incidentally), and it was worth the risk.

On February 03 2013 07:23 Sn0_Man wrote:
Immediately post-night 2, glurio comes out swinging because he knows he *has* to discredit me or he loses. He makes more in-depth posts than ever before and they are extremely tunnelled on me (admittedly mine are equally tunnelled on him). After basically blowing his cover (since his previous excuse was basically bad/lazy town), he retreats into hiding hoping the seeds of doubt he has sown blossom and grow. He has flung his shit and has no real content to provide so he resumes lurking. And over the course of this day, instead of clearing stuff up, the rest of town decides that it wants to lynch... Corazon? what is up here? There is no possible way from any perspective that corazon is the right lynch. However, cakepie's obsession with "playing the game" have resulted in more uncertainty and lack of clarity. If you choose to believe that glurio is just a lazy townie, then explain his outburst post-N2, especially how well he grasped my options as cop and how scum could abuse them to make me look scummy. He clearly had spent a ton of time thinking on it and working through the possibilities. Not really consisted with lazy town IMO, but very consistent with lurky scum.

On February 03 2013 07:23 Sn0_Man wrote:
I don't know what else to say. There is no playing left for me. I have solved the game, provided as much info to you as possible, and now I await the jury's choice.

zare unvotes, but slaylot votes on.
the four votes on warbaby are Acid, Sn0, glurio, Slayalot.

On February 01 2013 10:00 zarepath wrote:
[...]. He only cop claimed after Cora was under a lot of attack

On February 03 2013 08:41 Acid~ wrote:
I'm at a loss here.

I'll go with the strategy that won us the last game, but I really hate the implications.

On February 01 2013 22:03 glurio wrote:
Look at sn0s voting pattern and don't just cherry pick what fits your agenda.

On February 02 2013 23:38 glurio wrote:


Right. It's just as incriminating as mine or slays, which i thought cakepie should've also highlighted. So i did highlight it in a fitting color.

On February 03 2013 09:09 glurio wrote:
Sn0 has shown no single argument why i should be scum except "i figured the game out" or "thats the only possible combination".
How can you believe such weak evidence when you got so much evidence against him and cora?

On February 03 2013 09:44 Acid~ wrote:
No, that's what makes me sad. I really believe glurio is scum, which means Corazon is town. I think that's going to be it for me on the mafia games for a while.