Hero Mini Mafia - Page 86

On December 11 2012 22:30 wherebugsgo wrote:


not like it really matters, but probably:

Tunkeg
Adam
Munk-E
one of ZB/VE/you/BL

I feel very strongly that among the first 3 there are at least 2 scum. I don't think I am wrong about more than one of them, because Tunkeg + Adam in particular don't play like this as town from what I know.



I don't think mafia would so openly confront someone over a play like Djo did. His tone and willingness to question and probe is really towny to me. Ex:




He wants to find out thrawn's motivations so he votes him despite thinking that thrawn's actions were townish. I don't see many scum who are willing to put so much attention on themselves in this manner. Think about it: it opens Djo up to the "you're voting someone you have a townread on?" attack, and it's completely obvious. I'm certain scum would at the very least word their posts more carefully or not actually confront the player in such a manner at all.

Secondly, when he pushes jay as a lynch, he ACTUALLY pushes it. I don't see scum doing that either. They often don't actively try to convince people to join them in killing someone. Sure, he might be good as scum, but we then have to ask why he would be so concerned with my vote and where it's going. Things like this:



Indicate that Djo is reading the thread and at the very least concerned about people giving half-assed reasons to vote people. I didn't really have a great reason to vote Palmar and he called me out on it. Pretty townie reaction IMO.

He also doesn't let bullshit fly:



If you think Djo is scum, then you have to assume he is very very good at hiding his intentions. I just don't see scum acting the way he has acted so far.

He's also far too active IMO to be a day 1 lynch consideration.

On December 11 2012 21:58 Bluelightz wrote:
On Adam,



This caught my eye in Adam's filter, someone says "Oh Adam might be scum" he went into insta defensive mode, then he didn't address the accusation but only followed up with a counter vote. Seems strange?

On December 15 2012 01:00 VisceraEyes wrote:
LAWL

Oh man, selective humbleness. Palmar you're a treasure.

On December 15 2012 01:01 Palmar wrote:


Hi, you're such a scum aren't you?

On December 15 2012 01:02 Tunkeg wrote:


Then why the fuck aren't you voting him?

On December 15 2012 00:58 Palmar wrote:
Actually Clarity, look back on a few things about Bluelightz:

He defended debears in the Adam/BL exchange.

He made this post quite early:



The timing of his vote on Adam is very important here too:

BL was the fourth person to cast a vote on Adam. At the time Tunkeg lead with 4 votes, and Adam/Jay were tied at 3. If BL is scum it must have been a designed bus from that point on. There was no need for BL to step on the Adam wagon if he was scum right there.

In fact, I would argue his vote starts the swing to an Adam lynch.

On December 15 2012 01:07 Clarity_nl wrote:


I've addressed it in my case. That first post on Adam is like all his other commentary at the start of the game.
"Oh, this is weird", "oh, that is strange!"

Then when he has to leave and won't be back before lynch he parks his vote on Adam (which is the best decision scumwise. You won't be around to defend him so this is either a bus or a clever vote depending on if Adam gets lynched)

He votes for Adam and then he throws in "Palmar's case and my own reasons". I had to ask him for his reasons and he quoted his own post, the very post that you just showed me. Give me a break.

On December 15 2012 01:07 Palmar wrote:
If people are wondering how I'm working atm I've got like these almost certainly townies:

thrawn, clarity, bluelightz

these probably/maybe townies

marv, jay, grush

these hmm pfff hmm (need to read more on them all)

tunkeg, Z-bos, hapa

these shit tier people

VE, Vivax, Djodref

On December 15 2012 01:11 Clarity_nl wrote:


Why is grush probably town and why is hapa null? I don't agree with BL town but I'll consolidate for now and revisit it tomorrow.

##Unvote